Optimization models for sustainable insect production chains

Nisrine Mouhrim, Daniela A. Peguero, Ashley Green, Branca M. Silva, A. Bhatia, Dusan Ristic, Alberto Tonda, Alexander Mathys, Sergiy SmetanaJournal of Insects as Food and Feed 2023 · DOI

Abstract: Insect value chains are a complex system with non-linear links between many economic, environmental, and social variables. Multi-objective optimization (MOO) algorithms for finding optimal options for complex system functioning can provide a valuable insight in the development of sustainable insect chains. This review proposes a framework for MOO application that is based on gradual implementation, beginning with factors that have an immediate impact on insect production (feed qualities, resource utilization, yield), and progressing to integrated units (environmental, social, and economic impacts). The review introduces the key hotspots of insect production chains, which have been developed in suitable MOO objectives. They represent aspects of resource use, feed quality and its conversion by insects, labor safety and wage fairness, as well as environmental impacts. The capacity of the suggested MOO framework to describe all facets of sustainability may have certain limits. To determine the framework’s applicability and the specific MOO algorithms that can perform the function, modeling and further testing on real insect production chains would be necessary for the intended objectives.

Introduction

While edible insects are often touted as a "green" protein solution, the reality of industrial-scale production is highly complex. Current sustainability assessments, such as Life Cycle Assessments (LCAs), are often fragmented and inconsistent. For example, a producer might choose a low-cost waste stream for feed, only to find it slows insect growth or increases the energy required for climate control, ultimately hurting both environmental goals and the bottom line.

Insect value chains are non-linear systems where changing one factor, like feed quality, triggers a cascade of effects across resource use, yield, and social impact. This research seeks to move beyond single-metric evaluations toward a holistic optimization approach that can navigate these conflicting variables.

The Proposed Framework

The authors propose an integrated framework structured into three main stages and nine consecutive steps to guide the application of optimization models.

Framework stages 1 and 2: Modeling and Assessment
Framework stages 2 and 3: Economic Analysis and Optimization

As detailed in the framework, the process moves through three distinct phases:

  1. Modeling & Resource Use: Establishing material flow models, estimating feed properties, and tracking direct biomass transformation (e.g., feed conversion efficiency).
  2. Assessment & Economic Analysis: Conducting cradle-to-gate LCAs, identifying fair wage potentials, and calculating total annual costs (CAPEX and OPEX combined).
  3. Optimization: Identifying data interconnections and applying MOO algorithms—specifically mentioning the NSGA-II (Non-dominated Sorting Genetic Algorithm II)—to find "Pareto optimal" solutions.

What makes this approach novel is the definition of specific mathematical objectives tailored to insects, such as the Nutritional Value of Feed (NVF) index and Fair Wage Potential (FWP), which are integrated into the optimization loop rather than treated as afterthoughts.

Data Synthesis and Insights

As a conceptual review, this paper synthesizes parameters and findings from a wide array of existing literature (e.g., FAOSTAT, IPIFF guides, and various LCA studies). A major hurdle identified is the current "fragmented nature" of data, particularly the gap between lab-scale experiments and industrial-scale reality. The authors emphasize that "scaling factors" must be integrated into models to prevent inaccurate sustainability claims.

Key Results and Sustainability Hotspots

The paper’s primary result is the mathematical definition of 11 key objectives for sustainable insect production:

  • Environmental: Integrated Environmental Impact (ENV), Direct Energy Use (DEU), Renewable Energy Share (RES), and Direct Water Use (DWU).
  • Productive: Amount of Insect Biomass (AIB), Feed Conversion Efficiency (FCE), and Nutritional Value of Feed (NVF).
  • Social/Economic: Fair Wage Potential (FWP), Labor Safety (LS), Total Annual Cost (TAC), and Amount of Insect Frass (AIFr) generated.

The framework identifies feed production and energy use (for climate-controlled rearing) as the primary environmental bottlenecks. Interestingly, while insects can consume waste, the "nutritional match" of that waste to the insect's needs is a critical driver of overall efficiency. Furthermore, the inclusion of "Labor Safety" and "Fair Wage Potential" elevates the framework to a comprehensive ESG (Environmental, Social, and Governance) tool.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors are transparent about several challenges, including a significant lack of standardized data regarding social impacts and large-scale industrial performance. Currently, different studies use different system boundaries, making it hard to compare results. The authors call for the development of Product Environmental Footprint (PEF) Category Rules specifically for insects.

The next step for this research is to test the proposed MOO framework using real-world field data from commercial insect production facilities to refine the algorithms and scaling factors. The authors conclude that MOO is most effective when handling two to six confronting aspects at once, providing a manageable "sweet spot" for computational power and human interpretation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Insect value chains are a complex system with non-linear links between many economic, environmental, and social variables. Multi-objective optimization (MOO) algorithms for finding optimal options for complex system functioning can provide a valuable insight in the development of sustainable insect chains. This review proposes a framework for MOO application that is based on gradual implementation, beginning with factors that have an immediate impact on insect production (feed qualities, resource utilization, yield), and progressing to integrated units (environmental, social, and economic impacts). The review introduces the key hotspots of insect production chains, which have been developed in suitable MOO objectives. They represent aspects of resource use, feed quality and its conversion by insects, labor safety and wage fairness, as well as environmental impacts. The capacity of the suggested MOO framework to describe all facets of sustainability may have certain limits. To determine the framework’s applicability and the specific MOO algorithms that can perform the function, modeling and further testing on real insect production chains would be necessary for the intended objectives.
BibTeX
@article{mouhrim2023optimization,
  author = {Nisrine Mouhrim and Daniela A. Peguero and Ashley Green and Branca M. Silva and A. Bhatia and Dusan Ristic and Alberto Tonda and Alexander Mathys and Sergiy Smetana},
  title = {{Optimization models for sustainable insect production chains}},
  journal = {Journal of Insects as Food and Feed},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1163/23524588-20230148},
}
Figure