Optimized design of porous dental implant structures based on triply periodic minimal surface (TPMS)

Songqing Chen, Xiaoying Liu, Chenjian Liao, Xiangzhen Chen, Hongjuan Lai, Dongdong ChenBiomedizinische 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have optimized porous dental implants using Triply Periodic Minimal Surface (TPMS) geometries to solve the "stress shielding" problem. By tuning the porosity of Diamond (D-type) and Gyroid (G-type) structures to between 40% and 60%, they successfully matched the mechanical properties of human bone while maintaining enough structural integrity to withstand biting forces.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional dental implants are typically made of solid titanium alloys. While titanium is biocompatible, it is significantly stiffer than human bone—possessing an elastic modulus of roughly 110 GPa compared to cortical bone's ~14 GPa.

This mismatch leads to stress shielding: the stiff implant carries the lion's share of the mechanical load, "shielding" the surrounding bone from necessary stress. Because bone is a living tissue that remodels based on the loads it experiences (Wolff’s Law), under-stressed bone begins to resorb and lose density. This eventually leads to implant loosening and clinical failure. The challenge is to design an implant that is porous enough to mimic bone's flexibility and encourage "osseointegration" (bone ingrowth) without becoming too fragile to handle the 200N forces of chewing.

Methods

The authors employed a sophisticated digital workflow to design and test their "two-stage" porous implants:

  1. Patient-Specific Modeling: They used CT scan data from a female subject to reconstruct a high-fidelity 3D model of a mandible using MIMICS and Geomagic Studio.
  2. TPMS Architecture: They focused on two specific TPMS geometries: D-type (Diamond) and G-type (Gyroid). These are mathematically defined surfaces that create interconnected pore networks. Porosity was precisely controlled (at 40%, 60%, and 80%) by adjusting a specific mathematical parameter (t).
  3. Simulation (FEA): Using ANSYS and Abaqus, the team performed Finite Element Analysis to evaluate how these structures behave under a 200N masticatory (chewing) load. They specifically looked at the stress distribution at the "neck" and "apex" of the implant.
  4. Mechanical Validation: They used the Ashby-Gibson mathematical model to estimate the yield strength of the porous structures to ensure they wouldn't deform permanently under pressure.

Datasets

The study utilized a patient-specific mandibular model derived from DICOM-formatted medical imaging (CT scans) of a single female subject with normal mandibular development. While not a large-scale benchmark dataset, this provided a realistic, anatomically accurate environment for the biomechanical simulations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Porosity "Sweet Spot": The study found that 40–60% porosity is the ideal range. At 80% porosity, the G-type structure’s walls become so thin that the stress exceeds the yield strength of the titanium alloy, risking structural failure.
  • Mitigating Stress Shielding: The porous designs reduced the stress difference between cortical and cancellous bone by 30–50% compared to traditional solid designs. This suggests a much more "natural" load distribution that could prevent bone resorption.
  • D-type vs. G-type: While both performed well, the D-type structure at 60% porosity showed the most promising balance of stress transfer and mechanical durability.
  • Interconnectedness Matters: Beyond just mechanical matching, the TPMS structures provide a continuous, open-cell network. This is critical for the transport of blood and nutrients, which facilitates faster and deeper bone ingrowth into the implant itself.

Key Results

  • Stress Reduction: Porous designs significantly smoothed the stress gradient at the bone-implant interface.
  • Mechanical Integrity: Both D- and G-type structures met mechanical requirements at porosities $\leq$ 60%.
  • Peak Stress: For the D-structure, maximum equivalent stresses were 56.83 MPa (40% porosity), 60.14 MPa (60%), and 136.0 MPa (80%).
  • Yield Comparison: The yield strength of the base Ti-6Al-4V alloy is 970 MPa. Even with the reduction in strength due to porosity, the 40-60% designs remained well within the safety margin, whereas the 80% designs approached or exceeded homogenized yield limits in certain configurations.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several areas for further exploration:

  • In Silico Only: This study is entirely based on computer simulations (finite element analysis). While FEA is a robust tool, it cannot fully replicate the complex biological environment of the human mouth.
  • Fatigue Testing: Dental implants must withstand millions of loading cycles over decades. This paper does not address long-term fatigue life or the impact of cyclic loading on the thin TPMS walls.
  • Experimental Validation: The next steps involve in vitro (lab bench) experiments and eventually in vivo (animal or clinical) studies to validate the long-term stability and actual rate of bone ingrowth.
  • Manufacturing Constraints: While TPMS geometries are ideal for 3D printing (Selective Laser Melting), the paper does not detail the specific manufacturing tolerances required to maintain these precise mathematical curvatures in a physical titanium part.

Summary updated

Abstract

TPMS-based porous implants with 40-60 % porosity balance mechanical strength and stress distribution, offering personalized solutions for bone quality adaptation. Future work should validate long-term stability through <i>in vitro</i> experiments.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chen2025optimized,
  author = {Songqing Chen and Xiaoying Liu and Chenjian Liao and Xiangzhen Chen and Hongjuan Lai and Dongdong Chen},
  title = {{Optimized design of porous dental implant structures based on triply periodic minimal surface (TPMS)}},
  booktitle = {Biomedizinische},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1515/bmt-2025-0159},
}
Figure