Optimistic planning for Markov decision processes

Lucian Busoniu, Rémi MunosAISTATS 2012 · OpenReview

Abstract

The reinforcement learning community has recently intensified its interest in online planning methods, due to their relative independence on the state space size. However, tight near-optimality guarantees are not yet available for the general case of stochastic Markov decision processes and closed-loop, state-dependent planning policies. We therefore consider an algorithm related to AO* that optimistically explores a tree representation of the space of closed-loop policies, and we analyze the near-optimality of the action it returns after $n$ tree node expansions. While this optimistic planning requires a finite number of actions and possible next states for each transition, its asymptotic performance does not depend directly on these numbers, but only on the subset of nodes that significantly impact near-optimal policies. We characterize this set by introducing a novel measure of problem complexity, called the near-optimality exponent. Specializing the exponent and performance bound for some interesting classes of MDPs illustrates the algorithm works better when there are fewer near-optimal policies and less uniform transition probabilities.

Introduction

In reinforcement learning, planning involves looking ahead to choose the best action. While this is straightforward in deterministic systems, it becomes incredibly complex in stochastic Markov Decision Processes (MDPs), where an action can lead to multiple possible next states. Existing popular methods, like Monte Carlo Tree Search (MCTS) or UCT, often perform well in practice but lack tight theoretical guarantees for "closed-loop" policies—strategies where subsequent moves depend on the specific state reached.

Many planning algorithms struggle with the "curse of dimensionality," where computational costs explode as the state space grows. This paper bridges the gap by analyzing an algorithm that adapts its effort to the actual complexity of the problem, rather than the absolute size of the state space.

The Optimistic Planning Algorithm

The authors analyze an algorithm called Optimistic Planning (OP), which builds a look-ahead tree starting from the current state.

  1. Tree Expansion: Starting from the current state, OP builds a look-ahead tree. In each iteration, it expands a node by adding all possible actions ($K$) and all possible resulting states ($N$).
  2. Optimism Under Uncertainty: To decide which node to expand next, the algorithm identifies an "optimistic subtree"—the set of paths that currently show the highest potential upper bound on rewards.
  3. The "Any-time" Nature: OP can be stopped after any number of expansions ($n$), at which point it returns the action that looks best based on its current knowledge.
The structure of the MDP look-ahead tree, showing state nodes (squares) and action nodes (circles) with transition probabilities $p$ and rewards $r$.

Complexity and the Near-Optimality Exponent

The core novelty lies in the Near-Optimality Exponent ($\beta$). This is a new measure of problem complexity that characterizes the set of nodes that significantly impact near-optimal policies. Instead of looking at the whole state space, $\beta$ measures how "crowded" the space of good policies is.

Conceptual visualization of the subset of nodes $\mathcal{T}_{hs}$ that significantly impact near-optimal policies within the larger search space $\mathcal{T}_h$.

One of the most powerful aspects of OP is that it doesn't need to know the complexity ($\beta$) of the environment beforehand. It naturally spends more time exploring "near-optimal" branches and ignores clearly sub-optimal ones. Furthermore, the analysis captures a "global" effect: in a tree, a single state node might belong to many different policies. Expanding that node improves the value estimates for all those policies simultaneously.

Performance Across MDP Classes

The paper evaluates the algorithm using mathematical classes of MDPs to prove its propositions:

  • Uniform MDPs: Where all rewards and transition probabilities are equal (the "worst-case" scenario). The algorithm performs no worse than standard uniform planning, with a regret of $O(n^{-\frac{\log 1/\gamma}{\log NK}})$.
  • Structured Rewards: MDPs where only a few paths lead to high rewards. When $\beta = 0$ (very few near-optimal policies), the regret drops exponentially with the number of expansions.
  • Structured Probabilities: MDPs where transitions are non-uniform (e.g., Bernoulli transitions). If transition probabilities are highly non-uniform, the near-optimality exponent $\beta$ decreases, and the algorithm converges much faster.

Conclusion and Future Directions

While providing tight regret bounds, the current analysis requires a finite number of possible next states ($N$) for each transition. Additionally, the basic version of OP treated in this paper doesn't "merge" nodes if the same state is reached via different paths, leading to redundant computations. Future work involves "closing the tree into a graph" for greater efficiency and developing more efficient data structures to maintain these bounds in real-time.

Summary updated

Abstract

The reinforcement learning community has recently intensified its interest in online planning methods, due to their relative independence on the state space size. However, tight near-optimality guarantees are not yet available for the general case of stochastic Markov decision processes and closed-loop, state-dependent planning policies. We therefore consider an algorithm related to AO* that optimistically explores a tree representation of the space of closed-loop policies, and we analyze the near-optimality of the action it returns after n tree node expansions. While this optimistic planning requires a finite number of actions and possible next states for each transition, its asymptotic performance does not depend directly on these numbers, but only on the subset of nodes that significantly impact near-optimal policies. We characterize this set by introducing a novel measure of problem complexity, called the near-optimality exponent. Specializing the exponent and performance bound for some interesting classes of MDPs illustrates the algorithm works better when there are fewer near-optimal policies and less uniform transition probabilities.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{busoniu2012optimistic,
  author = {Lucian Busoniu and Rémi Munos},
  title = {{Optimistic planning for Markov decision processes}},
  booktitle = {International Conference on Artificial Intelligence and Statistics},
  year = {2012},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=huwjoCshoQ},
}
Figure