Optimization of a novel lipid extraction process from microalgae

Xiaojie Ren, Chao Wei, Yan Qi, Xin Shan, Mengyun Wu, Xinhe Zhao, Yuanda SongScientific 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces an optimized "solvent-water-solvent" method for extracting lipids from microalgae, significantly boosting yields by incorporating a water treatment step after initial solvent extraction. This approach enhances lipid recovery by disrupting cell membranes and offers a more efficient and environmentally friendly alternative to traditional methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Microalgae are a promising source of lipids for biofuels and other valuable products. However, efficiently extracting these lipids from the robust microalgal cell walls and membranes remains a significant challenge, often requiring harsh conditions or multiple extraction steps that can increase costs and environmental impact. While previous work suggested that washing algae cells before a second extraction could improve efficiency, this study aimed to systematically optimize this "solvent-water-solvent" approach by investigating various solvent systems, water treatment methods (vortex and ultrasonic), treatment durations, and microalgal growth stages. The goal was to find the most effective combination for maximizing lipid yield while minimizing solvent usage and maintaining lipid quality.

Methods

The researchers employed a modified "solvent-water-solvent" lipid extraction protocol. The core innovation lies in the intermediate water treatment step. After an initial organic solvent extraction, the remaining cell biomass was subjected to either vortexing or ultrasonic treatment in the presence of water before a second solvent extraction.

The study systematically varied:

  • Solvent Systems: Acetone, chloroform/methanol (2:1), chloroform/methanol/water (2:2:1), and dichloromethane/methanol (2:1).
  • Water Treatment Types: Vortex and ultrasonic.
  • Water Treatment Time: 0 s (control), 30 s, and 120 s.
  • Microalgae Growth Stages: 3rd, 5th, and 9th day of cultivation.

Lipid yield was quantified using a turbidimetric method based on sulfosalicylic acid. To understand the mechanism behind the improved extraction, scanning electron microscopy (SEM) was used to visualize changes in microalgal cell morphology at different stages of the extraction process.

Datasets

The study utilized microalgae cultures of Phaeodactylum tricornutum (FACHB-2174) and Aurantiochytrium sp. SW1. These were grown under controlled laboratory conditions using specific culture media (MBM for P. tricornutum and a glucose-based medium for A. sp. SW1). The experiments were conducted using algal biomass collected at three different growth stages (3rd, 5th, and 9th days). No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing microalgal strains were used for evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Water Treatment is Key: The intermediate water treatment step is crucial for significantly enhancing lipid extraction efficiency, not just a minor improvement.
  • Synergistic Effects: The effectiveness of water treatment is highly dependent on the specific solvent system used, the duration of the treatment, and the microalgal growth stage. There isn't a one-size-fits-all solution.
  • Mechanism of Action: SEM images reveal that water treatment, particularly with longer durations, effectively disrupts the cell membrane, which is already partially damaged by the initial solvent extraction. This increased membrane permeability allows for more efficient lipid release during the second extraction.
  • Optimizing for Specificity: Different microalgae species and even different growth stages of the same species may require tailored extraction protocols.

Key Results

  • General Improvement: The "solvent-water-solvent" method generally increased total lipid extraction by 10-30% compared to a single solvent extraction.
  • Optimal Combination: The highest lipid yield (47.88% of cell dry weight, or 478 mg/g) was achieved using the chloroform/methanol/water solvent system combined with 120 s of vortex water treatment on the 9th day of cell culture.
  • Dichloromethane/Methanol Boost: Under specific conditions (120 s vortex water treatment), the dichloromethane/methanol solvent system showed a remarkable 61.14% increase in total lipid extracted.
  • Vortex vs. Ultrasonic: While ultrasonic treatment was generally more effective than vortexing for short treatment times (30 s), vortex treatment became more efficient for longer durations (120 s) in certain solvent systems (e.g., acetone, chloroform/methanol/water).
  • Cellular Disruption: SEM confirmed that water treatment significantly disintegrates algal cells and destroys cell membranes, facilitating lipid release.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Species Specificity: While the study focused on Phaeodactylum tricornutum, the authors acknowledge that optimal conditions may vary for other microalgae species. Further research is needed to explore these variations.
  • Growth Stage Sensitivity: The study highlighted that microalgae cells at different growth stages exhibit varying sensitivity to water treatment, suggesting that optimizing extraction based on growth phase is important.
  • Scalability: While the method is presented as having broad application prospects and reducing solvent use, the practical scalability and cost-effectiveness of the optimized "solvent-water-solvent" method for industrial applications would require further investigation.
  • Environmental Impact of Solvents: Although the method aims to reduce solvent amounts, the inherent toxicity and volatility of some organic solvents (like chloroform and dichloromethane) remain a consideration. Exploring greener solvent alternatives in conjunction with this water treatment approach could be a future direction.

Summary updated

Abstract

Previous study found that the solvent extraction efficiency of lipid in microalgae could be greatly improved by washing algae cells before the second time extraction. Based on the "organic solvents-water-organic solvents" method, this research further studied the effect of four solvent systems (acetone, chloroform/methanol, chloroform/methanol/water, dichloromethane/methanol), two types of water treatment (vortex and ultrasonic), three water treatment time gradient (0 s, 30 s, 120 s) on the lipid extraction at three different microalgae growth stages (3rd day, 5th day, 9th day). The results show that the combination of water treatment type, treatment time and solvent is very important to the efficiency of lipid extraction. The total lipid extracted was generally increased by 10-30% after water treatment. Especially under the condition of 120 s vortex water treatment with dichloromethane/methanol as extraction solvent, the total lipid extracted increased by 61.14%. In addition, microalgae cells at different culture stages had different sensitivity to water treatment. In this study, under the combination of chloroform/methanol/water as extraction solvent and vortex water treatment for 120 s, the highest lipid yield was obtained on the ninth day of cell culture, which accounts 47.88% of the cell dry weight (478 mg/g cell dry weight). The changes of cell morphology and structure after water treatment were studied by scanning electron microscope, and it was found that water treatment could seriously destroy the cell membrane damaged by solvent, thus promoting the release of lipids. This study further optimizes the "solvent-water-solvent" lipid extraction method, which neither produces impurities nor damages the lipid quality, and can reduce the amount of organic solvent applied in the classical lipid extraction method with the same lipid yield, so it has a broad application prospect.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ren2021optimization,
  author = {Xiaojie Ren and Chao Wei and Yan Qi and Xin Shan and Mengyun Wu and Xinhe Zhao and Yuanda Song},
  title = {{Optimization of a novel lipid extraction process from microalgae}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-021-99356-z},
}
Figure