Optoelectronic tweezers (OET) trap stiffness with HeLa cells

Steven L. Neale, Aaron T. Ohta, Hsan-Yin Hsu, Justin K. Valley, Arash Jamshidi, Ming C. WuProceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE 2008 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper demonstrates the use of Optoelectronic Tweezers (OET) to precisely trap and manipulate HeLa cells. By using a projector to create custom light patterns, they achieve highly controllable cell manipulation with a stable trap stiffness, paving the way for complex cellular arrangements and studies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Manipulating microscopic particles, especially biological cells, with high precision is crucial for various research applications, from cell sorting to studying cellular mechanics. Traditional optical tweezers, while effective, can require high laser powers and are limited in their ability to create many traps simultaneously. Dielectrophoresis (DEP) offers an alternative, using electric fields to manipulate particles, but reconfiguring DEP traps can be cumbersome. Optoelectronic Tweezers (OET) emerged as a promising technique, combining the reconfigurability of optical methods with the low power requirements of DEP. However, a detailed understanding of OET trap stiffness and its behavior with biological cells, particularly for achieving precise, position-independent forces, was still needed. This paper aims to address this by exploring OET's capability for trapping HeLa cells, characterizing trap stiffness, and validating simulation models.

Methods

The researchers employed a custom-built OET system utilizing a modified digital micromirror device (DMD) from a data projector to create the light patterns. This projector-based approach simplifies alignment and reduces cost compared to other spatial light modulators. The OET chamber itself consists of two indium-tin-oxide (ITO) coated glass substrates sandwiching a liquid medium containing the particles. When a voltage is applied across the ITO layers, illuminating specific areas of a photoconductive layer (amorphous silicon) creates localized electrical field gradients.

To validate their system and modeling, they first used glass beads as a model particle. They then transitioned to trapping HeLa cells, investigating their behavior in different trap sizes. The electrical properties of the HeLa cell membrane were characterized by analyzing their DEP frequency response. Numerical simulations were performed using COMSOL Multiphysics to model the electric field gradients and predict DEP forces. Experimental measurements of trap stiffness were obtained by moving the OET chamber on a motorized stage and analyzing particle movement under viscous drag.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments involved using glass beads and HeLa cells suspended in various solutions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Projector-based OET is a viable and simplified approach: Using a standard data projector with a DMD chip offers a cost-effective and easily alignable method for generating complex OET trapping patterns.
  • Precise control over trap stiffness is achievable: The study demonstrates the ability to create OET traps with a constant stiffness that is independent of the particle's position within the trap, crucial for accurate manipulation.
  • HeLa cell membrane properties can be characterized via DEP: By analyzing the frequency-dependent DEP response of HeLa cells in solutions of varying conductivity, the researchers were able to deduce the electrical properties (thickness and conductivity) of the cell membrane.
  • Simulation models accurately predict OET forces with adjustments: While simulations using COMSOL provided a good starting point, they found that accounting for the particle's proximity to the substrate and applying a reduction factor was necessary to match experimental results for cell trapping.

Key Results

  • Stable, position-independent traps: The researchers successfully created OET traps with a stiffness of 3x10⁻⁶ N m⁻¹, exhibiting a force proportional to the distance from the trap center, enabling precise control.
  • High cell mobility: HeLa cells could be transported at velocities up to 50 µm s⁻¹ using the optimized trap size.
  • Accurate simulation of cell behavior: Simulations, when adjusted for proximity to the substrate and a force reduction factor of 4, accurately predicted the experimentally measured force profiles for trapped HeLa cells.
  • Characterization of HeLa cell membrane: The study determined the HeLa cell membrane to be approximately 5 nm thick with a conductivity of 0.87 µS m⁻¹.
  • Demonstration of multi-cell manipulation: The paper showcases the ability to arrange multiple HeLa cells into complex patterns, such as the "Cal" logo, highlighting the scalability of the OET system.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simulation-to-experiment force discrepancy: While simulations provided good agreement, a reduction factor of 4 was needed to match experimental forces, indicating that assumptions about uniform field gradients across the cell volume might not fully hold true, especially close to the substrate.
  • Future work could explore:
    • Further refinement of simulation models to eliminate the need for empirical reduction factors.
  • Investigating the long-term viability of cells under OET manipulation.
  • Exploring more complex cellular arrangements and dynamic manipulation tasks.
  • Applying this technique to a wider range of cell types and biological studies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Optoelectronic Tweezers (OET) creates patterned electrical fields by selectively illuminating a photoconductive layer sandwiched between two electrodes. The resulting electrical gradients are used to manipulate microscopic particles, including biological cells, using the dielectrophoresis (DEP) force. Previously it has been shown that up to 15,000 traps can be created with just 1 mW of optical power<sup>1</sup>, and that OET traps are 470 times stiffer than traps created with optical tweezers of the same power<sup>2</sup>. In this paper we explore the use of OET for trapping HeLa cells. First, experiments are performed using glass beads as a model particle, and the results are compared with numerical simulations to confirm our ability to model the electrical field gradients in the OET device. We then track trapped HeLa cells in different sizes of traps, showing maximum cell velocities of 60 &mu;m s<sup>-1</sup> using an illumination intensity of just 2.5 W cm<sup>-2</sup>. We measure the electrical properties of the cell's membrane by analyzing the cell's DEP frequency response and use this information to model the forces on the cell. We find that it is possible to create a trap with a stiffness of 3&times;10<sup>-6</sup> N m<sup>-1</sup> that does not vary with position within the trap.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{neale2008optoelectronic,
  author = {Steven L. Neale and Aaron T. Ohta and Hsan-Yin Hsu and Justin K. Valley and Arash Jamshidi and Ming C. Wu},
  title = {{Optoelectronic tweezers (OET) trap stiffness with HeLa cells}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE},
  year = {2008},
  doi = {10.1117/12.793899},
}
Figure