Optimization Strategy of SVC for Eliminating Electromagnetic Oscillation in Weak Networking Power Systems

Huabo Shi, Xinwei Sun, Gang Chen, Hua Zhang, Tang Yong-hong, Lin Xu, Lijie Ding, Chengwei Fan, Yin XuEnergies 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of electromagnetic oscillations in weak power grids caused by Static VAR Compensators (SVCs), which are crucial for voltage regulation. The authors propose a novel optimization strategy for SVC control parameters that balances improved voltage regulation with effective suppression of these potentially destabilizing oscillations, validated through simulations and real-world tests.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Central Tibet AC Interconnection Project (CTAIP) is a critical, yet challenging, ultra-long distance transmission system connecting the Tibet and Sichuan power grids. Due to its long tie-lines and weak connections, the system suffers from poor voltage regulation. To address this, six large-capacity SVCs were installed. However, these SVCs, while improving voltage regulation, can inadvertently excite low-frequency electromagnetic oscillations (below 50 Hz), a phenomenon that can destabilize the power grid. The core problem is finding a way to tune the SVCs' control parameters to maintain their essential voltage regulation function without exacerbating or causing these dangerous oscillations.

Methods

The authors employ a multi-faceted approach:

  • Eigenvalue Analysis: They use eigenvalue analysis to identify and quantify the electromagnetic oscillation modes within the system and assess how SVC parameters influence their damping.
  • Contradiction Identification: A key insight is the inherent conflict between aggressive PI (Proportional-Integral) control parameters for SVCs, which enhance voltage regulation, and their tendency to weaken the damping of electromagnetic oscillations.
  • Dual-Objective Optimization: A novel optimization strategy is developed that defines two key performance indices:
  • Voltage Regulation Performance: Measured by the rise time (T0.9) and settling time (Ts) of the SVC's reactive power or admittance response to a voltage reference step.
  • Electromagnetic Oscillation Suppression: Measured by the damping ratio of the identified low-frequency oscillation modes.
  • Comprehensive Objective Function: These two indices are combined into a single objective function, weighted to prioritize oscillation suppression.
  • Intelligent Optimization Algorithm: An optimization algorithm is applied to find the optimal PI parameters (Kp and Ki) for the SVCs.
  • Multi-SVC Optimization Strategy: A systematic process is outlined for optimizing parameters when multiple SVCs are present in a large grid.
  • Simulation and Experimental Validation: The proposed method is validated using PSCAD/EMTDC and RTDS (Real-Time Digital Simulator) for simulations, and an artificial grounding short-circuit test for real-world engineering verification.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilizes system models and parameters derived from the CTAIP and a simplified test system.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Inherent Oscillation Mode: Ultra-long transmission lines (like CTAIP's >1400 km) inherently possess low-frequency oscillation modes below 50 Hz.
  • SVCs as Oscillation Exciters: SVCs, particularly with aggressive PI control settings for fast voltage regulation, can significantly weaken the damping of these inherent oscillation modes, increasing the risk of instability.
  • The PI Parameter Dilemma: There's a direct trade-off: increasing PI gains (Kp, Ki) improves voltage regulation speed but degrades oscillation damping. Reducing them does the opposite.
  • Quantifying the Trade-off: The paper successfully quantifies this trade-off by defining specific performance indices for both voltage regulation (rise time, settling time) and oscillation damping.
  • A Balanced Solution: The proposed optimization strategy provides a systematic way to find a "sweet spot" for PI parameters, achieving acceptable voltage regulation while effectively suppressing oscillations.
  • Multi-SVC Complexity: Optimizing multiple SVCs simultaneously is complex, and the paper proposes a sequential, iterative approach to manage this.

Key Results

  • The proposed optimization strategy successfully suppressed electromagnetic oscillations in simulations (PSCAD/EMTDC and RTDS) and in a real-world artificial grounding short-circuit test on the CTAIP.
  • In simulations, oscillations that were previously slow to decay were observed to decay rapidly after optimization.
  • The engineering verification showed that SVCs operated correctly, did not cause unstable oscillations, and maintained high reactive power response speed.
  • While the optimization slightly reduced the reactive power regulation performance (e.g., T0.9 decreased by less than 0.07s, Ts by less than 0.13s in one case), this was deemed an acceptable trade-off for enhanced system stability.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Simplification: The optimization was initially performed on a simplified model before being applied to the CTAIP. While validated, further investigation into the impact of more complex system models could be beneficial.
  • Parameter Range: The PI parameter optimization was conducted within defined ranges. Exploring broader ranges or different optimization algorithms might yield further improvements.
  • Multi-SVC Optimization: While a strategy for multi-SVC optimization is proposed, its practical implementation and scalability to very large, complex grids could be a subject for future research.
  • Other Disturbances: The study focused on specific fault scenarios. Investigating the robustness of the optimized parameters under a wider range of system disturbances (e.g., load variations, renewable energy integration) would be valuable.

Summary updated

Abstract

The central Tibet AC interconnection project (CTAIP), which connects the Tibet power grid and the Sichuan power grid through a long distance transmission line of more than 1400 km, has a significant problem of voltage regulation. In order to improve the voltage regulation performance, six sets of ±60 Mvar static VAR compensators (SVC) were installed in the CTAIP. However, the SVCs may lead to electromagnetic oscillation below 50 Hz while improving voltage regulation capability. In this paper, the electromagnetic oscillation modes and the sensitivity of control parameters of SVC are analyzed. Then, the characteristics and influencing factors of the oscillation are discussed. It was found that there is an inherent electromagnetic oscillation mode below 50 Hz in the ultra-long distance transmission system. The employ of SVCs weaken the damping of this mode. Large proportional gain and integral gain (PI) parameters of SVCs can improve the voltage regulation performance, but weaken the electromagnetic oscillation mode damping. Therefore, a suppression method based on SVC PI parameters optimization is proposed to damp the oscillation. The essential of this method is to use the rising time of voltage response and setting time of SVCs as performance indicators of voltage regulation, and take the damping level of the electromagnetic oscillation mode as the performance index of SVC electromagnetic oscillation suppression ability. Combining the two indicators to form a comprehensive optimization index function, an intelligent optimization algorithm is applied. The process of SVC parameter optimization and the steps of multi-SVC parameter optimization in large power grids is proposed. Finally, PSCAD and real-time digital simulation (RTDS) simulation results verified the correctness of the proposed method. The optimization strategy was applied to CTAIP. The artificial grounding short circuit experimental results proved the effectiveness of the proposed strategy.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{shi2019optimization,
  author = {Huabo Shi and Xinwei Sun and Gang Chen and Hua Zhang and Tang Yong-hong and Lin Xu and Lijie Ding and Chengwei Fan and Yin Xu},
  title = {{Optimization Strategy of SVC for Eliminating Electromagnetic Oscillation in Weak Networking Power Systems}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/en12183489},
}
Figure