Optimize configuration of multi-energy storage system in a standalone microgrid

Jun ChenFrontiers in Energy Research 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes a comprehensive optimization model for multi-energy storage systems (combining electrical and thermal storage) in standalone microgrids. By integrating a seasonal battery life estimation model and a bio-inspired Bacterial Colony Chemotaxis (BCC) algorithm, the researchers achieved a 54% reduction in total costs while significantly increasing renewable energy utilization and system reliability.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Standalone microgrids—those not connected to a main power grid—face a dual challenge: the inherent volatility of renewable energy (like wind) and the rigid "thermoelectric coupling" of cogeneration units. In many systems, heat and power are produced together; during winter, these units often run at high levels to meet heating demands, producing excess electricity that forces the "abandonment" of clean wind power.

Existing research often treats electrical and thermal storage in isolation or fails to account for how battery degradation fluctuates between heating and non-heating seasons. This paper seeks to bridge that gap by creating a unified configuration model that optimizes the rated power and capacity of both battery and heat storage systems simultaneously.

Methods

The authors developed a multi-objective optimization framework focused on "economy" (minimizing investment, operation, and pollution costs). Key components include:

  • Seasonal Battery Life Modeling: Instead of a static life estimate, the paper uses the "rain flow counting method" to calculate battery degradation based on discharge depth. It specifically accounts for the different cycling patterns during the 120-day heating period vs. the 245-day non-heating period.
  • Thermoelectric Decoupling: The model incorporates heat storage to "buffer" the output of cogeneration units, allowing them to meet thermal loads without overproducing electricity.
  • Self-Sufficiency Probability: To handle the uncertainty of wind and load forecasts, the authors introduced a probabilistic constraint to ensure the microgrid remains stable even when predictions are slightly off.
  • BCC Algorithm: The problem is solved using an improved Bacterial Colony Chemotaxis algorithm. This bio-inspired approach mimics how bacteria exchange information to find food, which the authors adapted to find the optimal power distribution strategy more quickly than standard algorithms.

Datasets

The study validates its model using a simulated 6-unit microgrid system based on historical data from an island. The system includes:

  • 3 conventional thermal power units.
  • 2 steam extraction cogeneration units.
  • 1 wind turbine.
  • Historical residential load and wind speed data.
  • Coal consumption and operation parameters sourced from existing literature (Jiaming et al., 2016).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Heat-to-Power" Buffer: The most significant "aha moment" is the realization that thermal storage is often more cost-effective than battery storage for absorbing excess wind energy. By using excess wind to power electric boilers and storing that heat, the system can turn down cogeneration units, preventing wind abandonment.
  • Seasonal Battery Dynamics: The research shows that battery life is significantly impacted by the season. In the heating period, the SOC (State of Charge) curve is smoother because thermal storage handles much of the energy shifting, whereas, in non-heating periods, batteries cycle more aggressively (4.5 cycles/day vs 2.5 cycles/day).
  • Probabilistic Reliability: By moving away from deterministic "perfect" forecasts and using a 90% self-sufficiency probability requirement, the resulting configuration is much more resilient to real-world weather fluctuations.

Key Results

The researchers compared their optimized configuration (Scenario C) against a baseline with no storage (Scenario A) and a randomly configured system (Scenario B):

  • Cost Efficiency: The total cost dropped from $171.19 million to $77.75 million—a reduction of approximately 54% compared to the no-storage baseline.
  • Reliability Boost: The probability of electrical self-sufficiency increased from a shaky 65% to a robust 99%.
  • Environmental Impact: Pollution control costs were reduced, and wind power uptake was significantly promoted, particularly during night-time hours in the heating season.
  • Battery Longevity: Under the optimized configuration, the estimated service life of the battery system was calculated to be 2.2 years.

Limitations and Future Work

While the model is robust for standalone systems, the authors acknowledge several areas for expansion:

  • Grid Connection: The current study focuses only on independent (islanded) modes; future iterations could explore how these storage configurations interact with a main utility grid.
  • Broader Energy Vectors: The authors suggest incorporating other forms of energy conversion, such as Power-to-Gas (P2G) or liquid hydrogen storage, to further increase flexibility.
  • Real-time Life Modeling: Future research could move from typical-day estimations to more granular, real-time battery health monitoring within the optimization loop.

Summary updated

Abstract

Aiming at the integrated energy microgrid, an important part of the energy internet, this paper constructs a multi-energy storage system optimization configuration model of the integrated energy microgrid in an independent mode, and proposes a configuration method that includes the rated power and capacity of the storage system and the heat storage system. The storage system model includes the estimation of battery life during heating and non-heating periods. The model takes economy as the index, and considers the relevant constraints of thermoelectric coupling of thermoelectric units, including thermal and electrical balance, unit climb, energy storage system and self-sufficiency probability, etc., and uses a The bacterial colony chemotaxis (BCC) algorithm model based on unit output and energy storage system power distribution strategy to solve the problem. The operation characteristics of cogeneration units equipped with energy storage system are discussed. The results show that the proposed multi-energy storage system configuration method has significant economic and environmental benefits in both heating and non-heating periods, and promotes the uptake of wind power.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chen2023optimize,
  author = {Jun Chen},
  title = {{Optimize configuration of multi-energy storage system in a standalone microgrid}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Energy Research},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fenrg.2023.1283859},
}
Figure