Optogenetic dissection of descending behavioral control in Drosophila

Jessica Cande, Gordon J Berman, Shigehiro Namiki, Jirui Qiu, Wyatt Korff, Gwyneth M Card, Joshua W. Shaevitz, David L. SternbioRxiv 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel, high-throughput method to systematically map the behavioral outputs of individual descending neurons in fruit flies using optogenetics. By creating a comprehensive "behavior space," they've identified specific neuronal roles in controlling a wide range of fly movements, revealing that these neurons often drive stereotyped behaviors and that their effects can be context-dependent.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The brain's control over complex behaviors is mediated by descending neurons that transmit signals from the brain to the motor circuits in the nerve cord. In insects, while the number of descending neurons is relatively small (hundreds compared to billions in mammals), they are thought to encode a vast repertoire of movements. However, understanding how these few neurons orchestrate such a diverse range of behaviors has been a significant challenge. Traditional methods are low-throughput and often biased, making it difficult to systematically link specific neurons to specific behaviors in freely moving animals. This paper aims to overcome these limitations by developing a method to comprehensively assay the behavioral effects of activating large populations of descending neurons.

Methods

The authors developed a novel optogenetic approach combined with advanced behavioral analysis. They used a split-GAL4 system in Drosophila melanogaster to target specific descending neurons and express the light-sensitive channelrhodopsin CsChrimson. By activating these neurons with red light, they could precisely control their activity in freely behaving flies.

The core of their method is the creation of a "behavior space." This involves:

  1. High-resolution video recording: Capturing detailed postural dynamics of flies.
  2. Dimensionality Reduction: Using principal component analysis (PCA) and t-distributed Stochastic Neighbor Embedding (t-SNE) to reduce the high-dimensional video data into a 2D map representing the fly's behavioral repertoire.
  3. Behavioral Phenotyping: Identifying regions within this behavior space that are significantly more occupied when specific descending neurons are activated. This is done in an unbiased manner, without pre-defined behavioral categories.
  4. Entropy Analysis: Using entropy as a measure of behavioral diversity. A drop in entropy upon neuronal activation indicates a shift towards a more stereotyped set of behaviors.

This approach allows for the systematic and unbiased identification of behavioral phenotypes associated with the activation of many descending neurons.

Datasets

The study utilized a collection of 130 split-GAL4 lines targeting descending neurons in Drosophila melanogaster. These lines were generated as part of the Descending Interneuron Project Team at the Janelia Research Campus. The behavioral data was collected from these flies during optogenetic activation experiments. No specific external datasets were used for training or evaluation in the traditional machine learning sense; rather, the generated behavioral data was analyzed to create the behavior space.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Behavioral Space as a Comprehensive Map: The concept of a "behavior space" is powerful. It allows for an unbiased representation of all observable behaviors, enabling the identification of novel phenotypes without prior assumptions.
  • Descending Neurons Drive Stereotyped Behaviors: A key finding is that activating most descending neurons leads to highly stereotyped, repetitive behaviors, suggesting these neurons act as command signals for specific motor programs.
  • Context Dependency is Crucial: The study strongly supports the idea that the behavioral output of a descending neuron can depend on the fly's state before activation. This is evidenced by high mutual information between pre- and post-stimulation behaviors.
  • Modularity in Neural Control: The results suggest that descending neuron control of behavior is largely modular, with individual neurons or small groups of neurons being responsible for specific behavioral components.

Key Results

  • The authors successfully mapped behavioral phenotypes for 80% of the descending neurons in their collection.
  • They found that activation of most descending neurons drove stereotyped behaviors.
  • In many cases, multiple descending neurons activated similar behaviors.
  • Optogenetically-activated behaviors were often dependent on the behavioral state prior to activation, as indicated by significant mutual information between pre- and post-stimulation behaviors.
  • They identified specific neurons controlling locomotion (fast and slow), anterior movements, grooming (head and abdomen), and wing/abdomen movements.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Detection Limits: Behaviors occurring faster than 50 Hz (the Nyquist frequency of their system) could not be detected.
  • Assay Constraints: The study focused on behaviors observable when flies are standing and walking on a 2D substrate. Behaviors gated by flight or social interactions (like courtship) were not detected.
  • Sex Bias: Only male flies were assayed, so female-specific behaviors may have been missed.
  • Solitary Flies: Behaviors involving social interactions were not captured.

The authors suggest that future work should involve using similar analytical approaches to study descending neuron activation and inactivation in other behavioral settings to broaden the understanding of how these neurons direct motor patterns in specific contexts. Further exploration of how descending neurons encode information and how combinations of neurons generate complex behaviors will require characterizing additional lines.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract In most animals, the brain makes behavioral decisions that are transmitted by descending neurons to the nerve cord circuitry that produces behaviors. In insects, only a few descending neurons have been associated with specific behaviors. To explore how these neurons control an insect’s movements, we developed a novel method to systematically assay the behavioral effects of activating individual neurons on freely behaving terrestrial D. melanogaster . We calculated a two-dimensional representation of the entire behavior space explored by these flies and associated descending neurons with specific behaviors by identifying regions of this space that were visited with increased frequency during optogenetic activation. Applying this approach across a population of descending neurons, we found, that (1) activation of most of the descending neurons drove stereotyped behaviors, (2) in many cases multiple descending neurons activated similar behaviors, and (3) optogenetically-activated behaviors were often dependent on the behavioral state prior to activation.
BibTeX
@misc{cande2017optogenetic,
  author = {Jessica Cande and Gordon J Berman and Shigehiro Namiki and Jirui Qiu and Wyatt Korff and Gwyneth M Card and Joshua W. Shaevitz and David L. Stern},
  title = {{Optogenetic dissection of descending behavioral control in <i>Drosophila</i>}},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1101/230128},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure