Optimization of ESS Scheduling for Cost Reduction in Commercial and Industry Customers in Korea

Moonjong Jang, Ho‐Jin Choi, Chae-Gyun Lim, Byoungwoong An, Jungsub SimSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes a novel ESS scheduling optimization framework that simultaneously minimizes both peak demand charges and energy costs for commercial and industrial customers in Korea. The study reveals that demand charges are a higher priority for cost reduction than energy charges, and that customer-centric ESS optimization can also benefit the utility's grid stability.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The global push towards net-zero emissions has increased interest in energy efficiency, with Energy Storage Systems (ESSs) playing a crucial role. Utilities aim to improve operational efficiency and reduce investment costs by managing peak demand and load leveling. While many ESS scheduling optimization techniques exist, they often focus on either peak shaving or load balancing independently. This paper addresses the need for a unified approach that considers both objectives simultaneously for commercial and industrial customers, particularly within the context of Korea's specific electricity tariff structure, which heavily penalizes peak demand. The challenge lies in balancing the customer's desire for cost reduction with the utility's need for grid stability, all while navigating complex time-of-use (TOU) pricing.

Methods

The authors propose a cost-based ESS scheduling optimization framework that integrates two key algorithms:

  • Peak Demand Reduction Algorithm (PDRA): This algorithm focuses on minimizing the annual peak load, which directly impacts the demand charge component of the electricity bill. It aims to shave the highest peaks in the load profile.
  • Energy Cost Reduction Algorithm (ECRA): This algorithm focuses on load leveling and arbitrage, leveraging the differences in TOU electricity rates to reduce the energy charge component. It aims to shift energy consumption from high-cost periods to low-cost periods.

These two algorithms are orchestrated within a solver that takes electric demand data, ESS capacity, and electricity tariffs as input. The framework defines objective functions and constraints to guide the optimization process, including ESS state-of-charge limits, charging/discharging rates, and the overall system peak load. The optimization aims to find a daily ESS schedule that minimizes the total electricity bill.

Datasets

The study utilizes real-world data for its case study:

  • Electric Power Load Data: Acquired from a KEPCO (Korea Electric Power Corporation) branch office for the period of October 1, 2019, to March 31, 2020.
  • ESS Information: Including maximum ESS capacity, charging/discharging efficiency, and PCS capacity.
  • Electricity Tariff Data: Specifically, the "General Service (A) II" tariff plan from KEPCO, which includes demand charges and time-of-use energy charges across different seasons and periods.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Demand Charge Dominance: The research strongly suggests that for commercial and industrial customers in Korea, reducing the demand charge is a higher priority for overall cost savings than reducing the energy charge. This is due to the significant impact of the annual peak load on the base rate.
  • Synergistic Benefits: Optimizing ESS schedules for customer cost reduction also contributes positively to the utility's power system operation and stability, aligning with the utility's rate policies.
  • Prioritization is Key: The study highlights that there's a clear hierarchy among ESS scheduling objectives, with peak shaving (addressing demand charges) being more impactful than simple load balancing (addressing energy charges).
  • Integrated Approach Pays Off: A combined strategy of peak shaving and load balancing yields better results than either strategy implemented in isolation.

Key Results

The case study demonstrated significant cost reductions through the proposed ESS scheduling optimization:

  • Peak Demand Reduction: In scenarios with peak demand, the ESS scheduling for peak shaving reduced the peak load by approximately 10-15% (e.g., from 194.0 kW to 177.8 kW on September 19, 2019).
  • Cost Savings: Comparative cost analysis showed that the combined peak shaving and load balancing method achieved the highest daily gains, ranging from 1.7% to 1.9% on specific days and 2.4% monthly.
  • Demand Charge Impact: The majority of cost savings were attributed to reductions in demand charges, underscoring their importance.
  • Load Balancing Benefits: While less impactful than peak shaving for overall cost reduction, load balancing effectively shifted energy consumption to lower-cost periods, leading to energy charge savings.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The study did not consider the value of energy storage devices themselves (e.g., degradation, lifespan) in the cost analysis, focusing solely on operational costs.
  • The analysis was based on a specific tariff structure and a single branch office's data.
  • Future Work:
    • Improving the accuracy of electric power demand prediction for individual customers.
  • Developing cost-effective approaches that integrate photovoltaics (PV) and ESS, considering weather-dependent solar power output.
  • Researching methods to estimate the optimal ESS installation capacity in advance to guide investment decisions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Various attempts have been made to reduce carbon emissions in the energy sector as part of global net zero emissions trends. Among them, interest in the use of energy storage systems (ESSs) for energy efficiency is growing. Utilities intend to improve the efficiency of investment and operating costs by reducing the maximum peak and leveling the load. Many ESS-scheduling optimization techniques have been studied to reduce the peak demand, balance the load, or reduce the cost corresponding to these two purposes from the customer’s point of view. In this paper, a method for cost minimization that simultaneously considers both the peak demand and load balancing is proposed, and the results and analysis of a case study in Korea Electric Power Corporation (KEPCO), Korea are presented. Through these results, we show that there is a priority among the objective functions of the ESS schedule, that demand charge is more important than energy charge, and that the ESS schedule problem for customers to reduce costs is also beneficial to power system operation by the utility’s rate policy.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jang2022optimization,
  author = {Moonjong Jang and Ho‐Jin Choi and Chae-Gyun Lim and Byoungwoong An and Jungsub Sim},
  title = {{Optimization of ESS Scheduling for Cost Reduction in Commercial and Industry Customers in Korea}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su14063605},
}
Figure