Optimization of emergency allocation of necessities of life based on fractal perspective

Hong Li, Zhe Zhou, Chuan Hu, Yumei Ning, Zihao Wang, Huang Hua, Kangsheng TaoFrontiers in Public Health 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a Fractal Multi-level Distribution Network (FMDN) model designed to optimize the delivery of life necessities during large-scale disasters. By applying fractal theory, the researchers created a self-organizing system that accounts for road damage and fluctuating demand, successfully identifying cost-effective distribution paths in a case study of the 2010 Yushu earthquake.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the wake of a sudden catastrophe—like an earthquake or a pandemic—the demand for food, medicine, and shelter spikes "geometrically" while infrastructure often crumbles. Traditional logistics models frequently struggle with two major issues:

  1. Dynamic Uncertainty: It is nearly impossible to predict exactly how much of a specific resource is needed at a specific disaster point as the situation evolves.
  2. Infrastructure Fragility: Road damage significantly slows down transport, yet many models assume static travel speeds.

The authors argue that emergency management needs a more flexible, decentralized approach. They turn to fractal theory—the study of complex systems that are self-similar across different scales—to build a distribution network that can decompose complex tasks into autonomous, manageable units.

Methods

The authors propose the FMDN model, a three-tier hierarchy consisting of a Top-level Distribution Center (government/decision-makers), a Fractal Distribution Center Layer (logistics alliances), and a Sub-distribution Center Layer (execution units).

Key technical components include:

  • Fractal Self-Organization: Unlike rigid top-down systems, each "fractal unit" in this model can make independent decisions and adapt to local changes while remaining aligned with the overall goal.
  • Road Condition Coefficient ($\beta$): The model incorporates a variable ($0 \leq \beta \leq 1$) that adjusts vehicle speed based on the severity of road damage, making the delivery time estimates more realistic.
  • Robust Optimization for Demand: Instead of a single demand number, the authors use interval estimates. They introduce a control parameter ($\gamma$) to manage "demand disturbance," allowing the model to find solutions that remain feasible even if actual needs vary by 5% to 30% from initial estimates.
  • Mathematical Solving: The model was implemented and solved using LINGO 11.0, a software package for linear and non-linear programming.

Datasets

The paper validates the model using a numerical experiment based on the 7.1 Richter scale earthquake in Yushu, Qinghai Province, China.

  • Nodes: The simulation included 6 emergency reserve points, 4 regional distribution centers, and 6 demand points.
  • Parameters: The researchers used localized data for fixed construction costs, unit mileage transportation costs, and shortest distribution distances between nodes.
  • Comparison Data: The study compared three model variations: the Stochastic Demand Model, the Relative Robust Model, and the Absolute Robust Model.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Power of Self-Similarity: By treating distribution centers as fractal elements, the system gains "self-affinity." This means a small local unit operates using the same logic as the national command center, allowing for faster, decentralized responses without losing coordination.
  • Penalty Costs as a Driver: The model doesn't just look at transport costs; it includes "penalty costs" for failing to meet demand. This forces the optimization to prioritize speed and reliability over simple fuel efficiency.
  • Robustness vs. Cost: The study highlights a classic engineering trade-off. The "Absolute Robust" model (which prepares for the worst-case demand) is more expensive than the stochastic model but ensures that the system doesn't collapse if demand spikes unexpectedly.

Key Results

  • Optimal Configuration: For the Yushu case study, the model identified a specific optimal path: distributing materials from reserve point r4 through distribution center d3.
  • Financial Feasibility: The total operating cost for the optimized network was calculated at 367.31 million yuan.
  • Sensitivity to Disturbance: As the "disturbance coefficient" (the level of demand uncertainty) increased from 5% to 30%, the total cost rose accordingly. Specifically, the Absolute Robust model's cost increased from ~37,987 units to ~44,268 units, demonstrating the "price" of ensuring a reliable safety net in high-uncertainty environments.
  • Efficiency: The deviation between the relatively robust and stochastic models remained under 5%, suggesting that the robust approach provides significant reliability gains for a relatively small increase in cost.

Limitations and Future Work

While the FMDN model is a step forward in disaster logistics, the authors acknowledge several gaps:

  • Perishability: The current model treats all "necessities" as durable goods. It does not account for the shelf-life of fresh food or the specific requirements of cold-chain logistics for certain medicines.
  • Multi-modal Transport: The study focuses primarily on road transport. Future iterations could incorporate air, rail, or water transport to provide a more comprehensive "fractal" view of a national logistics network.
  • Real-time Data: The model currently relies on interval estimates; integrating real-time IoT data from vehicles and disaster sites could further refine the "road condition coefficient" during an active crisis.

Summary updated

Abstract

The supply and reserves of emergency necessities of life are important for emergency management in disaster events. The scope of the necessities of life changes with social development, and their reserves and allocation in sudden disaster events continually face new challenges. Timely distribution of the necessities of life during disasters is critical to saving lives and maintaining social order. Therefore, this study proposes a fractal multi-level distribution network (FMDN) optimization model with multiple warehouse points, multiple emergency distribution centers, and multiple disaster points from the perspective of fractal theory. The FMDN model considers the influence of road damage on vehicle speed and the dynamic change in demand at the affected points. The FMDN model aims to minimize the operating costs of a distribution network, including the cost of building emergency reserve points, transportation costs, and penalty costs for lack of demand. Numerical experiments verify the feasibility of the model. The FMDN model is solved using LINGO software programming, and an optimal distribution path and quantity are obtained. Analyzing the numerical example results shows that the model is suitable for emergencies and has good applicability.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2023optimization,
  author = {Hong Li and Zhe Zhou and Chuan Hu and Yumei Ning and Zihao Wang and Huang Hua and Kangsheng Tao},
  title = {{Optimization of emergency allocation of necessities of life based on fractal perspective}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Public Health},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fpubh.2023.1245415},
}
Figure