Optimizing Allocation of Distributed Electric Heating for Large-Scale Access Distribution Considering the Influence of Power Quality

Wei Li, Mengjun Li, Ning Zhang, Xuesong Zhou, Jiegui Zhou, Guanyu SongEnergies 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of integrating large-scale electric heating into existing power grids by proposing a novel two-layer optimization model. This model simultaneously optimizes power quality control devices and load scheduling to minimize power loss, voltage deviations, and investment costs, ensuring grid stability and efficiency.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing adoption of electric heating, driven by environmental concerns and government initiatives, poses a significant challenge to the stability and reliability of power distribution networks. Specifically, the surge in demand from electric heating can lead to several power quality issues:

  • Voltage Drops: Increased reactive power consumption by heating loads can cause voltage levels to fall, potentially preventing equipment from starting.
  • Three-Phase Imbalance: Uneven load distribution across phases, common in rural networks, can be exacerbated by electric heating, leading to operational inefficiencies and equipment stress.
  • Harmonic Distortion: Electric heating devices can introduce harmonic currents into the grid, degrading power quality and potentially causing interference with other equipment.
  • Network Overload: In areas with weak grid infrastructure, the added load from electric heating can push transformers and lines beyond their capacity.

Existing solutions often address these issues in isolation. This paper aims to provide a comprehensive approach by considering these problems concurrently within a unified optimization framework.

Methods

The core of this research is a dual-layer optimization model implemented using a co-simulation platform combining MATLAB and OpenDSS.

  • Upper-Layer Planning (Power Quality Control Device Configuration): This layer focuses on optimizing the placement and capacity of power quality control devices.
  • Objective: Minimize active power loss, voltage deviation, and investment cost for power quality control devices.
  • Decision Variables: Capacity configuration and placement of harmonic control devices (e.g., Active Power Filters - APFs) and reactive power compensation devices (e.g., Thyristor Switched Capacitors - TSCs), as well as the number and location of commutation switches.
  • Algorithm: An improved particle swarm optimization (PSO) algorithm is used for multi-objective optimization.
  • Lower-Layer Planning (Load Optimization Scheduling): This layer focuses on managing the load behavior of electric heating devices.
  • Objective: Minimize the number of switching actions and the degree of three-phase imbalance.
  • Decision Variable: The state of commutation switches.
  • Algorithm: An improved genetic algorithm (GA) is employed for optimization.

The two layers are interconnected: the upper layer's decisions inform the lower layer, and the lower layer's results (voltage deviation and three-phase imbalance) are fed back to the upper layer for iterative refinement.

The paper also details specific strategies:

  • Reactive Power Compensation and Harmonic Control: Recommends installing TSC + APF devices near electric heating users to mitigate impacts at the source.
  • Three-Phase Imbalance Management: Proposes using on-line automatic commutation devices on branches to balance loads.

Datasets

The study utilizes a simulated rural low-voltage distribution network in the Tongzhou District, Beijing, as a case study. This network is described with specific parameters:

  • Short-circuit capacity: 10 MVA
  • Transformer: 315 kVA S11 distribution transformer
  • Power supply radius: 681 m
  • Branches: Five branches with varying lengths.
  • Wire type: LGJ
  • Households: 140 single-phase users, evenly distributed across phases.

The simulations explore varying penetration rates of distributed electric heating from 20% to 80%.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Holistic Approach is Crucial: Addressing power quality issues arising from distributed electric heating requires a unified approach that considers device configuration and load management simultaneously, rather than treating them as separate problems.
  • Dual-Layer Optimization Effectiveness: The proposed two-layer model effectively balances competing objectives (e.g., cost vs. performance) to achieve optimal power quality management.
  • Targeted Device Placement: Placing reactive power compensation and harmonic filtering devices closer to the load (i.e., near electric heating users) is more effective in mitigating power quality issues.
  • Commutation Switches as a Key Control Lever: The intelligent use of commutation switches for load balancing is shown to be a practical and cost-effective method for managing three-phase imbalance.
  • Algorithm Synergy: The combination of PSO for upper-layer optimization and GA for lower-layer optimization demonstrates a robust approach to solving complex multi-objective problems in power systems.

Key Results

The simulations conducted on the Tongzhou District rural distribution network demonstrated significant improvements in power quality under various electric heating penetration rates (20-80%):

  • Voltage Improvement: The proposed optimization measures significantly improved voltage levels, ensuring they remained within the acceptable limits (+7% to -10%) for low-voltage distribution networks. For instance, at 80% penetration, the minimum voltage per unit value reached 0.9238 p.u. after treatment, meeting the standard.
  • Harmonic Reduction: The total harmonic distortion (THD) at the Point of Common Coupling (PCC) was effectively reduced. At 80% penetration, the harmonic voltage content rates were below the national standard limit of < 4% (e.g., 0.86% at 80% penetration).
  • Three-Phase Imbalance Reduction: The three-phase unbalance degree was significantly reduced, falling below the critical 1.3% threshold in all tested scenarios after treatment.
  • Power Factor Improvement: The fundamental power factor at the PCC point was maintained at 0.96 or higher.
  • Cost-Effectiveness: The model considers investment costs for power quality control devices, suggesting a balance between performance and economic feasibility.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The study relies on simulated data for a specific rural low-voltage distribution network. Real-world network complexities and variations might influence the outcomes.
  • The paper focuses on steady-state power quality. Dynamic transient stability under rapid load changes or faults is not explicitly addressed.
  • The cost parameters for devices are given as specific values (e.g., ¥45/A for APF). These can vary significantly in practice.
  • Future Work:
    • Dynamic Analysis: Investigating the system's response to transient events and dynamic load changes would provide a more complete picture of its performance.
  • Real-World Validation: Applying and validating the proposed model on actual distribution networks would be crucial for confirming its practical applicability.
  • Integration with Renewable Energy Sources: Exploring the combined impact and optimization strategies for electric heating alongside intermittent renewable energy sources (like solar and wind) would be a valuable extension.
  • Advanced Control Strategies: Investigating more sophisticated control algorithms for the commutation switches and power quality devices could further enhance performance.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, a dual-layer grid comprehensive resource optimizing allocation model is proposed, which considers power quality controlling and load optimization scheduling under large-scale application of distributed electric heating. The upper-layer planning aims to minimize the active power loss of the distribution network, the minimum voltage deviation, and the minimum investment cost of the power quality control device. The capacity configuration of the management device and the number and location of the commutation switch configuration were determined. The lower layer is load optimization scheduling, with the minimum number of action switches and the minimum three-phase imbalance as the planning goals, and the decision variable is the state of the commutation switch. By co-simulation through Matlab and OpenDSS, the improved particle swarm algorithm and genetic algorithm are used for multi-objective optimization and the solution. In this way, the capacity configuration of reactive power compensation and active filter, as well as the installation position and switch state of the commutation switch are optimized and managed. Finally, taking the rural low-voltage distribution network in the Tongzhou District as an example, simulations considering the variation in the distributed electric heating penetration rate in the range of 20–80% are carried out. The calculation example results show that the proposed algorithm is effective, can effectively improve the power factor, reduces the harmonic content of the distribution network and the three-phase unbalance, and significantly improves the distribution network voltage.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2022optimizing,
  author = {Wei Li and Mengjun Li and Ning Zhang and Xuesong Zhou and Jiegui Zhou and Guanyu Song},
  title = {{Optimizing Allocation of Distributed Electric Heating for Large-Scale Access Distribution Considering the Influence of Power Quality}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/en15103587},
}
Figure