Optimal Scheduling of Virtual Power Plant with Flexibility Margin Considering Demand Response and Uncertainties

Yetuo Tan, Yongming Zhi, Zhengbin Luo, Honggang Fan, Jun Wan, Tao ZhangEnergies 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes an optimal scheduling strategy for Virtual Power Plants (VPPs) that incorporates a "flexibility margin" and demand response, specifically focusing on electric vehicles. The goal is to improve grid stability and reduce costs by intelligently managing diverse energy resources while accounting for uncertainties in renewable energy generation and market prices.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing integration of renewable energy sources like wind and solar power into the grid introduces significant variability and uncertainty. This creates challenges for maintaining grid stability, as the rapid fluctuations in net load are difficult to manage with traditional reserve capacity. Virtual Power Plants (VPPs) offer a solution by aggregating distributed energy resources (DERs) such as renewables, storage, and flexible loads to provide grid services. However, optimizing VPP operations, especially when considering demand response and inherent uncertainties in renewable output and market prices, remains a complex problem. Existing approaches often struggle to fully capture the dynamic nature of these factors and the potential of flexible loads like electric vehicles. This paper aims to address this gap by developing an optimal scheduling method that explicitly considers a "flexibility margin" and integrates demand response strategies, particularly for electric vehicles, to enhance VPP performance and grid reliability.

Methods

The authors employ a mixed-integer linear programming (MILP) approach, implemented using LINGO software, to optimize the VPP's scheduling. The core of their methodology involves:

  • VPP Model Formulation: A comprehensive model of the VPP is developed, encompassing various DERs including photovoltaic systems, combined heat and power (CHP) units, gas-fired boilers, refrigeration units, and energy storage systems (electric, thermal, and cooling). Mathematical models are provided for each component's power output, thermal output, and energy storage dynamics.
  • Flexibility Margin Concept: A key contribution is the introduction of a "flexibility margin" concept. This is defined as the difference between the power load and the photovoltaic output (net load), and further broken down into upward and downward flexibility requirements. This margin is then used to define flexibility indicators.
  • Demand Response Integration: The paper specifically models the demand response of electric vehicles (EVs) through an "orderly charging and discharging strategy." This strategy considers user demands and interests, aiming to optimize EV charging to align with grid needs and user preferences, thereby contributing to peak shifting and valley filling.
  • Uncertainty Handling: While the abstract mentions uncertainties, the detailed methodology section focuses on deterministic optimization using MILP. The paper acknowledges that renewable energy output and market prices are subject to uncertainty, and the flexibility margin is partly designed to address this. However, the specific stochastic optimization techniques are not detailed in the provided text.
  • Objective Function: The primary objective is to maximize the VPP's profit. This is achieved by considering revenues from participating in power and gas markets, benefits from demand-side participation, and minimizing costs related to carbon emissions and unbalanced penalties.

Datasets

The paper utilizes a case study based on data from a community in Beijing, China. This dataset includes:

  • Hourly electricity load, cooling load, and heating load data.
  • Light radiation and temperature data (presumably for PV output estimation).
  • Charging prices for electric vehicles in Beijing.
  • Electricity purchase prices for users, varying by time of day (valley, usual, peak periods).
  • Carbon emission factors for the CHP unit and carbon trading prices.
  • Peak power load, peak cooling load, and peak heating load values.
  • PV installation capacity range.
  • Specifications for EV battery capacity, air conditioning, ice storage, electric boiler, and heat storage tank.
  • Cost parameters (installation cost, running costs, efficiency, period) for various technical equipment.

The paper also presents figures illustrating the prices of different energy sources (gas, PV feed-in tariff, electricity at different voltage levels) and the charging load of electric vehicles, which appear to be derived from or representative of real-world data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Flexibility Margin" is Crucial: Explicitly quantifying and utilizing a "flexibility margin" allows the VPP to better manage the inherent variability of renewables and demand. This goes beyond simply meeting load and aims to actively leverage the grid's capacity for change.
  • EVs as a Powerful Demand-Side Resource: The paper highlights the significant potential of electric vehicles for demand response. By implementing an "orderly charging and discharging strategy," EVs can be used not only to reduce user costs but also to actively support grid stability by shifting loads and preventing new peak demands.
  • Integrated Optimization for Economic and Environmental Benefits: The VPP model successfully integrates economic objectives (profit maximization) with environmental considerations (carbon emission reduction) through its objective function and the inclusion of carbon costs.
  • Addressing "New Peaks": A key problem identified is the creation of "new peaks" due to uncoordinated charging or renewable energy output. The proposed strategy aims to mitigate this by intelligently managing demand and supply, leading to smoother load profiles.

Key Results

The numerical results demonstrate that the proposed VPP scheduling strategy:

  • Reduces Operation Costs: The optimization method significantly reduces the overall operation cost for the VPP.
  • Prevents Overload and Achieves Peak Shifting: The strategy effectively prevents transformer overload and achieves peak shifting and valley filling, leading to a more stable power grid.
  • Enhances Economic Efficiency: By optimizing the load model of electric vehicles and integrating flexibility resources, the VPP's economic efficiency is increased.
  • Reduces User Charging Costs: Users participating in the peak-regulating auxiliary services market through the VPP experience reduced charging costs.
  • Increases VPP Profitability: Figures 8 and 9 illustrate that the VPP model, particularly with flexible EV charging, leads to increased annual profits and daily income for various participants (PV, CHP, power grid, and flexibility resources). The charging price for EVs is identified as a key factor influencing profitability.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Uncertainty Modeling: While the abstract mentions uncertainties, the primary method presented is deterministic MILP. The paper acknowledges that the prediction error of photovoltaic systems follows a normal distribution, but the detailed implementation of stochastic optimization techniques for all uncertainties (renewable output, demand, market prices) is not fully elaborated in the provided sections.
  • Computational Complexity: MILP can become computationally intensive for large-scale systems or long-term planning horizons.
  • User Behavior Modeling: The EV demand response model considers user demands and interests, but a more sophisticated modeling of user behavior and preferences could further enhance the strategy.

The authors suggest that future work could focus on further developing robust optimization methods to handle uncertainties more comprehensively and exploring more advanced demand response strategies.

Summary updated

Abstract

The emission reduction of global greenhouse gases is one of the key steps towards sustainable development. Demand response utilizes the resources of the demand side as an alternative of power supply which is very important for the power network balance, and the virtual power plant (VPP) could overcome barriers to participate in the electricity market. In this paper, the optimal scheduling of a VPP with a flexibility margin considering demand response and uncertainties is proposed. Compared with a conventional power plant, the cost models of VPPs considering the impact of uncertainty and the operation constraints considering demand response and flexibility margin characteristics are constructed. The orderly charging and discharging strategy for electric vehicles considering user demands and interests is introduced in the demand response. The research results show that the method can reduce the charging cost for users participating in reverse power supply using a VPP. The optimizing strategy could prevent overload, complete load transfer, and realize peak shifting and valley filling, solving the problems of the new peak caused by disorderly power utilization.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{tan2023optimal,
  author = {Yetuo Tan and Yongming Zhi and Zhengbin Luo and Honggang Fan and Jun Wan and Tao Zhang},
  title = {{Optimal Scheduling of Virtual Power Plant with Flexibility Margin Considering Demand Response and Uncertainties}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/en16155833},
}
Figure