Optimization of Granulation Process for Binder-Free Biochar-Based Fertilizer from Digestate and Its Slow-Release Performance

Yu Zhou, Jie Zhao, Yinfeng Hua, M Kellis, Qincheng Chen, Guoqing ShenSustainability 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper optimizes the granulation process for creating binder-free biochar-based fertilizer from biogas residue and chemical fertilizer. The resulting pellets exhibit excellent physical properties and a sustained-release of essential nutrients (N, P, K), offering a promising eco-friendly fertilizer for sustainable agriculture.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing global population generates vast amounts of kitchen waste, posing environmental and economic challenges. While anaerobic digestion offers a solution for waste management, the resulting biogas residues, though rich in nutrients, present issues when applied directly to soil. These include high nutrient mobility leading to loss and water eutrophication, potential phytotoxicity, and handling difficulties due to their viscosity and odor. Traditional biochar-based fertilizers, often prepared by mixing or coating, can be brittle, low-density, and inconvenient for storage and transportation. This study addresses the need for a more practical and effective biochar-based fertilizer by optimizing the granulation of biogas residue with chemical fertilizer into binder-free pellets, aiming to improve handling, reduce nutrient loss, and enhance slow-release properties.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-stage approach:

  1. Biochar Preparation: Biogas residue was pyrolyzed at 500°C to produce biochar (RB).
  2. Fertilizer Mixing: The RB was mixed with commercial compound fertilizer (CF) at a 2:1 ratio.
  3. Pelletization:
    • Single-Factor Experiments: Initial experiments systematically varied moisture content (5-15%), compression speed (40-100 mm/min), molding pressure (2.5-10 MPa), and pellet diameter (5-8 mm) to understand their individual effects on pellet properties (compressive strength, equilibrium moisture content (ECM) for hydrophobicity, and durability).
  4. Response Surface Methodology (RSM): A Box-Behnken design was used to optimize three key factors (compression speed, moisture content, and diameter) for compressive strength, ECM, and durability. This statistical approach allows for the identification of optimal parameter combinations and their interactions.
  5. Drying: Pellets were dried at various temperatures (25°C to 185°C) to investigate their impact on properties and slow-release performance.
  6. Characterization:
    • Physical Properties: Compressive strength, durability (MICUM test), and hydrophobicity (ECM) were measured.
  7. Chemical Structure: FTIR and XRD analyses were used to understand the chemical bonds and crystal structures of the biochar and fertilizer pellets, particularly how they interact.
  8. Surface Area and Porosity: BET analysis was performed to assess the pore structure of the materials.
  9. Thermal Stability: Thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) and derivative thermogravimetric analysis (DTG) were conducted to evaluate the thermal decomposition behavior.
  10. Slow-Release Kinetics: Nutrient (N, P, K) release experiments were performed over 413 hours, and the data were fitted to a first-order kinetic model to quantify the release rates.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilizes self-generated materials (biogas residue, commercial fertilizer) and experimental data derived from laboratory procedures.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Binder-Free Optimization is Crucial: The study successfully demonstrates that binder-free pellets can achieve excellent physical properties and slow-release performance, avoiding potential environmental issues associated with binders.
  • Synergistic Interaction: The interaction between biochar and chemical fertilizer is not merely physical mixing; chemical reactions and hydrogen bonding play a significant role in binding nutrients and improving pellet integrity, especially at higher drying temperatures.
  • Drying Temperature is a Double-Edged Sword: While higher drying temperatures enhance nutrient binding and slow-release properties (particularly for P), excessively high temperatures (above 145°C) can lead to excessive fluidity of the molten fertilizer, potential loss, and changes in crystal structure.
  • Optimized Parameters Yield Superior Pellets: The identified optimal granulation parameters (moisture content 7.84%, diameter 7 mm, compression speed 49.54 mm/min, molding pressure 7.5 MPa) result in pellets with high compressive strength and durability, and good hydrophobicity.
  • Nutrient-Specific Release: The slow-release performance varies by nutrient, with phosphorus showing the most sustained release, followed by nitrogen and then potassium. This differential release can be beneficial for plant nutrition.

Key Results

  • Optimal Pellet Properties: The best-performing pellets were achieved with a moisture content of 7.84%, a diameter of 7 mm, a compression speed of 49.54 mm/min, and a molding pressure of 7.5 MPa. These pellets exhibited a compressive strength of 427.77 N, an equilibrium moisture content (ECM) of 17.70% (indicating good hydrophobicity), and a durability of 99.24%.
  • Enhanced Slow Release: The binder-free RBF pellets demonstrated significantly improved sustained-release properties for N, P, and K compared to the control (CF). For example, after 32 hours, N release from RBF was substantially lower than CF (e.g., 11.31% for RBF-185 vs. 93.64% for CF).
  • Impact of Drying Temperature: Increasing drying temperature generally improved nutrient binding and slow-release performance. RBF-185 (dried at 185°C) showed the lowest cumulative N release (41.71% after 413h).
  • Nutrient Release Order: The sustained-release effect was best for P, followed by N, and then K.
  • Model Validation: The RSM model showed high R² values (e.g., 0.9978 for compressive strength), indicating its validity in predicting optimal parameters. Relative errors between predicted and measured values were very low (e.g., 0.11% for durability).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Drying Temperature Limit: The study suggests that drying temperatures should not be excessively high (e.g., above 145°C) to avoid potential loss of fertilizer components due to excessive fluidity and decomposition. Further research could explore the optimal balance between temperature and drying time.
  • Nutrient-Specific Release: While the differential release of N, P, and K is noted, further investigation into tailoring this release profile for specific crop needs could be beneficial.
  • Field Trials: The study was conducted under laboratory conditions. Future work should involve field trials to evaluate the performance of these RBF pellets in actual agricultural settings, assessing their impact on crop yield and soil health.
  • Long-Term Effects: While the study demonstrates sustained release over 413 hours, longer-term studies would be valuable to fully understand the long-term benefits and potential environmental impacts.
  • Kitchen Waste Recycling Integration: The paper highlights the potential for combining kitchen waste recycling with sustainable agriculture. Future research could focus on scaling up production and integrating this process into existing waste management and agricultural systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

Granulation of biochar-based fertilizer is one potential method to reduce transportation costs, provide for enhanced handling, and decrease the loss of fertilizer during soil application. This study aimed to synthesize binder-free biogas residue biochar-based fertilizer (RBF) pellets and investigate their physical properties and slow-release potential. Results showed that the physical properties and forming quality of the pellets reached the best when the moisture content was 7.84%, the diameter was 7 mm, the compression speed was 49.54 mm/min, and the molding pressure was 7.5 MPa. Sustained-release kinetic analysis and characterization results identified that the RBF had excellent nitrogen (N), phosphorus (P), and potassium (K) sustained release properties. The sustained release of nutrients gradually increased with the drying temperature, and the sustained-release effect of P was the best, followed by that of N and K. Therefore, RBF pellets may be applied as a green slow-release fertilizer in agricultural production. Physical, chemical, and slow-release properties could be improved by optimizing the drying and granulation process parameters, thus providing a new idea for the combination of kitchen waste recycling and sustainable agricultural development.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhou2021optimization,
  author = {Yu Zhou and Jie Zhao and Yinfeng Hua and M Kellis and Qincheng Chen and Guoqing Shen},
  title = {{Optimization of Granulation Process for Binder-Free Biochar-Based Fertilizer from Digestate and Its Slow-Release Performance}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/su13158573},
}
Figure