Oscillatory Neuronal Synchronization in Primary Visual Cortex as a Correlate of Stimulus Selection

Pascal Fries, Jan-Hinrich Schröder, Pieter R. Roelfsema, Wolf Singer, Andreas K. EngelJournal of Neuroscience 2002 · DOI

Abstract

Spike and local field potential activity were recorded simultaneously from multiple sites in primary visual cortex of strabismic cats, while monocular stimulation alternated with dichoptic stimulation, inducing interocular rivalry. During interocular rivalry, there is competition between the two nonfusible stimuli presented to the two eyes, and only one stimulus is selected at any time. We biased this competition in three different ways: (1) we exploited the condition that in strabismic cats there is often one dominant eye that is selected for most of the time. (2) We presented the two stimuli with a temporal offset, which biases competition in favor of the newly appearing stimulus. (3) We presented the two stimuli with highly different contrasts, which biases competition in favor of the stimulus with higher contrast. Whenever competition was biased in favor of the stimulus activating the recorded neurons, gamma-frequency synchronization of the respective responses was enhanced, and vice versa. Firing rates showed some differences between stimulation conditions. However, when present, these changes were inversely related to a competitive advantage of the respective stimulus. We hypothesize that enhanced gamma-frequency synchronization in primary visual cortex is a correlate of stimulus selection. Synchronization is likely to be translated into firing rate changes at later processing stages.

Introduction

In a complex visual environment, the brain must constantly filter competing information to select relevant stimuli for perception. A classic paradigm for studying this selection process is interocular rivalry, where conflicting images presented to each eye lead to alternating perception rather than a fused image. While higher-order cortical areas show clear activity changes corresponding to perceived stimuli, the role of the primary visual cortex (V1) has remained controversial. This study investigates whether V1 participates in stimulus selection through temporal coding—specifically, gamma-frequency synchronization—rather than simple changes in firing rates.

Methods and Experimental Design

The researchers recorded multiunit activity (MUA) and local field potentials (LFP) from the visual cortex of eight strabismic cats. Strabismic subjects are particularly useful because their V1 neurons are predominantly monocular, allowing researchers to isolate responses driven by a specific eye.

To induce and bias stimulus competition, the team used dichoptic stimulation (different images to each eye) and manipulated three factors:

  1. Eye Dominance: Utilizing the natural preference for one eye in strabismic subjects.
  2. Temporal Offset: Introducing a new stimulus to exploit the "novelty bias."
  3. Contrast Bias: Using varying contrast levels to favor one stimulus over the other.
Experimental setup and behavioral data. (A) Dichoptic stimulation setup. (B) Optokinetic Nystagmus (OKN) traces used to track stimulus selection under different contrast conditions.

The primary metric for synchronization was Spike-Field Coherence (SFC), measuring the phase-locking of individual spikes to the rhythmic gamma-band (40–70 Hz) oscillations of the local population. Behavioral selection was confirmed using Optokinetic Nystagmus (OKN), where eye movement patterns indicate which stimulus the subject is currently tracking.

Key Insights: Synchronization as a Selection Mechanism

The study revealed a consistent link between stimulus selection and neuronal synchronization. Whenever a stimulus "won" the competition—whether due to eye dominance, novelty, or higher contrast—the neurons representing that stimulus exhibited significantly enhanced gamma-frequency synchronization.

The Rate-Sync Dissociation

A critical finding was the dissociation between firing rates and synchronization. In many instances, the firing rates of neurons representing the selected stimulus did not increase; in fact, they often showed a slight decrease (e.g., a median 8% decrease during dominant-eye selection). In contrast, gamma-frequency SFC showed substantial increases:

  • Eye Dominance: +38% median increase in SFC.
  • Novelty Bias: +22% increase in SFC.
  • Contrast Bias: +75% increase in SFC.

This suggests that synchronization is an independent and primary channel for signaling stimulus selection in V1.

Discussion: Communication through Coherence

The authors propose the "Communication through Coherence" hypothesis: by synchronizing their firing, V1 neurons become more effective at driving downstream targets in higher visual areas. Much like a crowd clapping in unison is more audible than random noise, synchronized spikes are more likely to summate and trigger responses in subsequent processing stages. This mechanism allows the brain to highlight selected information without necessarily increasing the overall metabolic cost associated with higher firing rates.

Limitations and Future Directions

While the strabismic model provides a clear experimental framework, further research is needed to confirm if these mechanisms are identical in normal binocular vision. Additionally, while the study identifies synchronization in V1, future work must demonstrate the causal link between this early-stage synchrony and the firing rate changes observed in higher-order areas like V4 or IT.

Reference: Fries, P., Schröder, J. H., Roelfsema, P. R., Singer, W., & Engel, A. K. (2002). Oscillatory Neuronal Synchronization in Primary Visual Cortex as a Correlate of Stimulus Selection. The Journal of Neuroscience, 22(9), 3739–3754.

Summary updated

Abstract

Spike and local field potential activity were recorded simultaneously from multiple sites in primary visual cortex of strabismic cats, while monocular stimulation alternated with dichoptic stimulation, inducing interocular rivalry. During interocular rivalry, there is competition between the two nonfusible stimuli presented to the two eyes, and only one stimulus is selected at any time. We biased this competition in three different ways: (1) we exploited the condition that in strabismic cats there is often one dominant eye that is selected for most of the time. (2) We presented the two stimuli with a temporal offset, which biases competition in favor of the newly appearing stimulus. (3) We presented the two stimuli with highly different contrasts, which biases competition in favor of the stimulus with higher contrast. Whenever competition was biased in favor of the stimulus activating the recorded neurons, gamma-frequency synchronization of the respective responses was enhanced, and vice versa. Firing rates showed some differences between stimulation conditions. However, when present, these changes were inversely related to a competitive advantage of the respective stimulus. We hypothesize that enhanced gamma-frequency synchronization in primary visual cortex is a correlate of stimulus selection. Synchronization is likely to be translated into firing rate changes at later processing stages.
BibTeX
@article{fries2002oscillatory,
  author = {Pascal Fries and Jan-Hinrich Schröder and Pieter R. Roelfsema and Wolf Singer and Andreas K. Engel},
  title = {{Oscillatory Neuronal Synchronization in Primary Visual Cortex as a Correlate of Stimulus Selection}},
  journal = {Journal of Neuroscience},
  year = {2002},
  doi = {10.1523/jneurosci.22-09-03739.2002},
}
Figure