Outage-Based Resource Allocation for DF Two-Way Relay Networks with Energy Harvesting

Huaping Liu(刘华平), Chunling Peng, Fangwei Li, Huaping Liu, Guozhong WangSensors 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of optimizing resource allocation in two-way relay networks where the relay harvests energy. They propose a novel two-step algorithm to jointly optimize power allocation and energy harvesting strategies, significantly reducing system outage probability compared to existing methods, especially in asymmetric channel conditions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Wireless communication systems are increasingly reliant on relay nodes to extend coverage and improve reliability. In two-way relay (TWR) networks, two devices exchange information via a relay. A key challenge is efficiently managing resources like transmit power and how the relay utilizes harvested energy. Traditional approaches often assume the relay has its own power source or don't optimize energy harvesting alongside power allocation. This paper addresses the problem of minimizing the system's outage probability (the chance of failing to meet desired data rates) in a decode-and-forward (DF) TWR network where the relay harvests energy from the transmitted signals using a power-splitting (PS) protocol. The goal is to find the optimal way to split the transmit power between the two source nodes and how the relay splits the received signal for energy harvesting versus information decoding, all under a total power constraint. This is particularly challenging because the problem is non-convex and involves multiple interacting parameters.

Methods

The authors propose a two-step optimization algorithm to solve the complex, non-convex problem of jointly optimizing power allocation (PA) at the source nodes and power splitting (PS) at the relay.

  1. Problem Formulation: They first formulate the problem as minimizing the system outage probability, which is then transformed into maximizing a normalized signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) metric.
  2. Two-Step Optimization:
    • Step 1: Optimal PS Ratio: For a fixed power allocation ratio ($\alpha$) between the source nodes, they derive a closed-form expression for the optimal power splitting ratio ($\rho$) at the relay. This step simplifies the problem by reducing it to a one-dimensional optimization.
  3. Step 2: Optimal PA Ratio: The derived optimal $\rho$ is then substituted back into the objective function. This results in a one-dimensional optimization problem for the power allocation ratio ($\alpha$). The authors analyze this function through various cases based on channel conditions and rate thresholds, deriving closed-form solutions for the optimal $\alpha$.
  4. Algorithm Summary: A detailed algorithm (Algorithm 1) is provided to summarize the process of computing the optimal PA and PS ratios given system parameters.

The novelty lies in the systematic two-step approach to tackle the non-convexity and derive closed-form solutions, which is more efficient than numerical search.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The evaluation relies on simulated channel realizations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Joint Optimization is Crucial: Optimizing power allocation and energy harvesting (power splitting) together is essential for minimizing outage probability, rather than treating them independently.
  • Asymmetric Channels Matter: The performance gains of the proposed scheme are more pronounced when the communication channels between the sources and the relay are asymmetric. This highlights the importance of considering channel conditions in resource allocation.
  • Relay Placement is Key: The outage probability is sensitive to the relay's position. Placing the relay closer to one of the source nodes generally leads to better performance, especially in asymmetric scenarios.
  • Two-Step Approach Effectiveness: The proposed two-step optimization method successfully breaks down a complex non-convex problem into manageable subproblems, leading to efficient closed-form solutions.

Key Results

  • The proposed jointly optimal resource allocation scheme achieves a lower system outage probability compared to three benchmark schemes (optimal $\rho$ equal $\alpha$, optimal $\alpha$ equal $\rho$, and equal $\alpha$ and $\rho$).
  • The performance improvement is particularly significant in asymmetric channel conditions.
  • The numerical results validate the analytical derivations, showing close agreement between the proposed algorithm (A1) and numerical search (NS) for outage probability.
  • The paper demonstrates that increasing the total transmit power constraint ($P_t$) consistently reduces the outage probability.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Assumptions: The paper assumes perfect channel state information (CSI) is known at all nodes, which might not always be practical in real-world scenarios. It also assumes reciprocal channels and a passive relay with a power splitting protocol.
  • Future Work: While not explicitly detailed as future work, extending this framework to scenarios with imperfect CSI, non-reciprocal channels, or different energy harvesting/power splitting protocols would be logical next steps. Investigating the impact of different network topologies or incorporating more advanced relaying strategies could also be explored.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{liu2018outage,
  author = {Huaping Liu(刘华平) and Chunling Peng and Fangwei Li and Huaping Liu and Guozhong Wang},
  title = {{Outage-Based Resource Allocation for DF Two-Way Relay Networks with Energy Harvesting}},
  journal = {Sensors},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3390/s18113946},
}
Figure