Optimizing Business Environment by Developing E-government Services

Juan WangAdvances 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores how the Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macao Greater Bay Area (GBA) can boost its economic competitiveness by modernizing its e-government infrastructure. By analyzing international success stories like the UK and Singapore, the author argues that shifting from fragmented digital tools to "user-centered" platforms that cover entire business life cycles is the key to closing the development gap between GBA cities.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macao Greater Bay Area is one of China’s most economically vibrant regions, but it faces a "coordination" crisis. The region is a patchwork of different social and legal systems, and even within the nine Pearl River Delta (PRD) cities, there is a significant development gap.

The author tackles the question: How can digital government services be used as a strategic lever to optimize the business environment? Currently, while cities like Shenzhen and Guangzhou are digital leaders, others lag behind. This fragmentation creates friction for businesses trying to navigate the region, hindering the goal of a truly integrated, high-efficiency economic hub.

Methods

The paper employs a comparative case study and literature review approach. The author:

  1. Correlates Global Data: Compares the World Bank’s "Ease of Doing Business" rankings with the United Nations E-Government Survey to establish a statistical link between digital maturity and economic health.
  2. Benchmarking: Analyzes the "best practices" of international leaders in e-government, specifically the United Kingdom, Singapore, and New Zealand.
  3. Regional Analysis: Evaluates the current state of "Digital Guangdong," focusing on the "government-enterprise cooperation" model (a joint venture involving Tencent and major Chinese telcos).

Datasets

The paper does not introduce a new primary dataset but synthesizes several high-level benchmarks:

  • World Bank "Doing Business 2020" Report: Used to track China’s rise in global business rankings.
  • United Nations E-Government Survey 2020: Specifically the E-Government Development Index (EGDI) and Online Service Index (OSI).
  • Regional Regression Data: References linear regression analyses by researchers Wang Runliang and Zhang Banghui regarding the "Digital Dividend" and "Digital Gap" within the PRD cities.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Digital Dividend" vs. "Digital Gap": The paper highlights that e-government isn't just about moving paperwork online; it’s a tool for marketization. High-quality digital services reduce the "space for fraudulent use of office" by creating traceable, transparent digital trails.
  • From Transactions to "User-Journeys": A major insight is the shift from providing discrete services (like paying a single fee) to supporting whole user-journeys. For example, instead of just a "permit application" button, a platform should guide a user through the entire "life event" of starting a restaurant—from registration to food safety plans.
  • The GBA Disparity: There is a stark "7-point" gap in business environment evaluations between leaders (Shenzhen/Guangzhou) and trailing cities (Zhongshan). The author argues that this isn't just an economic issue, but a result of varying "reforming intensity."
  • The "One-Stop" Philosophy: Successful international models (like GOV.UK) integrated thousands of fragmented ministerial websites into a single portal. The paper suggests the GBA must move toward this level of radical simplification.

Key Results

  • Proven Correlation: The author identifies seven countries/regions (including Singapore, New Zealand, and Denmark) that appear at the top of both the UN E-Government and World Bank Business rankings, proving that digital excellence and business ease are inseparable.
  • Digital Guangdong Success: The paper notes that the creation of a provincial collaboration platform (gdzwfw.gov.cn) has already begun to reduce data loss and improve cross-departmental collaboration.
  • Policy Recommendations: The study concludes with two primary suggestions for the GBA:
  • Implementing a top-down management mechanism to standardize service levels across all nine cities.
  • Adopting customized, proactive services that use fuzzy search and AI-driven guides to help users who may not know exactly which legal provisions apply to them.

Limitations and Future Work

The paper focuses almost exclusively on the nine PRD cities (mainland China), largely sidestepping the massive legal and technical hurdles of integrating the e-government systems of Hong Kong and Macao, which operate under different "One Country, Two Systems" frameworks.

The author suggests that future research should focus on building mutual trust and creating a unified institutional framework that can standardize digital services across the entire Greater Bay Area, not just the mainland portion. This would require navigating complex cross-border data sharing and legal recognition of digital documents.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Fifth Plenary Session of the 19th Party Central Committee put forward clear requirements for the construction of digital government and the business environment. Besides, relevant studies show that e-government services are conducive to improving the evaluation of the business environment of enterprises and the degree of marketization. Drawing lessons from the practice of optimizing business environment by developing e-government services in foreign countries, this study puts forward two suggestions, that is forming a top-down mechanism of management by objectives and being user-centered and serving for whole user-journeys, to develop e-government services in the Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macao Greater Bay Area, which hopes to shed light on improving business environment and accelerating coordinated development of the Greater Bay Area.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2021optimizing,
  author = {Juan Wang},
  title = {{Optimizing Business Environment by Developing E-government Services}},
  booktitle = {Advances},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.2991/assehr.k.211209.064},
}
Figure