Optimization of stray capacitance based on CVT harmonic voltage measurement

Ran Zhuo, Wanwei Wang, Yan Luo, Rongfu Zhong, Zhiming Huang, Qiye DuJOURNAL 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the problem of inaccurate voltage measurements from Capacitive Voltage Transformers (CVTs) in power systems experiencing harmonic pollution. By developing an optimized equivalent circuit model and employing a multi-objective grey wolf optimization algorithm, the researchers accurately identify and correct the impact of stray capacitance, significantly improving CVT measurement accuracy under harmonic conditions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Modern power systems increasingly utilize nonlinear power electronic devices, leading to significant harmonic pollution. This harmonic content can severely degrade the measurement accuracy of traditional voltage transformers, particularly Capacitive Voltage Transformers (CVTs). While much research has focused on CVT performance under standard power frequencies, the impact of harmonics, specifically the influence of stray capacitance on harmonic transmission characteristics, has been insufficiently addressed. Stray capacitances, often overlooked or simplified, can introduce significant errors in harmonic environments, compromising the reliability of power system monitoring and control. This paper aims to bridge this gap by providing a method to accurately quantify and mitigate the effects of stray capacitance on CVT measurements in the presence of harmonics.

Methods

The core of this research lies in a two-pronged approach:

  1. Equivalent Circuit Modeling and Simulation: The authors first establish a detailed equivalent circuit model for a CVT, explicitly including key stray capacitances (Cs for the compensation reactor and Cp1 for the intermediate transformer's primary winding). They then use Simulink to simulate this model, capturing resonance phenomena. This simulation-driven approach allows for the quantification of stray capacitance's impact on the CVT's voltage transfer characteristics under various harmonic conditions.
  2. Multi-Objective Grey Wolf Optimization (MOGWO): To find the optimal values for the stray capacitance parameters (Cs and Cp1), the researchers employ the MOGWO algorithm. This algorithm is chosen for its ability to handle multi-objective optimization problems, which is crucial for balancing accuracy across different harmonic frequencies. The objective function is defined to minimize the relative error between the calculated and actual voltage ratios of the CVT. The MOGWO algorithm iteratively searches for the Pareto optimal set of stray capacitance values, leading to a refined set of parameters that minimize harmonic measurement errors.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study uses a specific CVT model (TYD35/√3-0.02HF) with provided parameters for simulation and analysis, rather than relying on external datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Stray Capacitance is a Major Harmonic Culprit: The research strongly emphasizes that stray capacitance, often a secondary consideration, plays a critical role in distorting CVT measurements under harmonic conditions. Its influence is not uniform and can lead to significant errors, especially at specific resonant frequencies.
  • Resonance Frequencies are Key: The study identifies specific resonance frequencies (f₁ = 150 Hz and f₂ = 200 Hz) where stray capacitance has the most pronounced effect. This insight is crucial for focusing optimization efforts on these critical ranges.
  • MOGWO for Precise Optimization: The application of the Multi-Objective Grey Wolf Optimizer proves effective in navigating the complex trade-offs involved in optimizing stray capacitance across multiple harmonic frequencies, leading to a more robust solution than single-objective approaches.
  • Optimized Parameters Significantly Reduce Error: The optimized stray capacitance values lead to a substantial reduction in voltage transfer error, particularly at higher frequencies, demonstrating the practical efficacy of the proposed method.

Key Results

  • The study successfully identified resonance frequencies at 150 Hz and 200 Hz, highlighting critical points for stray capacitance impact.
  • Using MOGWO, the optimal stray capacitance values were determined to be Cs = 287.598 pF and Cp1 = 116.672 pF at 300 iterations.
  • The proposed method reduced the voltage transfer error under harmonic conditions to 0.33%, a significant improvement.
  • An ablation study showed that removing either Cs or Cp1 from the model led to a substantial increase in error, underscoring the importance of optimizing both. A single-objective optimization approach resulted in imbalanced error reduction, with errors increasing at 200 Hz.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Specific Application Requirements: The authors acknowledge that while their method is effective, the "actual" optimal stray capacitance value should ultimately be determined based on specific application requirements, considering unique harmonic characteristics and frequency distributions.
  • Computational Efficiency: Future research should focus on enhancing the computational efficiency of the MOGWO algorithm for real-time optimization in dynamic power systems.
  • Adaptability and Stability: The adaptability and stability of the method need further verification under complex nonlinear loads and high-order harmonic interference conditions.
  • Experimental Validation: Practical engineering environments require experimental validation to complement the simulation-based findings.
  • Integration with Smart Grids: Integrating this optimization strategy with smart grid systems could advance harmonic monitoring and optimization in modern power systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

With the wide application of nonlinear power electronic devices in power systems, the problem of harmonic pollution is becoming more and more serious, which significantly affects the measurement accuracy of voltage transformers (especially capacitive voltage transformers, CVT). The existing research focuses on the performance optimization of CVT under power frequency conditions, and the research on measurement error under harmonic conditions is insufficient. In particular, the influence of stray capacitance on harmonic transmission characteristics has not been fully paid attention to. Therefore, this paper aims to solve the problem of CVT measurement error in harmonic environment. By proposing an optimization method based on equivalent circuit model, the key stray capacitance parameters are accurately identified and corrected, to improve its measurement accuracy. Firstly, the equivalent circuit model of CVT is established, and the resonance phenomenon data is captured by Simulink simulation technology. The objective function based on the relative error of voltage transfer coefficient is defined, and the Pareto solution set is calculated by optimization algorithm to identify the optimal stray capacitance parameters. After applying this parameter to the circuit model, the voltage transfer coefficient of CVT is corrected, which significantly reduces the measurement error in harmonic environment. This study not only provides a theoretical basis for the high-precision measurement of CVT in power system, but also provides a reference for practical technical application.
BibTeX
@article{zhuo2023optimization,
  author = {Ran Zhuo and Wanwei Wang and Yan Luo and Rongfu Zhong and Zhiming Huang and Qiye Du},
  title = {{Optimization of stray capacitance based on CVT harmonic voltage measurement}},
  journal = {JOURNAL},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.61702/80vhpp67},
}

Loading related content...

Figure