Optogenetic dissection of descending behavioral control in Drosophila

Jessica Cande, Shigehiro Namiki, Jirui Qiu, Wyatt Korff, Gwyneth M Card, Joshua W. Shaevitz, David L. Stern, Gordon J BermaneLife 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a high-throughput method to systematically map the behavioral outputs of individual descending neurons in fruit flies. This approach reveals that most descending neurons trigger stereotyped behaviors, often with overlapping functions, and that these behaviors can be context-dependent on the fly's prior state.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In insects, the brain communicates with the body's motor circuits via descending neurons. However, understanding how these relatively few neurons (compared to the vast number in the brain) precisely control the complex repertoire of an insect's movements has been a significant challenge. Previous studies have identified specific descending neurons linked to particular behaviors, but a comprehensive, systematic understanding of their collective function and how they encode diverse actions has been lacking. This paper aims to bridge that gap by providing a large-scale, unbiased characterization of descending neuron function in freely behaving flies.

Methods

The core of this study is a novel optogenetic approach combined with advanced behavioral analysis.

  • Optogenetic Activation: The researchers used a split-GAL4 system to target specific descending neurons in Drosophila melanogaster. When these flies were fed a retinal cofactor, activation of these neurons was triggered by red light.
  • High-Resolution Behavioral Tracking: A custom-built rig with multiple high-speed cameras captured detailed video of flies in small chambers.
  • Behavior Space Mapping: A key innovation is the creation of a "behavior space," a 2D representation of all possible fly movements derived from analyzing postural dynamics. This space is generated using principal component analysis and t-distributed Stochastic Neighbor Embedding (t-SNE), allowing for the visualization and quantification of complex behaviors.
  • Entropy-Based Phenotyping: The researchers used the "entropy" of the behavior space density as a measure of behavioral diversity. A drop in entropy upon optogenetic activation indicates that flies are converging on a specific set of behaviors. This method allows for unbiased identification of activated behaviors without prior assumptions.
  • Systematic Screening: They screened 130 split-GAL4 lines targeting approximately 160 neurons (representing 58 distinct cell types), systematically activating each and observing the resulting shifts in the behavior space.

Datasets

The study generated a novel behavioral dataset by recording the responses of 130 descending neuron lines to optogenetic stimulation. This dataset comprises approximately 700 million images of freely behaving flies. The raw video data, including one second before and after activation for all flies and trials, has been uploaded to the Dryad Digital Repository for public access.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Modularity and Redundancy: The findings suggest that descending neuron control is largely modular, with individual neurons often driving specific, stereotyped behaviors. However, there's also significant redundancy, as multiple different descending neurons can activate similar behavioral outputs.
  • Context is Key: A crucial insight is that the behavioral outcome of activating a descending neuron is often dependent on the fly's state before the stimulation. This suggests a dynamic and context-aware control system.
  • Unbiased Discovery: The use of a behavior space and entropy-based analysis allowed for the discovery of phenotypes without pre-conceived notions, revealing a wide range of behaviors, including locomotion, grooming, and more subtle movements.

Key Results

  • Broad Coverage: The study successfully mapped behavioral phenotypes for 80% of the descending neuron cell types screened.
  • Stereotyped Behaviors: Activation of most descending neurons (80% of those with a phenotype) drove stereotyped behaviors.
  • Overlapping Functions: Many descending neurons activated similar behaviors, indicating a degree of functional overlap.
  • Context Dependency: Mutual information analysis revealed that the fly's pre-stimulation behavior significantly informed the post-stimulation behavior, highlighting the context-dependent nature of descending neuron control.
  • Locomotion Dominance: A significant portion of the identified descending neurons drove locomotion (47 cell types) or anterior directed foreleg movements (10 cell types).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Nyquist Frequency Limit: Behaviors occurring faster than 50 Hz could not be detected due to the video recording frame rate.
  • Limited Behavioral Repertoire: The assay primarily focused on behaviors observable in standing and walking flies in a 2D environment, potentially missing behaviors related to flight or complex social interactions.
  • Male-Specific Assay: Only male flies were studied, meaning female-specific behaviors were not assessed.
  • Solitary Assay: Flies were assayed individually, potentially missing behaviors dependent on social interactions.

The authors suggest that future work should employ similar analytical approaches to study descending neuron inactivation and explore other behavioral contexts to gain a more complete understanding of how these neurons orchestrate behavior. They also highlight the need for further investigation into how combinations of descending neurons might generate more complex behavioral sequences.

Summary updated

Abstract

In most animals, the brain makes behavioral decisions that are transmitted by descending neurons to the nerve cord circuitry that produces behaviors. In insects, only a few descending neurons have been associated with specific behaviors. To explore how descending neurons control an insect's movements, we developed a novel method to systematically assay the behavioral effects of activating individual neurons on freely behaving terrestrial <i>D. melanogaster</i>. We calculated a two-dimensional representation of the entire behavior space explored by these flies, and we associated descending neurons with specific behaviors by identifying regions of this space that were visited with increased frequency during optogenetic activation. Applying this approach across a large collection of descending neurons, we found that (1) activation of most of the descending neurons drove stereotyped behaviors, (2) in many cases multiple descending neurons activated similar behaviors, and (3) optogenetically activated behaviors were often dependent on the behavioral state prior to activation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cande2018optogenetic,
  author = {Jessica Cande and Shigehiro Namiki and Jirui Qiu and Wyatt Korff and Gwyneth M Card and Joshua W. Shaevitz and David L. Stern and Gordon J Berman},
  title = {{Optogenetic dissection of descending behavioral control in Drosophila}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.34275},
}
Figure