Optimization of Steam Distribution Mode for Turbine Units Based on Governing Valve Characteristic Modeling

Lei Zhang, Zongliang Qiao, Bingsen Hei, Youfei Tang, Shasha LiuEnergies 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of optimizing steam turbine efficiency during peak-regulation operations, a growing necessity with increased renewable energy integration. By developing a detailed model of governing valve characteristics and simulating various steam distribution modes, the authors propose a refined "composite sliding pressure" strategy that significantly improves economic efficiency and reduces environmental impact.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing integration of renewable energy sources like wind and solar power necessitates that traditional thermal power plants, particularly coal-fired units, become more flexible and participate in "peak-regulating" operations. This means these units must efficiently adjust their output to balance the grid's fluctuating supply and demand. A critical factor influencing a turbine unit's economic performance, especially at lower loads, is its steam distribution mode. Existing operational data and models from manufacturers often don't reflect real-world conditions after years of use. Therefore, there's a need to accurately model turbine behavior under off-design conditions and identify optimal steam distribution strategies to improve efficiency and reduce operational costs and environmental emissions.

Methods

The authors employ a multi-pronged approach:

  • Theoretical Modeling: They derive theoretical models for the governing valve and governing stage, focusing on flow characteristics and pressure relationships.
  • Software Simulation: The APROS (Advanced Process Simulation) software is used to build a comprehensive simulation model of a 600 MW turbine unit. This model incorporates the governing valve, governing stage, and other key components like turbines (HP, IP, LP), heaters, and condensers.
  • Field Data Validation: The theoretical models and the APROS simulation results are validated against field test data from a real power plant. This ensures the model's reliability in representing actual operating conditions.
  • Comparative Analysis: Three primary steam distribution modes are analyzed: nozzle steam distribution, throttling steam distribution, and sliding pressure steam distribution. Their advantages, disadvantages, and economic impacts are thoroughly discussed.
  • Optimization: The study systematically analyzes the heat rate (a measure of efficiency) at various loads and main steam pressures under different operating modes. This allows for the determination of the most economical operating points and the development of an optimized steam distribution strategy.

Datasets

The paper utilizes field test data from a 600 MW power plant unit for model validation. Specific data points include power load, flow rate, steam pressures, temperatures, and heat rates under various operating conditions (VWO, TMCR, THA, 75% Vapor Extraction). No new benchmark datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Governing Valve Model Accuracy: The derived theoretical model for the governing valve and governing stage, when validated with field data, shows good agreement, providing a reliable basis for further simulation and optimization.
  • Sliding Pressure's Economic Advantage: Sliding pressure operation generally offers better economy than constant pressure operation, especially at lower loads, by minimizing throttling losses.
  • Composite Sliding Pressure is Key: A "composite sliding pressure" operation scheme, which combines constant pressure and sliding pressure modes across different load ranges, is identified as the most effective strategy for optimizing the unit's economy.
  • Load-Dependent Optimization: The optimal steam distribution mode and main steam pressure are highly dependent on the unit's load. What's optimal at one load may not be at another.
  • Significant Economic and Environmental Gains: Implementing the optimized operation mode can lead to substantial savings in coal consumption and significant reductions in carbon dioxide and sulfur dioxide emissions.

Key Results

  • The developed turbine model demonstrated good reliability, with main thermal parameters showing relative errors within 2% compared to field data.
  • The study recommends a specific optimized operation mode: sliding pressure operation for loads between 310 MW and 470 MW, with a main steam pressure range of 9.7-16.7 MPa. For loads below 310 MW and above 470 MW, constant pressure operation is recommended.
  • For an average annual load of 400 MW, the optimized operation mode is projected to save approximately 2721.61 tons of standard coal annually, yielding an economic benefit of 1.91 million yuan.
  • Environmental benefits include a reduction of 1850.69 tons of carbon emissions and 54.43 tons of sulfur dioxide emissions annually.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Simplifications: While the model is validated, it's based on a specific 600 MW unit. Its direct applicability to other turbine sizes or designs might require re-validation.
  • Field Data Granularity: The paper relies on existing field data. More granular data, especially across a wider range of off-design conditions, could further refine the models.
  • Boiler-Turbine Coordination: While the paper mentions coordinated control, a deeper dive into the dynamic interaction and optimization between the boiler and turbine during rapid load changes could be a future direction.
  • Advanced Control Strategies: Exploring more advanced control algorithms for implementing the optimized sliding pressure strategy in real-time could be a valuable next step.

Summary updated

Abstract

With the extensive application of renewable energy generation, thermal power units are required to participate in peak-regulating operations. The mode of steam distribution significantly influences the economy when the steam turbine operates at a low load. The turbine unit’s governing valve characteristics and steam distribution modes are studied in this paper, and the optimal sliding pressure operation curve is derived. Firstly, the theoretical model of the governing stage and the governing valve is derived, and the reliability is verified with field data. Secondly, the overall simulation model of the turbine unit is established, and the turbine off-design performance is analyzed with variable main steam pressure. Finally, the advantages and disadvantages of the three steam distribution modes are discussed thoroughly. The steam distribution modes and optimal main steam pressures are analyzed. The results show that a precise composite sliding pressure operation scheme is recommended, and a sliding pressure operation mode is adopted under 470 MW and constant pressure operation for others.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2022optimization,
  author = {Lei Zhang and Zongliang Qiao and Bingsen Hei and Youfei Tang and Shasha Liu},
  title = {{Optimization of Steam Distribution Mode for Turbine Units Based on Governing Valve Characteristic Modeling}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/en15239139},
}
Figure