Orbital Picture of Yu-Shiba-Rusinov Multiplets

Benjamin Heinrich, Michael V. Ruby, Katharina J. Franke, Peng Yang, Felix von OppenBulletin 2017

TL;DR

This paper uses advanced scanning tunneling microscopy and spectroscopy to reveal that Yu-Shiba-Rusinov (YSR) states, which appear when magnetic impurities are placed on superconductors, are intimately linked to the orbital structure of the impurity's electrons. By analyzing the spatial patterns and energy signatures of these states on lead superconductors, the researchers provide compelling evidence for an orbital picture of YSR multiplets, moving beyond simpler models.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

When a magnetic impurity is introduced into a superconductor, it can create localized electronic states within the superconducting energy gap, known as Yu-Shiba-Rusinov (YSR) states. The simplest theoretical models predict only a single pair of these states. However, experiments have consistently observed multiple YSR resonances. The origin of these multiple resonances has been a subject of debate, with explanations ranging from scattering channels with different angular momenta to anisotropic splitting of the magnetic impurity's own electronic levels. This paper aims to resolve this ambiguity by directly linking the observed YSR states to the specific orbitals of the magnetic impurity (manganese, Mn) and their interaction with the superconducting substrate (lead, Pb). Understanding this connection is crucial for controlling and utilizing these exotic states in future quantum technologies.

Methods

The researchers employed a combination of Scanning Tunneling Microscopy (STM) and Scanning Tunneling Spectroscopy (STS). STM allows for atomic-scale imaging of the surface and the adatoms, while STS probes the local electronic density of states. By performing STS at specific locations and energies, they could map out the spatial extent and intensity of the YSR states.

Key aspects of their methodology include:

  • High-Resolution Spectroscopy: Using superconducting tips and advanced techniques, they achieved an effective energy resolution of approximately 60 µeV at 1.2 K, enabling them to resolve closely spaced YSR states.
  • Spatial Mapping (dI/dV maps): They generated maps of the differential conductance (dI/dV) at the energies of the YSR resonances. These maps reveal how the electronic states are distributed spatially around the magnetic impurity.
  • Surface Preparation: High-quality, clean lead (Pb) single crystals were prepared using Ne+ ion sputtering and annealing.
  • Adatom Deposition: Manganese (Mn) atoms were evaporated onto the clean Pb surface under ultrahigh vacuum conditions.
  • Theoretical Analysis: The experimental findings were interpreted in the context of crystal field theory and theoretical models of YSR states, which helped in assigning the observed resonances to specific Mn d-orbitals.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental data generated by the authors using their STM/STS setup.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Orbital Fingerprints of YSR States: The most significant insight is the direct correlation between the spatial patterns of the YSR states and the known shapes of atomic orbitals (specifically, the d-orbitals of Mn). This provides strong evidence that the YSR states inherit their symmetry and spatial distribution from the underlying electronic orbitals of the magnetic impurity.
  • Crystal Field Splitting is Key: The observed splitting of the Mn d-levels due to the crystal field of the Pb substrate is crucial. This splitting removes the degeneracy of the d-orbitals, leading to distinct YSR states for each orbital.
  • Two-Band Superconductivity Matters: The lead superconductor has two distinct Fermi surfaces and superconducting gaps. The study suggests that the YSR states are predominantly influenced by one of these bands (the p-d-like band), which has a more localized character.
  • Anisotropy of the Fermi Surface: While the orbital symmetry of the impurity is primary, the anisotropy of the Pb Fermi surface also imprints a subtle symmetry on the YSR patterns, particularly on the Pb(111) surface.
  • Multiple YSR States Explained: The paper provides a clear explanation for the observation of multiple YSR resonances: each resonance corresponds to a specific crystal-field-split d-orbital of the Mn atom.

Key Results

  • On the Pb(001) surface, three pairs of YSR resonances were observed, which were spatially mapped and assigned to specific Mn d-orbitals (d₂², dx²-y², and degenerate dxz/yz and dxy orbitals).
  • On the Pb(111) surface, different adsorption sites (Mnpo(111) and Mnpb(111)) led to different crystal field symmetries and consequently different numbers of YSR resonances (five and three, respectively).
  • The spatial extent of some YSR states was found to be remarkably large, reaching up to 4 nm away from the adatom.
  • Oscillatory patterns in the YSR intensity were observed, with a periodicity matching half the Fermi wavelength of the p-d-like band of Pb, confirming its role in scattering.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Ambiguity in Orbital Assignment: While the paper strongly links YSR states to d-orbitals, the exact assignment of all resonances can be challenging, especially when orbital symmetries are similar or when interactions between adatoms occur. The authors acknowledge that for some resonances, the assignment is based on a combination of spatial patterns and theoretical arguments.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that this detailed understanding of orbital-dependent YSR states opens avenues for designing coupled adatom structures for future quantum devices. Further investigations into more complex adatom arrangements (dimers, chains, etc.) and their resulting YSR states are implied. The long-range and directional nature of these states are highlighted as promising for such applications.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{heinrich2017orbital,
  author = {Benjamin Heinrich and Michael V. Ruby and Katharina J. Franke and Peng Yang and Felix von Oppen},
  title = {{Orbital Picture of Yu-Shiba-Rusinov Multiplets}},
  journal = {Bulletin},
  year = {2017},
}
Figure