Optimazation of Domestic Plastic Waste Collection and Transportation System in Mega-city of China: Case Study of Tianjin

Richao Cong, Toru Matsumoto, He Xu, Wenchao LiJournal of Japan Society of Civil Engineers Ser G (Environmental Research) 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes a modernized framework for household plastic waste collection in Tianjin, China, shifting from an inefficient informal sector to a centralized system. By combining a theoretical Grid City Model (GCM) with real-world Geographic Information System (GIS) data, the researchers demonstrate that optimizing the number of intermediate collection hubs can reduce CO2 emissions by approximately 40% while significantly lowering transportation costs.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In many Chinese mega-cities like Tianjin, plastic recycling relies heavily on an "informal" system. Independent collectors use bicycles to gather waste and sell it to small-scale middlemen at unregulated "markets." While this provides livelihoods, it is plagued by low economic efficiency, poor labor conditions, and high environmental impact due to uncoordinated transportation and low vehicle load factors.

Typical informal plastic waste collection in Tianjin using non-motorized transport.

The authors seek to bridge the gap between this chaotic reality and a modernized "Circular Economy" vision. Specifically, they address the Vehicle Routing Problem (VRP) at a city-wide scale: How many intermediate collection hubs are needed, and where should they be placed to minimize both costs and carbon footprint?

Methods

The researchers employed a two-stage optimization approach:

  1. Grid City Model (GCM): This theoretical model was used to find the "sweet spot" for the number of intermediate disposal sites. It balances the trade-off between primary transport (collection points to hubs) and secondary transport (hubs to the final recycling plant). The model uses a multi-objective function to minimize both total cost and CO2 emissions.
  2. GIS-Based Validation: To move beyond theoretical grids, the authors used ArcGIS to map Tianjin’s actual road networks and population density. They calculated the shortest routes from over 1,000 existing collection points to proposed hubs, providing a high-fidelity estimation of fuel consumption and emissions.
  3. Case Comparison: They compared the Present Case (informal, 50% load efficiency, decentralized) against an Improved Case (modernized hubs, 90% load efficiency, centralized at the Zi’ya Circular Economy Industry Park).
Comparison between the current informal collection flow and the proposed improved centralized system.

Datasets

The study utilized several localized datasets for Tianjin:

  • Population Density: 100m x 100m grid data used to estimate waste generation.
  • Road Network Data: Detailed digital maps of Tianjin’s urban and suburban infrastructure.
  • Field Survey Data: Information on approximately 1,000 existing informal collection points and their operational characteristics.
  • Waste Generation Metrics: Estimated total non-PET household plastic waste at 36,000 tons/year, with a 85.5% recovery potential.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Hub Trade-off: Increasing the number of intermediate hubs reduces the distance small collection vehicles must travel (primary transport) but increases the cost of facility maintenance and the complexity of secondary transport. The study found the optimal balance to be 3 hubs in the city center and 25 in the outskirts.
  • Load Efficiency is King: A major driver of the "Improved Case" success was increasing the secondary transport load efficiency from 50% to 90%. By using larger, fully-loaded trucks to move waste from hubs to the Zi’ya plant, the carbon intensity of the system dropped dramatically.
  • GCM vs. GIS: The paper highlights that while GCM is excellent for finding an initial mathematical optimum, GIS is necessary to account for real-world constraints like actual road distances and non-uniform population distribution, which simple grid models often underestimate.

Key Results

  • CO2 Mitigation: The optimized system reduced annual CO2 emissions from 3,603 tons to 2,173 tons—a 40% reduction (approx. 1,430 tons-CO2/year).
  • Cost Optimization: The total system cost was minimized at the specific hub counts mentioned above (3 urban, 25 suburban). Beyond these numbers, the cost of operating the facilities began to outweigh the transportation savings.
  • Distance Reduction: Total transport distance was slashed significantly, particularly in the secondary transport phase, thanks to better routing and higher vehicle capacity utilization.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Implementation Barriers: The authors acknowledge that moving from an informal to a formal system requires significant cooperation between the municipal government and the private sector, particularly regarding land acquisition for the new hubs.
  • Social Impact: The paper focuses on environmental and economic metrics; however, the transition from an informal to a formal system would have significant social implications for the thousands of individual collectors currently operating in Tianjin, which warrants further study.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{cong2016optimazation,
  author = {Richao Cong and Toru Matsumoto and He Xu and Wenchao Li},
  title = {{Optimazation of Domestic Plastic Waste Collection and Transportation System in Mega-city of China: Case Study of Tianjin}},
  journal = {Journal of Japan Society of Civil Engineers Ser G (Environmental Research)},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.2208/jscejer.72.i\_65},
}
Figure