Organic waste to biohydrogen: A critical review from technological development and environmental impact analysis perspective

Hailin Tian, Jie Li, Miao Yan, Yen Wah Tong, Chi‐Hwa Wang, Xiaonan WangApplied Energy 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper provides a comprehensive review of technologies for converting organic waste into biohydrogen, focusing on both their technological feasibility and environmental impact. It highlights gasification as the most studied technology, but also emphasizes the need for further research into microbial electrolysis cells (MECs) and the importance of life cycle assessments (LCAs) to truly understand the sustainability of these biohydrogen production methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The world faces a dual challenge: a growing demand for energy and an ever-increasing amount of waste. Traditional energy sources, primarily fossil fuels, contribute significantly to greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions and environmental pollution. This paper addresses the urgent need for sustainable energy solutions by exploring biohydrogen production from organic waste. Biohydrogen offers a clean energy alternative with the added benefit of waste management. However, various technologies exist for this conversion, each with its own set of advantages, disadvantages, and environmental implications. This review aims to critically assess these technologies, providing a consolidated view of their current state and future potential.

Methods

This paper is a critical review, meaning it synthesizes and analyzes existing research rather than presenting new experimental data. The authors systematically reviewed a vast body of literature on biohydrogen production from organic waste, focusing on three main technological pathways:

  • Biological Fermentation: This includes dark fermentation and photo fermentation, which utilize microorganisms to break down organic matter and produce hydrogen.
  • Thermochemical Gasification: This process converts organic waste into syngas (a mixture of hydrogen, carbon monoxide, etc.) at high temperatures.
  • Microbial Electrolysis Cells (MECs): These are electrochemical systems that use microorganisms to convert organic matter into hydrogen.

The review critically examines the technological development, operational parameters, and environmental impacts (primarily through Life Cycle Assessment - LCA) of these technologies.

Datasets

Not applicable, as this is a review paper synthesizing existing research.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Gasification is King (in research volume): Gasification has attracted the most research attention among the reviewed technologies, likely due to its versatility in handling various waste types and its relatively fast decomposition process.
  • MECs are the Underdogs (in research): Microbial Electrolysis Cells (MECs) are the least studied, indicating a significant gap in research and development for this promising technology.
  • Waste Composition Matters: The chemical composition of the waste feedstock, particularly carbohydrate content, significantly influences hydrogen yield in fermentation. Lipids and proteins play a less significant role.
  • Pretreatment is Crucial for Lignocellulose: Lignocellulosic materials, common in agricultural waste, are difficult for bacteria to break down, necessitating pretreatment to improve hydrogen production efficiency.
  • Co-fermentation Synergies: Combining different waste types in fermentation can lead to synergistic effects, resulting in higher hydrogen yields than using single waste types.
  • Gasification's Environmental Edge (on paper): LCA studies suggest that waste gasification generally has a better environmental profile compared to other technologies, particularly in terms of GHG emissions.
  • LCA Robustness is Lacking: A significant number of LCA studies reviewed suffer from a lack of sensitivity and uncertainty analysis, questioning the robustness of their conclusions and highlighting the need for higher-quality LCAs.
  • Integration is the Future: The limitations of individual technologies (e.g., low yield in dark fermentation, complexity in photo fermentation and MECs) suggest that integrated systems combining different approaches (e.g., dark fermentation followed by MEC) may offer the most promising path forward.

Key Results

  • Research Trends: Over the past decade, research in biohydrogen production has shown an increasing trend. Gasification is the most studied technology, followed by biological fermentation, with MECs being the least researched.
  • Feedstock Diversity: A wide range of organic wastes have been investigated, including wastewater, agricultural waste, food waste, sewage sludge, municipal solid waste, wood waste, and plastics.
  • Technology Maturity: Gasification is considered the most mature technology, followed by fermentation, while MECs are the least mature.
  • GHG Emissions: Waste gasification generally shows lower GHG emissions compared to fermentation, MECs, and conventional hydrogen production methods like natural gas steam reforming.
  • LCA Quality: The majority of reviewed LCA studies have low quality due to insufficient sensitivity and uncertainty analysis.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations:

  • LCA Robustness: The paper strongly emphasizes that many existing LCA studies lack the rigor of sensitivity and uncertainty analysis, limiting the reliability of their conclusions.
  • Scale-Up Challenges: While pilot-scale demonstrations exist for some technologies, full-scale commercialization is still limited, especially for MECs.
  • Complexity of MECs: MEC technology faces challenges related to the cost of catalysts and membranes, electrode material performance, and the stability of hydrogen production over long-term operation.
  • Gasification Byproducts: Gasification produces complex syngas compositions and byproducts, necessitating further steps for reforming and purification, which adds to the overall cost and complexity.

Future Work:

  • Integrated Systems: Further research is needed on integrating different technologies (e.g., dark fermentation with MECs or anaerobic digestion) to leverage their complementary strengths.
  • Optimization of Operational Parameters: Continued optimization of parameters like temperature, pH, hydraulic retention time, and catalyst selection is crucial for all technologies.
  • Genetic Engineering: Modifying microorganisms through genetic engineering to enhance hydrogen yield and rate, and overcome limitations like low conversion efficiency, is a promising area.
  • Cheap and Effective Catalysts: Development of cost-effective and durable catalysts is essential for both gasification and MEC technologies.
  • Fundamental Microbial Research: Deeper understanding of microbial communities and their working mechanisms in biohydrogen production processes is needed, aided by advancements in biotechnology like high-throughput sequencing.
  • High-Quality LCAs: More rigorous LCA studies with comprehensive sensitivity and uncertainty analyses are required to accurately assess the sustainability of these technologies.
  • Scale-Up Studies: Research focusing on scaling up these technologies from laboratory to pilot and commercial scales is critical for their practical implementation.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{tian2019organic,
  author = {Hailin Tian and Jie Li and Miao Yan and Yen Wah Tong and Chi‐Hwa Wang and Xiaonan Wang},
  title = {{Organic waste to biohydrogen: A critical review from technological development and environmental impact analysis perspective}},
  booktitle = {Applied Energy},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1016/j.apenergy.2019.113961},
}
Figure