ORCHIDEE-CROP (v0), a new process based Agro-Land Surface Model: model description and evaluation over Europe

Xiuchen Wu, Nicolas Vuichard, Philippe Ciais, Nicolas Viovy, Nathalie de Noblet‐Ducoudré, Xuhui Wang, Vincenzo Magliulo, M. Wattenbach, Luca Vitale, Paul Di Tommasi, Eddy Moors, W.w.p. Jans, J.a. Elbers, Éric Ceschia, Tiphaine Tallec, Christian Bernhofer, Thomas Grünwald, Christine Moureaux, Tanguy Manise, Anne De Ligne, P. Cellier, Benjamin Loubet, Eric Larmanou, Dominique Ripoche2015 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces ORCHIDEE-CROP (v0), a new process-based model that integrates crop phenology and harvest into the ORCHIDEE land surface model. This enhanced model significantly improves the simulation of crop development and carbon/energy fluxes across Europe, providing a more realistic representation of agricultural systems in climate models.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how crops respond to changing climate and atmospheric CO2 is crucial for predicting food security and climate feedbacks. Existing land surface models (LSMs) often treat croplands simplistically, either by lumping them with natural vegetation or using static, crop-specific parameterizations that don't fully capture dynamic crop processes. This limits their ability to accurately simulate the complex interactions between agriculture, the carbon cycle, and the climate system. The authors aim to bridge this gap by developing a more sophisticated crop model that can be integrated into a global LSM.

Methods

The core innovation is the integration of a "generic crop phenology and harvest module" into the ORCHIDEEv196 land surface model. This module, based on the STICS agronomic model, simulates key crop development stages, leaf area index (LAI) dynamics, and carbon allocation to grain for yield. It also includes a simplified parameterization for nitrogen fertilization. The model was evaluated against eddy covariance flux tower data and biometric measurements from seven winter wheat and maize sites across Europe.

Datasets

The study utilized observational data from seven eddy-covariance sites across Europe, which provided measurements of:

  • Carbon dioxide fluxes (Net Ecosystem Exchange - NEE)
  • Latent heat fluxes (LE)
  • Sensible heat fluxes (H)
  • Leaf Area Index (LAI)
  • Aboveground Biomass (AGB)
  • Crop Yield

Meteorological data (temperature, precipitation, wind speed, etc.) were also used as model input.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Phenology is Key: Explicitly modeling crop phenology (development stages) is critical for accurately simulating LAI dynamics and, consequently, carbon and energy fluxes. The default ORCHIDEE model, which treated crops like grass, showed poor performance in this regard.
  • Generic Approach Works: The use of a "generic" crop module, parameterized from STICS, proved effective for simulating different temperate crops (maize and winter wheat) across diverse European sites, suggesting this approach can be broadly applied.
  • Nitrogen Matters, Simply: Even a simplified nitrogen fertilization parameterization improved yield simulations, highlighting the importance of nutrient dynamics in crop models.
  • Hydrology Matters Too: The study found that a more detailed 11-layer soil hydrological scheme (11LAY) improved simulations, particularly for crops in drier climates, suggesting that soil moisture dynamics are a significant driver of crop responses.

Key Results

  • LAI Improvement: ORCHIDEE-CROP (v0) significantly improved LAI simulations compared to the original ORCHIDEE, reducing the RMSE by nearly half (from 2.38 ± 0.77 to 1.08 ± 0.34 m² m⁻²).
  • Good Overall Match: The model achieved a generally good match for aboveground biomass (NRMSE 11.0–54.2%), crop yield, and daily carbon and energy fluxes (NRMSE ~9.0–20.1% for NEE, ~9.4–22.3% for energy fluxes).
  • Spatial Gradients Captured: The model successfully captured spatial gradients of carbon and energy fluxes across the European sites, a crucial capability for regional and global simulations.
  • Yield Simulation: With fertilization, ORCHIDEE-CROP showed a significant reduction in yield NRMSE (from 47% to 23%) compared to the unfertilized version.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Management Simplifications: The authors acknowledge limitations in representing detailed crop management practices (e.g., irrigation, specific fertilization strategies beyond a simple additive response) and the lack of an explicit nitrogen cycle.
  • Root Profile: The root profile is assumed to be fixed, and a more mechanistic parameterization is suggested for future improvement.
  • Pest, Diseases, Weeds: The current model simplifies pest, disease, and weed impacts, assuming they are controlled.
  • Extreme Soil Conditions: Extreme soil conditions like high salinity or acidity are not explicitly handled.
  • Future Directions: The authors emphasize the need for explicit nutrition dynamics and more detailed human management modules to improve understanding and prediction of croplands' role in the biosphere-atmosphere continuum. They also suggest coupling with atmospheric circulation models for global applications. The code is still under development but available upon request.

Summary updated

Abstract

The responses of crop functioning to changing climate and atmospheric CO2 concentration ([CO2]) could have large effects on food production, and impact carbon, water and energy fluxes, causing feedbacks to climate. To simulate the responses of temperate crops to changing climate and [CO2], accounting for the specific phenology of crops mediated by management practice, we present here the development of a process-oriented terrestrial biogeochemical model named ORCHIDEE-CROP (v0), which integrates a generic crop phenology and harvest module and a very simple parameterization of nitrogen fertilization, into the land surface model (LSM) ORCHIDEEv196, in order to simulate biophysical and biochemical interactions in croplands, as well as plant productivity and harvested yield. The model is applicable for a range of temperate crops, but it is tested here for maize and winter wheat, with the phenological parameterizations of two European varieties originating from the STICS agronomical model. We evaluate the ORCHIDEE-CROP (v0) model against eddy covariance and biometric measurements at 7 winter wheat and maize sites in Europe. The specific ecosystem variables used in the evaluation are CO2 fluxes (NEE), latent heat and sensible heat fluxes. Additional measurements of leaf area index (LAI), aboveground biomass and yield are used as well. Evaluation results reveal that ORCHIDEE-CROP (v0) reproduces the observed timing of crop development stages and the amplitude of pertaining LAI changes in contrast to ORCHIDEEv196 in which by default crops have the same phenology than grass. A near-halving of the root mean square error of LAI from 2.38 ± 0.77 to 1.08 ± 0.34 m2 m−2 is obtained between ORCHIDEEv196 and ORCHIDEE-CROP (v0) across the 7 study sites. Improved crop phenology and carbon allocation lead to a general good match between modelled and observed aboveground biomass (with a normalized root mean squared error (NRMSE) of 11.0–54.2 %), crop yield, as well as of the daily carbon and energy fluxes with NRMSE of ~9.0–20.1 and ~9.4–22.3 % for NEE, and sensible and latent heat fluxes, respectively. The model data mistfit for energy fluxes are within uncertainties of the measurements, which themselves show an incomplete energy balance closure within the range 80.6–86.3 %. The remaining discrepancies between modelled and observed LAI and other variables at specific sites are partly attributable to unrealistic representation of management events. In addition, ORCHIDEE-CROP (v0) is shown to have the ability to capture the spatial gradients of carbon and energy-related variables, such as gross primary productivity, NEE, sensible heat fluxes and latent heat fluxes, across the sites in Europe, an important requirement for future spatially explicit simulations. Further improvement of the model with an explicit parameterization of nutrition dynamics and of management, is expected to improve its predictive ability to simulate croplands in an Earth System Model.
BibTeX
@misc{wu2015orchidee,
  author = {Xiuchen Wu and Nicolas Vuichard and Philippe Ciais and Nicolas Viovy and Nathalie de Noblet‐Ducoudré and Xuhui Wang and Vincenzo Magliulo and M. Wattenbach and Luca Vitale and Paul Di Tommasi and Eddy Moors and W.W.P. Jans and J.A. Elbers and Éric Ceschia and Tiphaine Tallec and Christian Bernhofer and Thomas Grünwald and Christine Moureaux and Tanguy Manise and Anne De Ligne and P. Cellier and Benjamin Loubet and Eric Larmanou and Dominique Ripoche},
  title = {{ORCHIDEE-CROP (v0), a new process based Agro-Land Surface Model: model description and evaluation over Europe}},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.5194/gmdd-8-4653-2015},
}

Loading related content...

Figure