TL;DR
This paper proposes a novel signal design for integrated data and energy transfer (IDET) using Orthogonal-Time-Frequency-Space (OTFS) modulation, specifically designed to overcome the limitations of traditional OFDM-based systems in high-mobility scenarios. By leveraging OTFS's inherent resilience to Doppler effects, the proposed system achieves improved energy harvesting and data transmission rates compared to existing methods.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The increasing demand for energy-efficient communication in the Internet of Everything (IoE) era has led to the development of Integrated Data and Energy Transfer (IDET) systems. These systems aim to simultaneously transmit data and harvest wireless energy, enabling self-sustaining low-power devices. However, existing IDET solutions primarily rely on Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiplexing (OFDM) waveforms, which are optimized for static environments. In high-mobility scenarios, the significant Doppler offsets inherent in these environments severely degrade OFDM-based IDET performance. This paper addresses this critical gap by proposing an IDET system based on Orthogonal-Time-Frequency-Space (OTFS) modulation, which is inherently more robust to Doppler effects due to its delay-Doppler domain representation.
Methods
The core of this paper lies in the novel signal design for an OTFS-IDET system. At the transmitter, random data signals and deterministic energy signals are superimposed in the delay-Doppler (DD) domain with optimally designed amplitudes. This superimposed signal is then transformed into the time-frequency (TF) domain. At the receiver, the received signal is split in the power domain to simultaneously perform energy harvesting (EH) and data recovery.
A key technical contribution is the formulation and solution of a non-convex optimization problem. This problem aims to jointly optimize the amplitudes of the data and energy signals at the transmitter and the power splitting ratio at the receiver to maximize harvested energy while satisfying a minimum data rate requirement. The authors ingeniously transform this non-convex problem into a Geometric Programming (GP) problem through inequality relaxations, enabling the derivation of an optimal solution. The paper also details the system model, including the channel model with imperfect channel estimation and the non-linear energy harvester model.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The evaluation is based on simulations using specified parameters.
Key Insights and Ideas
- OTFS for IDET in High Mobility: The paper demonstrates that OTFS modulation is a superior choice for IDET in high-mobility scenarios compared to OFDM, primarily due to its inherent robustness against Doppler offsets.
- Joint Optimization for Performance: Optimizing signal amplitudes and power splitting ratios jointly at the transmitter and receiver is crucial for maximizing energy harvesting while ensuring reliable data transmission.
- Geometric Programming for Tractability: Transforming the complex optimization problem into a Geometric Programming problem is a clever mathematical technique that allows for efficient and optimal solution finding.
- Trade-off Between Data and Energy: The paper highlights the inherent trade-off between data rate and energy harvesting, and how the proposed system effectively manages this trade-off.
- Impact of Channel Estimation Error: While OTFS is robust, imperfect channel estimation still impacts performance, but to a lesser extent than in OFDM systems.
Key Results
- Performance Gain: The proposed OTFS-IDET system demonstrates a significant performance gain in terms of harvested energy compared to conventional OFDM-IDET systems in high-mobility scenarios. This gain increases with higher mobility speeds.
- Convergence: The optimization algorithm (Algorithm 1) is shown to converge within a reasonable number of iterations (around 7 iterations for the described ellipsoid method).
- Impact of Interference: Increasing the residual energy signal interference (represented by parameter λ) degrades the IDET performance, as expected.
- Impact of Channel Estimation Error: Performance degradation due to channel estimation error is observed, but the OTFS system remains more resilient than OFDM. For instance, with an estimation error variance of $\sigma^2 = 0.05$, the performance is worse than with $\sigma^2 = 0.01$, but still superior to OFDM.
Limitations and Future Work
- Imperfect Channel Estimation: While the paper considers imperfect channel estimation, further investigation into more advanced channel estimation techniques for OTFS-IDET could yield even better results.
- Practical Pulse Shaping: The paper acknowledges that practical pulse shapes of OTFS can introduce inter-carrier and inter-symbol interference, which were not considered in this model but are a direction for future work.
- Multiple Users and MIMO: The current system considers a single transmitter-receiver pair. Extending the framework to multiple users and Multiple-Input Multiple-Output (MIMO) scenarios would be a valuable next step.
- Complexity: While the GP transformation aids in finding a solution, the computational complexity of the ellipsoid method is still significant, and exploring more efficient optimization techniques could be beneficial.
Summary updated