Origin of Small Barriers in Jahn–Teller Systems: Quantifying the Role of 3d–4s Hybridization in the Model System NaCl:Ni+

M. T. Barriuso, B. Ortiz-Sevilla, J. A. Aramburu, Pablo García‐Fernández, J. M. García‐Lastra, M. MorenoInorganic 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the microscopic origin of the energy barrier in Jahn-Teller (JT) systems, specifically focusing on the NaCl:Ni⁺ model. They discover that the unusually small barrier in this system is a result of a delicate balance between 3d-4s hybridization favoring an elongated geometry and anharmonicity favoring a compressed one, a finding crucial for understanding JT system behavior.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Jahn-Teller (JT) effect describes how certain transition metal ions in symmetrical environments can distort their surrounding ligands to lower their electronic energy. This distortion leads to different possible geometries (e.g., compressed or elongated octahedra), which are separated by an energy barrier. Understanding the origin and magnitude of this barrier is crucial for predicting material properties, especially in cases where the JT effect leads to dynamic behavior (tunneling between geometries) or static behavior (fixed geometry due to random strains).

However, the precise microscopic origins of these energy barriers are not fully understood, particularly for systems with unusually small barriers. This paper tackles this challenge by studying NaCl:Ni⁺, a system known for its experimentally observed small barrier, which is significantly lower than in similar JT systems with d⁹ or d⁷ ions. The authors aim to quantitatively explain why this barrier is so small and what factors contribute to it.

Methods

The researchers employed a combination of ab initio calculations, a computational approach that solves the electronic structure of a system from first principles without empirical parameters. They utilized two main computational strategies:

  • Periodic Calculations: Using the CRYSTAL09 package, they modeled the NaCl:Ni⁺ system as a periodic crystal lattice with the Ni⁺ ion replacing a Na⁺ ion. This approach captures the influence of the entire crystal environment. They explored various exchange-correlation functionals (LDA, GGA, and hybrid functionals) and basis sets to ensure the robustness of their results.
  • Cluster Calculations: They also used the Amsterdam Density Functional (ADF) code to model finite clusters of NaCl:Ni⁺. This method allows for more detailed analysis of the local electronic environment around the Ni⁺ ion and helps isolate specific interactions. They employed different cluster sizes and functionals for comparison.

A key aspect of their analysis involved examining the energy dependence on the distortion coordinate (Qe), which describes the degree of tetragonal distortion. By analyzing how the energies of the A₁g and B₁g electronic states change with Qe, they could dissect the contributions of various physical mechanisms to the energy barrier.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on ab initio calculations performed on the model system NaCl:Ni⁺, rather than on pre-existing experimental datasets for training. Experimental data for NaCl:Ni⁺ (e.g., EPR spectra) and related systems (e.g., NaCl:Rh²⁺, NaCl:Ag²⁺) were used for comparison and validation of their theoretical findings.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Competing Forces: The small barrier in NaCl:Ni⁺ isn't due to a single dominant factor but rather a delicate interplay between two opposing forces:
  • 3d-4s Hybridization: This interaction favors an elongated geometry for the NiCl₆⁵⁻ complex.
  • Anharmonicity: The inherent non-linearity in the vibrational modes of the NiCl₆⁵⁻ complex favors a compressed geometry.
  • Dominance of Hybridization: Crucially, the 3d-4s hybridization's contribution to favoring elongation is slightly larger than the anharmonicity's contribution to compression. This explains the observed elongated geometry.
  • Elastically Coupled System: Unlike some other JT systems (like NaCl:Rh²⁺) where the impurity complex is elastically decoupled from the host lattice, NaCl:Ni⁺ is more elastically coupled. This difference significantly impacts the anharmonic contribution.
  • Tunneling Splitting: The calculated tunneling splitting (3Γ) is estimated to be very small (< 9 cm⁻¹), which explains why random strains in real crystals readily destroy coherence, leading to the experimentally observed static JT effect rather than a dynamic one.
  • Importance of Small Distortions: The study emphasizes that understanding JT barriers requires considering even subtle changes in electronic density that occur during small distortions, a factor often overlooked.

Key Results

  • Small Barrier: All calculations consistently yielded a small energy barrier, |B| ≤ 160 cm⁻¹, significantly lower than values for similar systems like NaCl:Rh²⁺ (B = 511 cm⁻¹) or NaCl:Ag²⁺ (B = 500 cm⁻¹).
  • Elongated Geometry: The calculations confirmed that the equilibrium geometry for NaCl:Ni⁺ is elongated, consistent with experimental observations.
  • Quantitative Contribution: The 3d-4s vibronic admixture was quantitatively shown to be the primary driver for the elongated geometry, outweighing the anharmonic contribution that favors compression.
  • d-d Transition Energies: The calculated d-d transition energies for NiCl₆⁵⁻ were found to be significantly smaller than those for CuCl₆⁴⁻, highlighting the unique electronic structure of Ni⁺.
  • Optical Electronegativity: The optical electronegativity of Ni⁺ was estimated to be around 1, which is notably lower than for divalent transition metal ions.
  • g-tensor Explanation: The calculated results reasonably explain the experimental g-tensor values for NaCl:Ni⁺.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Experimental Data for Tunneling: While the study estimates the tunneling splitting (3Γ), direct experimental measurements for this specific value in NaCl:Ni⁺ are lacking, making direct comparison challenging.
  • Complexity of Real Systems: The study focuses on a model system. While it provides fundamental insights, applying these findings to more complex real-world materials might require further investigation.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that further work along these lines is underway, implying continued exploration of JT systems and their underlying mechanisms. They also highlight the importance of ab initio calculations for providing detailed insights into the subtle origins of equilibrium geometries in JT systems, which can help avoid unnecessary speculation in theoretical models.

Summary updated

Abstract

Despite its relevance, the microscopic origin of the energy barrier, B, between the compressed and elongated geometries of Jahn-Teller (JT) systems is not well understood yet because of a lack of quantitative data about its various contributions. Seeking to clear up this matter, we have carried out both periodic and cluster ab initio calculations on the model system NaCl:Ni(+). This system is particularly puzzling because, according to experimental data, its barrier is much smaller than that for other d(9) and d(7) ions in similar lattices. All calculations performed on the model system lead, in fact, to values |B| ≤ 160 cm(-1), which are certainly smaller than B = 500 cm(-1) derived for NaCl:M(2+) (M = Ag, Rh) or B = 1024 cm(-1) obtained for KCl:Ag(2+). As a salient feature, analysis of calculations carried out as a function of the Qθ (∼3z(2) - r(2)) coordinate unveils the microscopic origin of the barrier. It is quantitatively proven that the elongated geometry observed for NaCl:Ni(+) is due to the 3d-4s vibronic admixture, which is slightly larger than the anharmonicity in the eg JT mode that favors a compressed geometry. The existence of these two competing mechanisms explains the low value of B for the model system, contrary to cases where the complex formed by d(9) or d(7) ions is elastically decoupled from the host lattice. Although the magnitude of B for NaCl:Ni(+) is particularly small, the tunneling splitting, 3Γ, is estimated to be below 9 cm(-1), thus explaining why the coherence is easily destroyed by random strains and thus a static JT effect is observed experimentally. As a main conclusion, the barrier in JT systems cannot be understood neglecting the tiny changes of the electronic density involved in small distortions. The present calculations reasonably explain the experimental g tensor of NaCl:Ni(+), pointing out that the d-d transitions in NiCl6(5-) are much smaller than those for CuCl6(4-) and the optical electronegativity of Ni(+) is only around 1.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{barriuso2013origin,
  author = {M. T. Barriuso and B. Ortiz-Sevilla and J. A. Aramburu and Pablo García‐Fernández and J. M. García‐Lastra and M. Moreno},
  title = {{Origin of Small Barriers in Jahn–Teller Systems: Quantifying the Role of 3d–4s Hybridization in the Model System NaCl:Ni<sup>+</sup>}},
  booktitle = {Inorganic},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1021/ic4009009},
}
Figure