Optimization design of brushless DC motor based on improved JAYA algorithm

Cheng Yuan, Xueli Lyu, Shasha MaoScientific 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces an improved JAYA algorithm to optimize the design of brushless DC (BLDC) motors, aiming to boost their efficiency and reduce costs. By enhancing population diversity and introducing adaptive strategies, the proposed algorithm achieves higher average efficiency (94.48%) and better parameter optimization compared to existing methods, leading to improved motor performance.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Brushless DC motors are ubiquitous in industrial applications due to their efficiency and reliability. However, optimizing their design to maximize efficiency and minimize costs is a complex challenge. Traditional optimization methods often struggle with high computational complexity, long processing times, and a tendency to get stuck in local optima. Existing bio-inspired algorithms, while promising, can be sensitive to parameter settings and may suffer from premature convergence, limiting their effectiveness in finding truly optimal solutions for BLDC motor design. This paper addresses the need for a more robust and efficient optimization algorithm that can navigate the complex parameter space of BLDC motors to achieve superior performance.

Methods

The core of this research lies in the development and application of an improved JAYA algorithm. The standard JAYA algorithm, known for its simplicity and speed, can sometimes lead to a lack of population diversity and premature convergence. To overcome this, the authors introduce two key enhancements:

  1. Empirical Learning Strategy: This strategy improves population diversity by allowing individuals to learn from the experiences of others, helping to avoid getting trapped in local optima.
  2. Adaptive Strategy: This strategy balances the algorithm's exploration (searching new areas) and exploitation (refining existing solutions) capabilities. It dynamically adjusts learning strategies and uses an adaptive weight mechanism to control how individuals approach the best and worst solutions. A chaotic elite search strategy is also employed to refine the optimal solution in each iteration.

The paper also details the mathematical model of a BLDC motor, outlining the relationships between various structural parameters (like stator diameter, magnetic induction, and current density) and motor efficiency. This model serves as the objective function for the optimization process.

Datasets

The paper does not introduce new datasets. Instead, it uses the CEC2013 test function suite to evaluate the performance of the proposed algorithms. These functions are standard benchmarks for testing optimization algorithms, encompassing both unimodal (testing development capability) and multimodal (testing exploration capability) functions. The authors also use experimental data derived from BLDC motor simulations and real-world vibration signals for validation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • JAYA's Achilles' Heel: The paper highlights that while JAYA is fast, its single information exchange mechanism can lead to reduced population diversity and premature convergence to local optima.
  • Diversity is Key: The introduction of empirical learning and adaptive strategies significantly boosts population diversity, which is crucial for escaping local optima and finding global solutions.
  • Adaptive Balancing Act: The adaptive strategy effectively balances exploration and exploitation, allowing the algorithm to converge faster in the early stages and refine solutions more precisely later on.
  • Beyond Efficiency: While the primary focus is on efficiency, the adaptive JAYA algorithm also demonstrates effectiveness in reducing vibration signals, suggesting broader benefits for motor performance and longevity.
  • Parameter Optimization is Critical: The study underscores the importance of optimizing specific parameters like stator diameter, tooth magnetic induction, and winding current density for achieving optimal motor performance.

Key Results

The improved and adaptive JAYA algorithms demonstrated significant improvements over the original JAYA algorithm and other comparative methods (PSO, PIO, BSO, DE):

  • Average Efficiency: The improved JAYA algorithm achieved an average motor efficiency of 94.48% in multimodal function operations, with a variation of only 1.2 percentage points between maximum and minimum efficiency.
  • Adaptive JAYA Performance: The adaptive JAYA algorithm showed even greater promise, stabilizing around 93% efficiency with a maximum of 95.3%. This is 5-12 percentage points higher than other comparison algorithms.
  • Convergence Speed: The adaptive JAYA algorithm reached the global optimum in approximately 40 iterations, demonstrating faster convergence and higher accuracy.
  • Parameter Optimization Accuracy: The optimal motor parameters found by the adaptive JAYA algorithm were closest to the theoretical values, satisfying both variable and model constraints. Specifically, the stator diameter, tooth magnetic induction, winding current density, air gap magnetic induction, and stator yoke magnetic induction were found to be 201.5 mm, 1.8 T, 2.049 A/mm², 0.63 T, and 0.91 T, respectively.
  • Reduced Vibration: The adaptive JAYA algorithm effectively reduced noise in vibration signals, with reduction rates of up to 26.35% compared to other methods.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Single-Objective Optimization: The current study primarily focuses on maximizing motor efficiency. The authors acknowledge that in practical applications, minimizing motor quality (and thus production cost) is also crucial. They suggest establishing a multi-objective optimization model to simultaneously optimize efficiency and reduce motor quality.
  • Further Exploration of Hybrid Strategies: While the proposed hybrid learning strategy shows promise, further research could explore different combinations and weightings of these strategies to potentially achieve even better results.
  • Real-World Validation: While simulations and experimental data are used, further validation on a wider range of real-world BLDC motor applications could strengthen the findings.

The paper concludes that the adaptive JAYA algorithm offers a robust and efficient solution for the complex optimization design problem of brushless DC motors, paving the way for improved industrial applications.

Summary updated

Abstract

Brushless direct current motor is widely used in industrial production because of its simple structure, wide speed range and low noise. To improve the operation efficiency of brushless DC motor and reduce the production and application costs, the optimization of brushless DC motor is analyzed by introducing the JAYA algorithm. This method determines the optimal parameters of a brushless DC motor using the theory of electromagnetic structure parameter selection and efficiency calculation. The population diversity of the JAYA algorithm is improved through an empirical learning strategy, and an adaptive strategy is introduced to balance the development ability and search performance of the algorithm. This ensures population diversity and improves convergence speed. The experiment showcases that the improved JAYA algorithm has a lower rank average in unimodal function operations, demonstrating stronger local development ability and better stability. It exhibits strong search ability in many local optima of multimodal functions. Moreover, the motor's average efficiency after optimization is 94.48%. The algorithm reaches the global optimum after approximately 40 iterations and offers faster convergence speed and higher accuracy. The adaptive JAYA algorithm is stable at around 93% when the number of iterations reaches 90, with a maximum efficiency of 95.3%. It is 5-12 percentage points higher than the other three comparison algorithms. The optimal solution of the motor parameters in the adaptive JAYA algorithm is closest to the theoretical parameter optimization value, meeting both the constraints of variables and the constraints of the model. The stator diameter, tooth magnetic induction, winding current density, air gap magnetic induction, and stator yoke magnetic induction values are 201.5 mm, 1.8 T, 2.049 A/mm<sup>2</sup>, 0.63 T, and 0.91 T, respectively. The research overcomes the problem of parameter optimization in the optimization design of brushless DC motor, improving their economic value of brushless DC motor in industrial production and application.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yuan2024optimization,
  author = {Cheng Yuan and Xueli Lyu and Shasha Mao},
  title = {{Optimization design of brushless DC motor based on improved JAYA algorithm}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-024-54582-z},
}
Figure