ORF1a of highly pathogenic PRRS attenuated vaccine virus plays a key role in neutralizing antibody induction in piglets and virus neutralization in vitro

Chaoliang Leng, Wuchao Zhang, Hongliang Zhang, Yunchao Kan, Lunguang Yao, Hongyue Zhai, Mingliang Li, Zhen Li, Chunxiao Liu, Tongqing An, Jinmei Peng, Qian Wang, Yumin Leng, Xuehui Cai, Zhi‐Jun Tian, Guangzhi TongVirology 2017 · DOI

Porcine Reproductive and Respiratory Syndrome (PRRS) remains one of the most significant economic burdens on the global swine industry. While attenuated live vaccines are used, their efficacy in inducing neutralizing antibodies (NAs) varies significantly between strains. This study investigates the genetic determinants of NA induction by comparing two vaccine strains: the highly immunogenic HuN4-F112 and the poorly immunogenic CH-1R.

Traditionally, research into PRRSV neutralization has focused on structural proteins encoded by ORF2–7. However, this study reveals that the ORF1a region, which encodes non-structural proteins (NSPs), plays a critical role in triggering a protective immune response.

Methodology: Swapping the Viral Machinery

To identify the genomic regions responsible for inducing NAs, the researchers employed reverse genetics to create six chimeric viruses. They swapped three major genomic segments between the HuN4-F112 (high NA) and CH-1R (low NA) backbones:

  1. 5’UTR + ORF1a (NSP1–8)
  2. ORF1b (NSP9–12)
  3. ORF2–7 + 3’UTR (Structural proteins)
Schematic representation of PRRSV genomic RNA and the construction of chimeric full-length plasmids and rescued viruses.

These chimeric constructs were transfected into MARC-145 cells to "rescue" the live viruses. The successful replication of all parental and chimeric strains was confirmed via immunofluorescence assays (IFA) targeting the viral N protein.

Immunofluorescence assay (IFA) confirming the rescue of parental and chimeric PRRSV strains in MARC-145 cells.

The rescued viruses were then tested in a longitudinal study involving 33 PRRSV-free Bama piglets to evaluate their ability to induce NAs and their replication kinetics in vivo.

Key Insights: Challenging the Structural Dogma

The study yielded several groundbreaking insights into PRRSV immunology:

  • ORF1a is the Primary Driver: The most significant finding was that the presence of the HuN4-F112 ORF1a region was the primary predictor of high NA titers. Piglets inoculated with viruses containing this region reached NA titers >45, whereas those without it remained below 10.
  • A New Neutralization Region: This research provides the first definitive evidence that ORF1a contains a "neutralization region," challenging the long-held belief that only structural proteins (ORF2-7) are targets for neutralizing antibodies.
  • NSP2 as a Likely Candidate: Within the ORF1a region, NSP2 is highlighted as a likely candidate for these effects. Recent evidence suggests NSP2 may be a structural component of the virion, explaining its role in antibody-mediated neutralization.
  • Replication vs. Immunogenicity: While all genomic fragments influenced in vitro replication speed, faster replication did not necessarily equate to a stronger immune response in vivo, suggesting that immunogenicity is tied to specific viral components rather than just viral load.

Results and Future Directions

  • Seroconversion Speed: Viruses carrying the HuN4 ORF1a induced detectable antibodies within 2 weeks, compared to 4+ weeks for other variants.
  • Cross-Neutralization: Sera from piglets vaccinated with HuN4-based ORF1a strains showed superior cross-neutralization capabilities against various chimeric variants.

Limitations

While the study successfully narrowed the search for NA-inducing elements to the ORF1a region, this region is large, encoding ten different non-structural proteins. The specific epitopes or amino acid sequences responsible for the observed immunogenicity remain to be identified.

Future Work

Future work will focus on "fine-mapping" ORF1a to pinpoint the exact proteins (likely NSP2) and sequences involved. These findings pave the way for developing next-generation "designer" vaccines that are optimized for high neutralizing antibody production, offering better protection against highly pathogenic PRRSV strains.

Summary updated

Abstract

The 5'UTR + ORF1a region of HuN4-F112 played a key role in inducing NAs in piglets. Furthermore, we confirmed for the first time that ORF1a contains a neutralization region. This study provides important information that can be used for further study of the generation of anti-PRRSV NAs.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{leng2017orf,
  author = {Chaoliang Leng and Wuchao Zhang and Hongliang Zhang and Yunchao Kan and Lunguang Yao and Hongyue Zhai and Mingliang Li and Zhen Li and Chunxiao Liu and Tongqing An and Jinmei Peng and Qian Wang and Yumin Leng and Xuehui Cai and Zhi‐Jun Tian and Guangzhi Tong},
  title = {{ORF1a of highly pathogenic PRRS attenuated vaccine virus plays a key role in neutralizing antibody induction in piglets and virus neutralization in vitro}},
  booktitle = {Virology},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1186/s12985-017-0825-2},
}
Figure