Optimal Scheduling of the Wind-Photovoltaic-Energy Storage Multi-Energy Complementary System Considering Battery Service Life

Yanpin Li, Huiliang Wang, Zichao Zhang, Huawei Li, Xiaoli Wang, Qifan Zhang, Tong Zhou, Peng Zhang, Fengxiang ChangEnergies 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel hybrid energy storage operation strategy for wind-solar power systems that explicitly accounts for battery degradation, aiming to balance grid stability, renewable energy integration, and system costs. By employing an improved particle swarm optimization (PSO) algorithm, the strategy effectively reduces battery life loss and overall generation costs, demonstrating a more sustainable approach to renewable energy management.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing integration of renewable energy sources like wind and solar into power grids presents significant challenges due to their inherent variability and intermittency. This leads to grid instability, power quality issues, and increased operational burdens on traditional power plants. While energy storage systems (ESS) are crucial for mitigating these issues, existing scheduling models often overlook the impact of charging and discharging cycles on battery lifespan, leading to premature degradation and increased long-term costs. This paper addresses the need for an optimal scheduling strategy that not only ensures grid stability and maximizes renewable energy utilization but also actively preserves battery health, thereby extending the operational life of the energy storage system.

Methods

The core of this research lies in developing an optimal scheduling model for a wind-solar-energy storage multi-energy complementary system. Key methodological contributions include:

  • Hybrid Energy Storage Strategy: The paper proposes a hybrid energy storage system combining battery energy storage (BESS) and pumped storage. This strategy leverages the fast response of BESS for short-term fluctuations and the long-duration capabilities of pumped storage.
  • Battery Life Consideration: A significant innovation is the explicit incorporation of battery service life into the optimization model. This is achieved by considering battery degradation through factors like depth of discharge and state of charge (SOC), and quantifying it with a "battery life-loss coefficient."
  • "Generalized Load" Concept: The model defines a "generalized load" as the system's remaining energy demand after accounting for wind, PV, and energy storage output. This concept helps in smoothing out fluctuations and managing the overall system load.
  • Multi-Objective Optimization: The study formulates three distinct optimization objectives:
  • Minimizing the mean squared deviation of the "generalized load" (improving grid stability).
  • Minimizing the fluctuation of the combined system output (enhancing grid stability).
  • Minimizing the total generation cost of the combined system.
  • Improved Particle Swarm Optimization (IPSO): To efficiently solve the complex optimization problem with numerous decision variables, an improved PSO algorithm is employed. This enhanced PSO incorporates:
  • Linearly Decreasing Inertia Weight: To balance exploration and exploitation and prevent premature convergence.
  • Prime Ideal Set Initialization: To ensure a more uniform distribution of initial particles, improving search space coverage.
  • Asynchronous Learning Factors: To dynamically adjust the learning parameters, allowing for faster initial convergence and more accurate final solutions.

Datasets

The study utilizes typical daily load curves and predicted output data for wind and photovoltaic power plants as input for the simulation. The specific system parameters (installed capacity, investment costs, operation and maintenance factors, service life, efficiencies, etc.) for a 500 MW wind farm, 400 MW PV power station, 75 MW pumped storage, and 25 MW battery energy storage station are provided in Table 1.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Battery Health is Paramount: The research strongly emphasizes that neglecting battery lifespan in scheduling can lead to significant long-term costs and reduced system efficiency. Proactively managing battery charge/discharge cycles is crucial for sustainable renewable energy integration.
  • Hybrid Storage Synergy: Combining BESS with pumped storage offers a robust solution, allowing for rapid response to grid demands while also providing sustained energy buffering.
  • "Generalized Load" as a Smart Metric: Using the "generalized load" as a key metric for optimization helps in effectively managing the residual demand and smoothing out the impact of variable renewables.
  • IPSO's Superiority: The improved PSO algorithm demonstrates a clear advantage over the conventional PSO in achieving better global optimization and avoiding local optima, leading to more precise scheduling outcomes.

Key Results

The study demonstrates significant improvements across various objectives when using the proposed optimization strategy compared to a conventional approach that doesn't consider battery life:

  • Battery Life Loss Reduction:
    • For minimizing generalized load deviation: Battery life-loss coefficient reduced from 0.073% to 0.055%.
  • For minimizing system output fluctuation: Battery life-loss coefficient reduced from 0.088% to 0.053%.
  • For minimizing generation cost: Battery life-loss coefficient reduced from 0.092% to 0.081%.
  • Cost Reduction: For the objective of minimizing generation cost, the total system cost was reduced from 449.14 (10^4 RMB) to 448.88 (10^4 RMB) under the optimized strategy.
  • Improved Scheduling Accuracy: The improved PSO algorithm converged to a better solution (43.83 MW) compared to the conventional PSO (54.98 MW) in terms of fitness value.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Daily Scope: The current study focuses on a single day's operation. The authors acknowledge that future research should consider the uncertainties of annual wind and PV outputs.
  • Multiple Targets: While the paper addresses three objectives, further research could explore the impact of multiple, potentially conflicting, targets on the combined power generation system.
  • Uncertainty Modeling: The current model assumes deterministic inputs. Incorporating stochastic elements for load and renewable generation would provide a more realistic representation.

This research provides a valuable framework for optimizing renewable energy systems by integrating battery health into the scheduling process, paving the way for more sustainable and cost-effective grid operations.

Summary updated

Abstract

Under the background of “peak carbon dioxide emissions by 2030 and carbon neutrality by 2060 strategies” and grid-connected large-scale renewables, the grid usually adopts a method of optimal scheduling to improve its ability to cope with the stochastic and volatile nature of renewable energy and to increase economic efficiency. This article proposes a short-term optimal scheduling model for wind–solar storage combined-power generation systems in high-penetration renewable energy areas. After the comprehensive consideration of battery life, energy storage units, and load characteristics, a hybrid energy storage operation strategy was developed. The model uses the remaining energy in the system after deducting wind PV and energy storage output as the “generalized load”. An improved particle swarm optimization (PSO) is used to solve the scheduling schemes of different running strategies under different objectives. The optimization strategy optimizes the battery life-loss coefficient from 0.073% to 0.055% under the target of minimizing the mean squared deviation of “generalized load”, which was optimized from 0.088% to 0.053% under the minimized fluctuation of combined system output and optimized from 0.092% to 0.081% under the minimized generation costs of the combined system. The results show that the model can ensure a stable operation of the combined system, and the operation strategy proposed in this article effectively reduces battery life loss while reducing the total power generation cost of the system. Finally, the superiority of the improved PSO algorithm was verified.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2023optimal,
  author = {Yanpin Li and Huiliang Wang and Zichao Zhang and Huawei Li and Xiaoli Wang and Qifan Zhang and Tong Zhou and Peng Zhang and Fengxiang Chang},
  title = {{Optimal Scheduling of the Wind-Photovoltaic-Energy Storage Multi-Energy Complementary System Considering Battery Service Life}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/en16135002},
}
Figure