Optimizing Smart Grid Aggregators and Measuring Degree of Privacy in a Distributed Trust Based Anonymous Aggregation System

Mohammad Saidur RahmanarXiv 2020 · OpenReview

Abstract

A smart grid is an advanced method for supplying electricity to the consumers alleviating the limitations of the existing system. It causes frequent meter reading transmission from the end-user to the supplier. This frequent data transmission poses privacy risks. Several works have been proposed to solve this problem but cannot ensure privacy at the optimal level. This work is based on a distributed trust-based data aggregation system leveraging a secret sharing mechanism. In this work, we show that three aggregators are enough for ensuring consumer's privacy in a distributed trust-based system. We leverage the idea of anonymity in our research and show that neither an active attacker nor a passive attacker can breach consumer's privacy. We show proof of our concept mathematically and in a cryptographic game based mechanism. We name our new proposed system "Distributed Trust Based Anonymous System (DTBAS)".

Introduction

The transition to smart grids is essential for modernizing energy distribution, enabling real-time monitoring and efficient supply management. However, this advancement introduces significant privacy concerns. Unlike traditional systems where meters are read monthly, smart meters transmit data at high frequencies—often every 15 minutes. This granular data can inadvertently reveal sensitive information about a consumer's lifestyle, such as occupancy patterns and appliance usage.

Existing privacy-preserving solutions frequently rely on a single Trusted Third Party (TTP) for data aggregation. This centralized approach creates a single point of failure; if the TTP is compromised, the privacy of all connected users is jeopardized. This research proposes the Distributed Trust Based Anonymous System (DTBAS), which shifts from centralized trust to a distributed model to enhance consumer privacy.

Methodology: The DTBAS Framework

The core of DTBAS is a Secret Sharing Mechanism. Instead of transmitting a complete data packet to a single entity, a smart meter divides its reading into multiple "shares." In the proposed optimal configuration, the reading is split into three equal parts. Each share is then transmitted to a different aggregator.

Secret sharing mechanism in DTBAS

Attack Modeling

The system's robustness is evaluated against two primary threat actors:

  1. Active Attackers: Adversaries who gain control over one or more aggregators to attempt to reconstruct a specific user's data.
  2. Passive Attackers: Global adversaries, such as a malicious supplier, who monitor all network traffic to deanonymize users.

Privacy Quantification

To objectively measure privacy, the study employs Shannon’s Entropy. The "Degree of Anonymity" ($d_a$) is calculated, where $d_a = 1.0$ signifies perfect anonymity (the attacker has no advantage over a random guess).

Key Insights and Results

The mathematical analysis reveals a "sweet spot" for privacy optimization. Contrary to the intuition that more aggregators always yield better security, the research demonstrates that three aggregators are optimal.

The "Three Aggregator" Sweet Spot

In a "Variable Probability" model—where attackers can make informed guesses—the degree of anonymity actually decreases as the number of aggregators increases beyond three. For instance, the $d_a$ drops from $0.68$ with three aggregators to $0.52$ with five.

DTBAS architecture with three aggregators

Resilience and Requirements

The study proves that an active attacker controlling up to two aggregators in a three-aggregator system cannot reconstruct the original secret, as the information gained remains insufficient. Furthermore, the system establishes a baseline requirement of at least three users and three aggregators to maintain secure operations.

Conclusion and Future Work

DTBAS provides a mathematically grounded framework for anonymous data aggregation in smart grids. By identifying three aggregators as the optimal configuration, the system balances privacy, security, and complexity. While this work serves as a theoretical proof of concept using synthetic probability distributions, future research will focus on empirical validation using real-world electricity consumption datasets and evaluating the system's performance in live network environments.

Summary updated

Abstract

A smart grid is an advanced method for supplying electricity to the consumers alleviating the limitations of the existing system. It causes frequent meter reading transmission from the end-user to the supplier. This frequent data transmission poses privacy risks. Several works have been proposed to solve this problem but cannot ensure privacy at the optimal level. This work is based on a distributed trust-based data aggregation system leveraging a secret sharing mechanism. In this work, we show that {\em three aggregators} are enough for ensuring consumer's privacy in a distributed trust-based system. We leverage the idea of anonymity in our research and show that neither an active attacker nor a passive attacker can breach consumer's privacy. We show proof of our concept mathematically and in a cryptographic game based mechanism. We name our new proposed system \emph{"Distributed Trust Based Anonymous System (DTBAS)"}.
BibTeX
@misc{rahman2020optimizing,
  author = {Mohammad Saidur Rahman},
  title = {{Optimizing Smart Grid Aggregators and Measuring Degree of Privacy in a Distributed Trust Based Anonymous Aggregation System}},
  year = {2020},
  eprint = {2006.06070},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2006.06070},
}
Figure