Organization, programme and structure: an analysis of the Chinese innovation policy framework

Can Huang, Celeste Varum, Mark Spinoglio, Luís Borges Gouveia, Augusto MedinaR 2004 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper analyzes China's innovation policy framework by comparing it to OECD countries, identifying strengths and weaknesses. It highlights that while China has made strides, areas like education, human resources, and intellectual property rights (IPR) require significant improvement to foster a more robust innovation system.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the challenge of understanding and evaluating China's rapidly evolving innovation policy. As China transitioned from a planned economy to a market-oriented one, its innovation policy underwent significant changes. The authors aim to dissect this complex system, identify its key components, and assess its effectiveness by benchmarking it against established innovation leaders in OECD countries. This is crucial for understanding China's current innovation landscape and its future trajectory.

Methods

The study employs a comparative analysis approach. It first identifies the stakeholders involved in China's innovation policy design and implementation and then compares them with government systems in selected OECD countries. The authors then examine China's innovation policy across five key categories:

  1. Reform in public S&T institutions: How China's science and technology institutions have been restructured.
  2. Financial policy: The mechanisms used to fund S&T activities.
  3. Business innovation support structure: The systems in place to foster business innovation.
  4. Human resource policy: Measures to develop and attract talent.
  5. Legislative actions: The legal framework supporting innovation.

This framework is used to identify China's strengths and weaknesses, with a particular focus on education/human resources and IPR protection for deeper analysis.

Datasets

The paper does not introduce new datasets. Instead, it relies on existing data and reports from various sources, including:

  • OECD and European Commission reports on innovation policy.
  • Statistical data from Chinese government ministries and agencies (e.g., Ministry of Science and Technology, Chinese Academy of Sciences).
  • Academic literature and research papers on innovation systems and policy.
  • International databases and yearbooks (e.g., World Education Indicators, OECD Science Technology Industry Scoreboard).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Coordinated but Fragmented Efforts: China has a multi-dimensional approach to innovation policy, involving numerous government bodies. However, the paper suggests that these efforts can sometimes be uncoordinated, leading to a lack of synergy.
  • OECD as a Benchmark: The OECD countries serve as a valuable reference point, highlighting areas where China's policy framework is still developing or less effective.
  • Education and Human Capital Bottleneck: Despite progress, China's education system and human resource development are identified as significant weaknesses. Unbalanced development between regions and the persistent issue of illiteracy pose long-term challenges to innovation.
  • IPR Protection: A Work in Progress: While China has made rapid progress in IPR legislation, enforcement and the overall legal environment still require substantial improvement to truly foster innovation and attract foreign investment.
  • The "Economic Rationalism" Dilemma: Reforms in education, driven by "Economic Rationalism," have led to decentralization but have not necessarily increased public investment in education proportionally, exacerbating regional disparities.

Key Results

The paper identifies several weak components in China's innovation policy framework, particularly in:

  • Education and initial/further training: China lags behind OECD averages in key education indicators.
  • Fostering innovation in enterprises (especially SMEs): While efforts are being made, the support structures are not yet fully developed.
  • Public authorities and support to innovation policy-makers: The coordination and effectiveness of these bodies are questioned.
  • Protection of intellectual and industrial property: Despite legislative advancements, enforcement and awareness remain challenges.
  • Innovation financing: While various funding mechanisms exist, their effectiveness and coordination are areas for improvement.
  • Cooperation between research, universities, and companies: Intensifying this collaboration is seen as crucial.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge their "unavoidable limited knowledge about the policy design and implementation in a country like China." They emphasize that their comparative analysis is tentative and encourages further rigorous analysis.

Future work suggested by the paper includes:

  • Prioritizing Education: China's education system needs to be a top priority for government budget allocation and outlays.
  • Strengthening IPR Regimes: A long-term strategy is needed to enhance legal and administrative regimes for IPR protection, especially at the local level, potentially adopting a "Rigorous Policy for IPR Protection."
  • Addressing Policy Coherence: Future efforts should focus on improving the coherence and mutual support among different policy actions to enhance the overall effectiveness of China's innovation system.

Summary updated

Abstract

The paper first identifies the stakeholders involved in the design and implementation of China's innovation policy and compares them with different government systems in selected Organization for Economic Co‐operation and Development (OECD) countries. In order to disclose the relative strength and weaknesses inside China's innovation policy framework, we proceed to utilize policy practices in the OECD countries as a guideline to examine China's innovation policy in five categories: reform in the public S&T institutions, financial policy, business innovation support structure, human resource policy and legislative actions. Subsequently, several weak components of the Chinese innovation policy framework are identified and two of them are selected for further analysis: education and human resource policy, and protection of Intellectual Property Rights (IPR). Finally, the paper provides some priorities and possible actions for future innovation policy developments in China.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{huang2004organization,
  author = {Can Huang and Celeste Varum and Mark Spinoglio and Luís Borges Gouveia and Augusto Medina},
  title = {{Organization, programme and structure: an analysis of the Chinese innovation policy framework}},
  booktitle = {R},
  year = {2004},
  doi = {10.1111/j.1467-9310.2004.00347.x},
}
Figure