Origin of Orthogonality of Strain‐Promoted Click Reactions

J. Wagner, Davide Mercadante, Ivana Nikić, Edward A. Lemke, Frauke GräterChemistry 2015 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper delves into the "why" behind the varying speeds of strain-promoted click reactions, crucial for labeling biomolecules. By combining quantum chemistry with experimental data, they reveal that the seemingly minor "handles" used to attach labels can fundamentally alter reaction mechanisms, even flipping them from inverse to normal electron demand. This insight is key to designing more precise and orthogonal bio-labeling tools.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The field of bio-labeling relies heavily on "click reactions" – highly selective and bioorthogonal chemical reactions that can occur within living systems without interfering with natural processes. Strain-promoted click reactions, particularly those involving strained rings like cyclooctynes and tetrazines, are popular due to their speed and efficiency. However, their reactivity can vary significantly, even between closely related molecules. This variability makes it challenging to predict and control reaction outcomes, especially when trying to label multiple biomolecules simultaneously with different colors. While previous studies have explored these reactions, they often used highly simplified reactants. This paper addresses the critical gap of understanding how the actual "handles" – the functional groups used to attach labels or link to biomolecules – influence the reaction's fundamental electronic properties and, consequently, its speed and selectivity.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Quantum Chemistry Calculations: They used density functional theory (DFT), specifically the M06-2X functional with a 6-311+G(d,p) basis set, to systematically compute the energies of various reactant conformations, van der Waals complexes, and transition states. This allowed them to determine activation energies ($E_{act}$) for a comprehensive set of reactions.
  • Experimental Rate Measurements: They measured the experimental reaction rates ($k$) for a subset of these reactions using stopped-flow spectroscopy.
  • Correlation Analysis: They established a correlation between the calculated activation energies and the experimentally determined reaction rates to validate their computational models.
  • Frontier Molecular Orbital (FMO) Analysis: They analyzed the energy differences between frontier molecular orbitals (Δ$E_{FMO}$) of interacting reactants to understand the electronic driving forces behind the reactions.
  • Distortion Energy Analysis: They quantified the energy required to distort the reactants into their transition state geometries ($E_{dist}$), recognizing that this strain is a key factor in these reactions.

A novel aspect of their methodology was defining activation energy relative to the van der Waals complex rather than the isolated reactants. This approach accounts for the significant role of these pre-reaction complexes, especially in fast reactions where isolated reactant energies might be misleading.

Datasets

The paper does not introduce new benchmark datasets. Instead, it utilizes a set of 15 experimentally measured reaction rates for various combinations of strained cyclooctynes (TCO*e/a, SCO, BCNendo/exo) and azides/tetrazines (n-propyl azide, 3-benzyl tetrazine (H-Tet), and 3-benzyl-6-methyl tetrazine (Me-Tet)). These experimental data were used to validate the computational models.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Handles are Not Just Passive Linkers: The most significant finding is that the functional groups (handles) attached to the click reaction partners are not merely passive connectors. They actively influence the reaction's electronic nature and kinetics.
  • Challenging the Inverse Electron Demand Paradigm: The study challenges the long-held assumption that all strain-promoted inverse electron demand Diels-Alder (SPIEDAC) reactions behave similarly. They found that certain cyclooctyne derivatives, when functionalized with specific handles, can switch to a normal electron demand mechanism.
  • Introducing SPINEDAC: They coined the term "SPINEDAC" (strain-promoted inherently normal electron demand Diels-Alder cycloaddition) to describe these newly identified normal electron demand reactions.
  • Electron Demand is Tunable: The electronic properties of the handles can tune the electron demand of the reaction. For example, the electrophilic nature of the SCO cyclooctyne, influenced by its carbamate handle, can drive a reaction towards normal electron demand.
  • Distortion vs. Electronic Effects: Both distortion energies (the strain required to reach the transition state) and frontier molecular orbital energy gaps are critical determinants of reaction speed. The interplay between these factors dictates the overall reactivity.
  • Regioselectivity and Stereochemistry Matter: The isomeric configuration of the handles (e.g., axial vs. equatorial) and their orientation relative to the reactive centers significantly impact reaction rates and regioselectivity.

Key Results

  • Strong Correlation: A high correlation ($R^2 = 0.89$) was found between calculated activation energies and experimental reaction rates, validating the computational approach.
  • SPINEDAC Identification: They identified specific reactions, particularly those involving SCO and tetrazines, that exhibit normal electron demand, a departure from the typical inverse electron demand observed in SPIEDAC reactions.
  • Handle Influence on Reactivity: The methyl group on Me-Tet and the carbamate handle on SCO were shown to introduce significant steric hindrance, increasing distortion penalties and slowing down reactions. Conversely, the axial carbamate on TCO*a enhances its electrophilicity, leading to faster reactions.
  • Predictive Power: The study provides a framework for predicting how modifications to handles can alter reaction kinetics and electron demand, enabling rational design of new click chemistries.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Simplifications: While the study included handles, it still used simplified versions of the actual biomolecule attachment points. The full complexity of attaching large biomolecules might introduce further steric and electronic effects not fully captured.
  • Experimental Scope: While 15 reactions were measured, the study focused on a specific set of reactants. Expanding the experimental validation to a wider range of functionalized molecules would be beneficial.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that further modifications to electron-donating/withdrawing groups on both the tetrazines and cyclooctynes, while minimizing steric hindrance, could be used to fine-tune reactivity for specific applications. They also emphasize the need to consider these structural features when designing new click chemistries for biological labeling. The ability to switch between inverse and normal electron demand based on subtle chemical changes highlights the importance of careful design and computational prediction.

Summary updated

Abstract

Site-specific labeling of biomolecules is rapidly advancing due to the discovery of novel mutually orthogonal reactions. Quantum chemistry studies have also increased our understanding of their relative rates, although these have until now been based on highly simplified reactants. Here we examine a set of strain-promoted click-type cycloaddition reactions of n-propyl azide, 3-benzyl tetrazine and 3-benzyl-6-methyl tetrazine with cyclooctenes/ynes, in which we aim to address all relevant structural details of the reactants. Our calculations have included the obligatory handles used to attach the label and biomolecule as these can critically influence the stereochemistry and electron demand of the reaction. We systematically computed orbital gaps, activation and distortion energies using density functional theory and determined experimental rates for validation. Our results challenge the current paradigm of the inverse electron demand for this class of reactions. We found that the ubiquitous handles, when next to the triple bond of cyclooctynes, can switch the Diels-Alder type ligations to normal electron demand, a class we term as SPINEDAC reactions. Electron donating substituents on tetrazine can enhance normal demand but also increase distortion penalties. The presence and isomeric configuration of handles thus determine the reaction speed and regioselectivity. Our findings can be directly utilized in engineering genuine cycloaddition click chemistries for biological labeling.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wagner2015origin,
  author = {J. Wagner and Davide Mercadante and Ivana Nikić and Edward A. Lemke and Frauke Gräter},
  title = {{Origin of Orthogonality of Strain‐Promoted Click Reactions}},
  booktitle = {Chemistry},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1002/chem.201501727},
}
Figure