TL;DR
This paper outlines a protocol for a systematic review investigating whether discharging patients from intensive care units (ICUs) during off-hours (evenings and nights) is associated with higher in-hospital mortality or ICU readmission rates. The findings could inform critical system changes to improve patient outcomes after ICU discharge.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Patients discharged from the ICU often face a high-risk period of subsequent in-hospital mortality, accounting for a significant portion of ICU-related deaths. A particular concern is the practice of discharging patients from the ICU during "out-of-hours" periods (evenings and nights). This practice might be driven by factors like bed pressure or could lead to reduced care intensity due to fewer staff available during these times. The authors hypothesize that this out-of-hours discharge could be a contributing factor to the elevated post-ICU mortality rates, a link that has not been systematically reviewed to date. Understanding this association is crucial because out-of-hours discharge is a modifiable aspect of hospital care.
Methods
This paper details a protocol for a systematic review and meta-analysis. The review will involve two main searches: one general search for factors associated with post-ICU in-hospital mortality and a second, more focused search specifically on out-of-hours discharges. The searches will be conducted across multiple databases (Medline, Embase, Web of Knowledge, CINAHL, Cochrane Library) and will include grey literature (OpenGrey) to capture unpublished data. No language or date restrictions will be applied.
Two independent reviewers will screen articles for inclusion, first by title, then by abstract, and finally by full text. Methodological quality will be assessed using the ACROBAT-NRSI tool. The primary outcome measure is post-ICU in-hospital mortality. Studies reporting ICU readmission rates will also be included to provide a more comprehensive picture.
Data will be synthesized using a random-effects meta-analysis. Subgroup analyses are planned to explore factors such as discharge destination, palliative care discharges, and different definitions of "out-of-hours."
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The paper describes a protocol for a systematic review, which will identify and synthesize data from existing studies.
Key Insights and Ideas
- The "High-Risk Journey" Post-ICU: The paper highlights that ICU discharge isn't necessarily the end of a critical phase but rather the beginning of a period with significant in-hospital mortality risk, comparable to or exceeding mortality for entire hospital stays in some conditions.
- Out-of-Hours Discharge as a Potential Marker: The authors propose that out-of-hours discharge might serve as a marker for either premature discharge (due to resource pressures) or a reduction in the quality of care received upon transfer to a lower-level ward, both of which could negatively impact patient outcomes.
- Amenable to System Change: The core motivation for this review is that if out-of-hours discharge is indeed linked to adverse outcomes, it represents a highly actionable area for hospital system improvement.
- Need for Comprehensive Synthesis: The authors emphasize that while individual studies may touch upon out-of-hours discharge, a systematic review that synthesizes data from both general post-ICU mortality studies and those specifically examining discharge timing is needed.
Key Results
As this is a protocol for a systematic review, no results from the review itself are presented. The paper outlines the planned methodology for data collection and analysis.
Limitations and Future Work
Limitations: * Definition Variability: The authors acknowledge that a significant limitation may be the differences in how "out-of-hours" and "in-hours" are defined across studies and institutions. Similarly, definitions of discharge destinations (e.g., high dependency unit vs. ward level) may vary. * Data Quality: The review's findings will be inherently limited by the quality of the available data in the primary studies. * Bias Assessment: While the ACROBAT-NRSI tool will be used to assess within-study bias, the results of this assessment are not expected to be used to weight studies in the meta-analysis, but rather to aid in the interpretation of overall results.
Future Work: The protocol itself outlines the planned future work, which includes conducting the systematic searches, screening and data extraction, quality assessment, and meta-analysis. The planned subgroup analyses will explore specific factors influencing the association between out-of-hours discharge and mortality. The ultimate goal is to provide evidence that can inform system-level changes to improve patient care and outcomes following ICU discharge.
Summary updated