Orthogonal Chirp-Division Multiplexing for Power Line Sensing via Time-Domain Reflectometry

Lucas Giroto de Oliveira, Mateus de L. Filomeno, H. Vincent Poor, Moisés V. RibeiroIEEE Sensors Journal 2019 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

This study proposes a distributed power line sensing system based on Orthogonal Chirp-Division Multiplexing (OCDM) and Time-Domain Reflectometry (TDR). By leveraging the convolution theorem of the modified discrete Fresnel transform (DFnT), the authors introduce a multiple access scheme that enables simultaneous reflectometric and transferometric sensing across multiple power line modems (PLMs). The system's performance is evaluated in terms of range resolution, maximum unambiguous range, measurement density, and signal-to-interference-plus-noise ratio (SINR). Numerical results demonstrate that the OCDM-based approach maintains a high measurement frequency regardless of the number of modems, providing a significant advantage over traditional time-division and code-division multiple access schemes while ensuring fair performance across the network.

Introduction

Maintaining the health of modern power grids requires continuous monitoring to detect "soft" faults, such as cable degradation or high-impedance faults, which can lead to catastrophic failure if left unaddressed. Time-Domain Reflectometry (TDR) is a standard technique for this purpose, involving the injection of signals into the line and the analysis of their reflections. However, implementing TDR in a distributed manner across an entire network is challenging due to interference between multiple sensing units. Existing Orthogonal Frequency-Division Multiplexing (OFDM) solutions often face trade-offs between measurement frequency and performance consistency across different frequency bands.

System Model and OCDM-Based Sensing

The proposed system utilizes a baseband version of OCDM, which replaces the Discrete Fourier Transform (DFT) used in OFDM with the Discrete Fresnel Transform (DFnT). Specifically, a Modified DFnT (Type III) is employed to ensure the generated signals are real-valued, making them compatible with baseband power line communication (PLC) systems.

To enable multiple access without interference, the authors propose a "subchirp allocation" scheme in the Fresnel domain. Instead of separating modems by time or frequency, they are assigned orthogonal subchirps. This allows the system to perform both reflectometry (analyzing reflections) and transferometry (analyzing signals between modems) simultaneously.

Subchirp allocation scheme for multiple access in the Fresnel domain.

Performance Analysis and Key Results

The study evaluates the OCDM-based TDR system using numerical simulations of typical European low-voltage (LV) and US medium-voltage (MV) power distribution networks.

Measurement Density

A primary advantage of the OCDM scheme is its ability to maintain a constant, high number of measurements (snapshots) per second as more modems are added to the network. In contrast, Time-Division Multiple Access (TDMA) and Code-Division Multiple Access (CDMA) schemes see a sharp decline in measurement frequency as the number of PLMs ($N_{PLM}$) increases. For a network with 10 modems, OCDM provides approximately ten times more reflectograms per second than TDMA.

Comparison of measurement frequency ($N_\rho$) across different multiple access schemes as the number of modems ($N_{PLM}$) increases.

Fairness and Resolution

In frequency-division (FDMA) schemes, modems assigned to higher frequencies often suffer from increased attenuation and noise. Because OCDM spreads chirps across the entire available bandwidth, every modem experiences the same average channel conditions. This results in a "fair" and stable SINR across the network—measured at 14.85 dB in a Brazilian MV scenario, compared to the fluctuating 13.83–16.04 dB range seen in FDMA. Furthermore, OCDM achieves the same range resolution as OFDM-based systems, as resolution is fundamentally determined by the signal bandwidth ($B$).

Sensing Range

The maximum unambiguous range for reflectometry was calculated to be approximately 1.87 km for LV scenarios and 3.21 km for MV scenarios (with a cyclic prefix of 30). However, the authors noted that this range is more sensitive to the measurement window length in OCDM than in TDMA; as more modems are added, the effective window for each modem shrinks, which can eventually limit the maximum detectable distance.

Conclusion

The proposed OCDM-based multiple access scheme offers a robust solution for distributed power line sensing. By providing high measurement density and fair performance across all network modems without sacrificing spatial resolution, it outperforms traditional TDMA and CDMA approaches. Future work will focus on experimental validation using physical PLC hardware and the development of data fusion techniques to integrate high-density measurements into comprehensive grid health maps.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this study, a time-domain reflectometry (TDR) system based on the orthogonal chirp-division multiplexing (OCDM) scheme is proposed for power line sensing. After the system model description, a multiple access scheme that exploits the convolution theorem of the modified discrete Fresnel transform for enabling distributed reflectometric and transferometric power line sensing is introduced. Next, the effects of the parametrization of the proposed OCDM-based TDR system on range resolution and maximum unambiguous range are assessed. A comparison with multiple access schemes based on the Hermitian symmetric orthogonal frequency-division multiplexing (HS-OFDM) is then performed, being the number of measurements obtained over time and signal-to-interference-plus-noise ratio (SINR) used as performance metrics. Numerical results show that the proposed multiple access scheme achieves the highest number of measurements over time, besides yielding the same range resolution as the HS-OFDM-based counterparts. Finally, the proposed multiple access scheme is slightly outperformed by the HS-OFDM based on code-division multiple access and by the HS-OFDM based on frequency-division multiple access at some power line modems (PLMs) consisting the distributed sensing system, although its yielded SINR values at distinct PLMs are at a same level.
BibTeX
@article{oliveira2019orthogonal,
  author = {Lucas Giroto de Oliveira and Mateus de L. Filomeno and H. Vincent Poor and Moisés V. Ribeiro},
  title = {{Orthogonal Chirp-Division Multiplexing for Power Line Sensing via Time-Domain Reflectometry}},
  journal = {IEEE Sensors Journal},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1109/jsen.2019.2932994},
}

Loading related content...

Figure