Optimal utilization of ecological economic resources and low-carbon economic analysis from the perspective of Public Health

Qi Wang, Feng Yan, Ao HuFrontiers in Public Health 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores how to optimize urban residential public spaces to improve public health (PH) while adhering to ecological and low-carbon economic principles. By analyzing resident satisfaction through a multi-indicator model, the researchers found that accessibility, integrity, and pleasure are the three primary drivers that encourage residents to engage in health-promoting outdoor activities.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As China undergoes rapid urbanization, the focus of urban planning is shifting from merely building physical structures to addressing the social and emotional needs of residents. Concurrently, public health challenges are transitioning from infectious diseases to chronic conditions and "sub-health" states.

While regular outdoor activity is a proven mitigator for these health risks, many urban "settlements" (residential complexes) lack optimized public spaces. The authors seek to bridge the gap between urban design and public health by identifying which specific characteristics of a residential public space actually motivate people to get outside and move, all within the framework of a sustainable, low-carbon economy.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-stage statistical approach to build and validate a satisfaction evaluation model:

  1. Model Construction: They developed a framework with five first-level indicators (Accessibility, Safety, Practicality, Ecology, and Pleasure) and 12 second-level indicators (ranging from walking distance to "humanities education fun").
  2. Data Collection: A questionnaire was distributed across three distinct residential settlements in "J City," China, capturing data on resident demographics, activity habits, and space satisfaction.
  3. Statistical Analysis:
    • Reliability & Validity: Used Cronbach’s $\alpha$ (0.914) and the Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin (KMO) test (0.94) to ensure the survey data was robust.
  4. Principal Component Analysis (PCA): Used to reduce the 12 indicators into three "macro" factors: Integrity ($F_1$), Accessibility ($F_2$), and Pleasure ($F_3$).
  5. Multiple Linear Regression (MLR): Used to determine the weight of each macro factor on the frequency of residents' outdoor activities.

Datasets

The study utilized a primary dataset generated from a questionnaire survey:

  • Sample Size: 269 valid responses (from an initial 300 distributed).
  • Location: Three settlements in J City (Settlement A: older/transformed, Settlement B: high-rise, Settlement C: national healthy housing demonstration project).
  • Demographics: Included a balanced gender ratio (53% women) and a high proportion of residents with bachelor's degrees (61%).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Integrity" Factor: One of the most interesting findings was the synthesis of Safety, Practicality, and Ecology into a single principal factor called "Integrity." This suggests that residents don't view these as separate silos; a space feels "whole" and usable only when it is simultaneously safe, functional, and green.
  • Accessibility is King: The statistical weight of accessibility ($0.355$) was the highest. If a space isn't easy to reach (short walking distance, good road access), residents simply won't use it, regardless of how beautiful or "green" it is.
  • Night Owls: The data revealed that 68.77% of residents prefer being active at night. This highlights the critical importance of "Q3: Night lighting quality," which falls under the Integrity factor.
  • Specific High-Impact Indicators: Beyond the macro factors, three specific indicators had the strongest correlation with activity frequency:
  • Q11: Interest of humanities education/fun.
  • Q10: Sunshine and ventilation conditions.
  • Q1: Walking arrival time.

Key Results

The core of the paper is the Multiple Linear Regression equation, which predicts the intensity of outdoor activity ($Y$): $$Y = 0.346F_1 (\text{Integrity}) + 0.355F_2 (\text{Accessibility}) + 0.223F_3 (\text{Pleasure}) + \sigma$$

  • Accessibility ($F_2$) has the greatest influence (coefficient 0.355).
  • Integrity ($F_1$) follows closely (coefficient 0.346).
  • Pleasure ($F_3$) has a significant but lower impact (coefficient 0.223).

The overall satisfaction rating across the studied settlements was 3.76 out of 5, indicating a generally positive but improvable environment. Residents rated "Ecology" and "Accessibility" the highest, while "Practicality" (completeness of facilities) received the lowest scores.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Geographic Scope: The study only looked at three settlements in one city. The authors acknowledge that results might differ between Northern and Southern China due to climate and cultural variations.
  • Idealization vs. Reality: Upgrading public spaces for health is often constrained by existing infrastructure and budgets. The paper focuses on the "optimal" but doesn't deeply dive into the cost-benefit analysis of specific renovations.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest expanding the sample size to more cities and conducting "factor correlation research" to see how these variables interact over longer periods or in different urban contexts.

Summary updated

Abstract

We can optimize the utilization of urban residential public space resources from the aspects of accessibility, integrity and pleasure, so as to promote residents to go to public spaces for outdoor activities and physical exercise, which is more conducive to the public health of residents.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2023optimal,
  author = {Qi Wang and Feng Yan and Ao Hu},
  title = {{Optimal utilization of ecological economic resources and low-carbon economic analysis from the perspective of Public Health}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Public Health},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fpubh.2023.1152809},
}
Figure