Optimizing porphyrins for dye sensitized solar cells using large-scale ab initio calculations

Kristian B. Ørnsø, Christian Søndergaard Pedersen, J. M. García‐Lastra, Kristian S. ThygesenPhysical 2014 · DOI

Abstract

In the search for sustainable energy sources, dye sensitized solar cells (DSSCs) represent an attractive solution due to their low cost, relatively high efficiencies, and flexible design. Porphyrin-based dyes are characterized by strong absorption in the visible part of the spectrum and easy customization allowing their electronic properties to be controlled by structural variations. Here we present a computational screening study of more than 5000 porphyrin-based dyes obtained by modifying the porphyrin backbone (metal center and axial ligands), substituting hydrogen by fluorine, and adding different side and anchoring groups. Based on the calculated frontier orbital energies and optical gaps we quantify the energy level alignment with the TiO2 conduction band and different redox mediators. An analysis of the energy level-structure relationship reveals a significant structural diversity among the dyes with the highest level alignment quality, demonstrating the large degree of flexibility in porphyrin dye design. As a specific example of dye optimization, we show that the level alignment of the high efficiency record dye YD2-o-C8 can be significantly improved by modest structural variations. All the presented data have been stored in a publicly available database.

Introduction

Dye-sensitized solar cells (DSSCs) are a promising low-cost alternative to traditional silicon photovoltaics. However, their overall efficiency is critically dependent on the molecular dye's energy level alignment. For optimal performance, the dye's excited state must be high enough in energy to inject an electron into the semiconductor conduction band (typically $TiO_2$), while its ground state must be low enough to be efficiently regenerated by a redox electrolyte. Porphyrins, structural relatives of chlorophyll, are ideal candidates due to their intense visible light absorption and highly tunable nature. Given the nearly infinite chemical design space, systematic computational screening is essential to guide experimental efforts toward the most efficient molecular architectures.

Computational Methodology

The study utilized high-throughput Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations performed with the GPAW code. A library of 5,145 unique dyes was constructed by systematically varying several structural components:

  • Porphyrin Backbones: Including Zinc-centered (ZnP), metal-free, and Titanium-centered (TiOP) structures, as well as fluorinated variants.
  • Side and Anchor Groups: Seven donor side groups and three acceptor anchor groups were permuted across the backbones.

Instead of relying on simple orbital energies, the researchers calculated the fundamental gap (via ionization potential and electron affinity) and the optical gap ($E_1$). A "level alignment quality" metric ($\eta$) was introduced to quantify how effectively a dye's absorption spectrum overlaps with solar flux while meeting the thermodynamic requirements for electron injection and dye regeneration.

Key Structural Insights

The screening revealed several powerful "tuning knobs" for molecular design. Zinc-centered porphyrins (ZnP) remain a standard benchmark due to their well-understood electronic properties and high performance in existing devices.

The standard Zinc-centered porphyrin (ZnP) backbone used as a baseline in the screening study.

However, the introduction of Titanium ($Ti^{4+}$) centers, such as in TiOP, allows for the use of axial ligands. These ligands, which extend perpendicular to the porphyrin plane, provide a unique mechanism to shift the Highest Occupied Molecular Orbital (HOMO) level independently of the side groups, facilitating better alignment with redox mediators without compromising other properties.

The Titanium Oxo Porphyrin (TiOP) backbone, which allows for axial ligand tuning of energy levels.

Additionally, the study highlighted the "fluorine effect": replacing hydrogen atoms on the porphyrin backbone with fluorine induces a strong electrostatic shift, pulling both HOMO and LUMO levels downward. This provides another layer of control for matching dyes to specific electrolytes.

Results and Optimization

The high-throughput approach identified thousands of candidates that theoretically outperform the current record-holding dye, YD2-o-C8 (which has a predicted $\eta$ of 0.20). The best-performing dyes achieved $\eta$ values as high as 0.46, more than double the baseline.

As a proof of concept, the researchers demonstrated that the alignment quality of YD2-o-C8 could be improved from 0.20 to 0.33 by simply swapping its side groups for MOTPA/DMP, while maintaining compatibility with the standard iodide/triiodide redox mediator. This suggests that even highly optimized experimental dyes have significant room for theoretical improvement through systematic structural variation.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

This large-scale screening demonstrates the vast potential for optimizing porphyrin dyes through targeted structural modifications. While the current calculations were performed in a vacuum—omitting solvent and surface effects that would shift absolute energy levels—the identified trends provide a robust map for experimentalists. Future work will aim to incorporate kinetic modeling and more complex environment effects to further refine these predictive models. All data from this study, including frontier orbital energies and structural details, have been made publicly available in the Computational Materials Repository (CMR) at the Technical University of Denmark.

Summary updated

Abstract

In the search for sustainable energy sources, dye sensitized solar cells (DSSCs) represent an attractive solution due to their low cost, relatively high efficiencies, and flexible design. Porphyrin-based dyes are characterized by strong absorption in the visible part of the spectrum and easy customization allowing their electronic properties to be controlled by structural variations. Here we present a computational screening study of more than 5000 porphyrin-based dyes obtained by modifying the porphyrin backbone (metal center and axial ligands), substituting hydrogen by fluorine, and adding different side and anchoring groups. Based on the calculated frontier orbital energies and optical gaps we quantify the energy level alignment with the TiO2 conduction band and different redox mediators. An analysis of the energy level-structure relationship reveals a significant structural diversity among the dyes with the highest level alignment quality, demonstrating the large degree of flexibility in porphyrin dye design. As a specific example of dye optimization, we show that the level alignment of the high efficiency record dye YD2-o-C8 [Yella et al., Science, 2011, 334, 629-634] can be significantly improved by modest structural variations. All the presented data have been stored in a publicly available database.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{rns2014optimizing,
  author = {Kristian B. Ørnsø and Christian Søndergaard Pedersen and J. M. García‐Lastra and Kristian S. Thygesen},
  title = {{Optimizing porphyrins for dye sensitized solar cells using large-scale <i>ab initio</i> calculations}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1039/c4cp01289e},
}
Figure