Optimization of e-commerce logistics service quality considering multiple consumption psychologies

Meng Ma, Lu Shen, XuanQing SunFrontiers in Psychology 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores how to optimize e-commerce logistics by viewing service quality through the lens of consumer psychology. By analyzing a fresh-food e-commerce platform, the researchers identify that while basic metrics like speed and accuracy are high, modern consumers increasingly demand "soft" service improvements like enhanced data privacy, real-time tracking updates, and specialized "delay insurance."

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the 5G era, e-commerce has shifted from a luxury to a daily necessity, particularly for fresh produce. However, the "last mile" of logistics remains a significant bottleneck. While many studies focus purely on operational efficiency (e.g., shortest path algorithms), this paper addresses the human element: consumption psychology.

The authors argue that logistics service quality isn't just about how fast a package arrives, but how the delivery process aligns with different psychological drivers—such as the need for security, the desire for social status, or purely rational "realistic" consumption. The challenge is identifying which specific psychological needs are currently underserved in the competitive fresh-food market.

Methods

The researchers employed a two-pronged approach:

  1. Theoretical Framework: They categorized consumer psychology into four types: conformity (following trends), seeking difference (originality), comparison (status-seeking), and realistic (rational/need-based). They also mapped out the seven stages of the consumer psychological process, from "generating needs" to "feedback on use."
  2. Empirical Case Study: They focused on "E-commerce B," a Chinese vegetable and fruit delivery platform.
  3. Quantitative Analysis: A questionnaire was distributed to 300 people (246 valid responses). To ensure the data was robust, they used the Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin (KMO) test for validity (scoring 0.869, indicating high suitability for factor analysis) and Cronbach’s alpha for reliability (scoring 0.86).

Datasets

The study relies on a primary dataset generated specifically for this research:

  • Survey Data: 246 valid responses from a random sample of consumers.
  • Demographics: The sample was predominantly female (53.87%) and aged 21–40 (77.9%), reflecting the core demographic of online grocery shoppers.
  • Platform Metrics: Historical data from "E-commerce B," noting it surpassed 10 million orders by mid-2020.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Realistic" Consumer Dominates: In the fresh food sector, most consumers operate under "realistic psychology," meaning they prioritize rational factors like applicability, economy, and reliability over "showing off."
  • The Satisfaction Paradox: While over 89% of users were satisfied with commodity quality and delivery speed, significant "hidden" anxieties emerged.
  • New Logistics Frontiers: Consumers are moving beyond "is it here yet?" to "is my data safe?" and "is the food sanitized?"
    • 40.42% of respondents wanted better virus elimination/disinfection protocols (likely influenced by the COVID-19 pandemic).
  • 39.54% demanded real-time logistics updates, showing that information transparency is as important as the physical delivery itself.
  • The Need for "Delay Insurance": Nearly a quarter of consumers (24.97%) expressed interest in insurance specifically for delivery delays, suggesting that psychological peace of mind is a marketable service feature.

Key Results

  • High Baseline Performance: 91.6% of customers rated the accuracy of goods as high/very high, and 89.63% reported that goods arrived on time.
  • Professionalism Gaps: Despite high satisfaction, 26.34% of users want better personal privacy protection, and 21.97% feel the ability of delivery personnel to handle "wrong orders" needs improvement.
  • Optimization Strategies: The authors propose four pillars for improvement:
  • Personnel Management: Using face recognition to prevent "imposter" delivery drivers and enforcing uniform clothing for a professional first impression.
  • Basic Services: Installing refrigeration equipment in busy delivery hubs to prevent rot if a customer is late to pick up an order.
  • Emergency Planning: Developing specific protocols for "force majeure" events like heavy rain or sudden epidemic outbreaks.
  • Cross-Industry Learning: Adopting "best practices" from leaders like Hema Xiansheng to expand service scope into medicines and errands.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several constraints:

  • Limited Scope: The study focused only on one vegetable/fruit platform; results might differ for electronics or luxury goods where "comparison psychology" is stronger.
  • Data Source: The survey data was collected offline, which may introduce a different bias compared to purely online shoppers.
  • Future Directions: The researchers suggest that future studies should conduct "all-round and multi-field research" across various types of e-commerce and combine both online and offline data to create a more holistic model of logistics psychology.

Summary updated

Abstract

This work is developed to improve the current quality of e-commerce logistics services. From the perspective of multiple consumer psychology, based on e-commerce, consumer psychology, and other related theories, vegetable e-commerce B is selected as the research object. The commodity quality, accuracy, and timeliness of commodity distribution and other factors of e-commerce B are discussed through questionnaire survey. Then, according to customers' opinions about "e-commerce B's distribution and professional aspects that need to be improved," the research is conducted. Finally, the direction of follow-up optimization is proposed from four different perspectives of multiple consumption psychology. The research results show that more than 89% of the surveyed customers believe that e-commerce B does a good job in terms of commodity quality, accuracy, and timeliness of commodity distribution, and has a high level of logistics service. However, 26.34% of customers hope that e-commerce B can strengthen the protection of personal privacy, 24.97% hope that the platform can add "delay insurance" for goods, and 39.54% hope that the logistics information of purchased goods can be updated in real time. Therefore, e-commerce B needs to be optimized and improved continuously in the future development. Therefore, research on the optimization of logistics service quality of e-commerce is performed under multiple consumption psychology, which provides certain help for the rapid development of subsequent e-commerce.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ma2022optimization,
  author = {Meng Ma and Lu Shen and XuanQing Sun},
  title = {{Optimization of e-commerce logistics service quality considering multiple consumption psychologies}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2022.956418},
}
Figure