Ordering Bent and Straight Dicarboxylate Linkers in an fcu Zirconium Metal–Organic Framework

Grace S. G. Farmer, Daniel J. Cheney, Khai‐Nghi Truong, Nusik Gedikoglu, Bhupendra P. Mali, Datta Markad, Dmytro Antypov, Frédéric Blanc, Alexandros P. Katsoulidis, Matthew J. RosseinskyJournal of the American Chemical Society 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a novel zirconium metal-organic framework (MOF) by combining straight and bent organic linkers in a single-pot synthesis. This new MOF, with an ordered structure, exhibits unique pore shapes that enable the separation of challenging hydrocarbon mixtures and demonstrates reversible structural changes in response to solvent.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) are highly porous materials built from metal nodes and organic linkers. While MOFs with a single type of linker are well-studied, creating MOFs with multiple, different linkers in an ordered fashion is challenging. This "multicomponent" approach offers the potential for more complex structures and enhanced functionalities, but designing and synthesizing them often requires multistep procedures or relies on preconceived structural models. The authors sought to explore the possibility of creating ordered multicomponent MOFs by combining linkers with different geometries (straight and bent) in a single synthesis step, without a predefined structural target, to discover novel structures and properties.

Methods

The core of this research involved a high-throughput synthesis (HTS) workflow. This involved systematically varying the ratios of the zirconium source (ZrOCl₂·8H₂O), two organic linkers (1,4-benzenedicarboxylate, BDC, a straight linker, and 2,5-thiophenedicarboxylate, TDC, a bent linker), and a modulator (formic acid, FA) in a solvent (dimethylformamide, DMF). This allowed for the rapid exploration of a vast chemical space.

Once promising reaction conditions were identified, the resulting solid products were characterized using powder X-ray diffraction (PXRD) to determine their crystallinity and phase purity. For the newly discovered phase, the crystal structure was solved using synchrotron PXRD data and refined using the Rietveld method. Further characterization included thermogravimetric analysis (TGA), ¹H magic angle spinning (MAS) NMR, and ¹³C CP MAS NMR to confirm the chemical formula, linker ratios, and solvent content, as well as to study structural transformations.

Finally, the material's performance was evaluated through gas chromatography (GC) for the separation of a challenging mixture of n-hexane, cyclohexane, and benzene, and N₂ adsorption-desorption isotherms to assess its porosity. Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations were also employed to understand the guest-molecule diffusion within the MOF's pores and compare it to a known MOF (UiO-66).

Datasets

The paper does not explicitly mention training or evaluation on pre-existing datasets in the machine learning sense. Instead, the "dataset" explored is the chemical space defined by the varying reaction parameters (linker ratios, metal-to-linker ratio, modulator-to-metal ratio). The PXRD patterns of known MOFs (UiO-66 and DUT-67) were used as benchmarks for comparison.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Unprecedented Ordering: The study demonstrates that combining linkers of different geometries (straight BDC and bent TDC) in a one-pot synthesis can lead to highly ordered, non-predetermined structures, challenging the notion that such complex arrangements require multistep synthesis.
  • Synergistic Linker Arrangement: The bent TDC linker, typically challenging to incorporate into high-connectivity MOFs, is accommodated in the fcu topology by coordinating to the equatorial plane of the Zr clusters. This rotation of Zr clusters, in turn, creates distinct sites for the straight BDC linkers, leading to a unique framework.
  • Reversible Structural Transformation: The MOF exhibits a remarkable reversible structural change. Upon exposure to protic solvents like methanol, the TDC linker can be displaced from its direct coordination to Zr clusters, forming hydrogen bonds instead. This transition from a 12-connected framework to an 8-connected one, and back upon solvent removal, highlights the dynamic nature of the material.
  • Tailored Porosity for Separation: The unique cage and window shapes resulting from the ordered arrangement of BDC and TDC linkers enable the MOF to achieve efficient chromatographic separation of n-hexane, cyclohexane, and benzene, a feat that is difficult with conventional methods.
  • High-Throughput Synthesis as a Discovery Tool: The research underscores the power of HTS in exploring complex chemical spaces to discover novel materials with unexpected structures and properties, moving beyond rational design based on existing motifs.

Key Results

  • A new Zr-MOF, Zr₆(BDC)₄(TDC)₂-DMF, was synthesized and structurally characterized.
  • The MOF crystallizes in a tetragonal space group (I4₁/acd), a distortion from the typical cubic symmetry of fcu topology.
  • The structure features an ordered arrangement of eight BDC linkers and four TDC linkers around the Zr₆ clusters.
  • The MOF demonstrated chromatographic separation of n-hexane, cyclohexane, and benzene, exhibiting reverse shape selectivity.
  • The material showed reversible unbinding and rebinding of the bent TDC linkers upon addition and removal of protic solvents, leading to structural transitions.
  • The BET surface area of the activated MOF was 1054 m²/g, with a pore volume of 0.41 cm³/g.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the crystallite size (50-600 nm) was too small for single-crystal X-ray diffraction, necessitating the use of synchrotron PXRD and Rietveld refinement. While the MOF shows promising separation capabilities, the BET surface area is lower than that of UiO-66, which is attributed to the replacement of some BDC linkers with the shorter TDC. The study also notes that the MOF contains missing linkers, similar to UiO-66, which impacts its theoretical surface area and pore volume.

Future work could focus on further optimizing the synthesis to achieve higher linker occupancy and potentially larger crystallites for single-crystal studies. Exploring the application of this MOF in other separation processes or as a catalyst, leveraging its dynamic structural properties, would also be valuable. The demonstrated reversible structural transformation opens avenues for designing responsive materials.

Summary updated

Abstract

The ordering of multiple organic linkers with different sizes and geometries on metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) offers structures with advanced complexity and functionality for enhanced properties. The selection of the components and the number of synthesis steps are commonly rationalized to match existing structural motifs in order to increase the probability of producing the designed new frameworks. Alternatively, combining multiple components, without a preconceived structural model, allows for the exploration of unprecedented structural characteristics. However, this approach requires a large number of experiments to identify both the composition and conditions for a successful synthesis. Here, we report a new Zr-MOF containing ordered straight and bent dicarboxylate linkers prepared by a one-pot synthesis. The discovery was made by high-throughput exploration of the chemical space composed of two linkers, the source of Zr, and the modulator. The linkers and the Zr<sub>6</sub> cluster are ordered on an <b>fcu</b> framework that is tetragonally distorted from its typical cubic symmetry. The arrangement of linkers with different sizes and geometries affords cages and windows with shapes that have not been reported previously, despite the plethora of known <b>fcu</b>-based MOFs. The new MOF exhibits chromatographic separation of the <i>n</i>-hexane/benzene/cyclohexane mixture and demonstrates reversible unbinding and rebinding of the bent linkers upon the addition and removal of protic solvents. The unusual structural properties of the new MOF arise from ordering linkers in a non-predetermined manner following high-throughput synthesis exploration.
BibTeX
@article{farmer2025ordering,
  author = {Grace S. G. Farmer and Daniel J. Cheney and Khai‐Nghi Truong and Nusik Gedikoglu and Bhupendra P. Mali and Datta Markad and Dmytro Antypov and Frédéric Blanc and Alexandros P. Katsoulidis and Matthew J. Rosseinsky},
  title = {{Ordering Bent and Straight Dicarboxylate Linkers in an fcu Zirconium Metal–Organic Framework}},
  journal = {Journal of the American Chemical Society},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1021/jacs.5c05854},
}
Figure