TL;DR
This paper proposes a novel revenue-sharing model for hybrid energy plants (wind-solar-storage) to solve the "fairness gap" that often discourages energy storage participation. By combining a coordinated scheduling strategy with the Minimum Cost-Remaining Savings (MCRS) method, the model increases total plant profits by over 12% and boosts energy storage revenue by 28% through better management of green power market penalties.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
As the world shifts toward "green power" markets, hybrid plants that combine wind, solar, and energy storage systems (ESS) are becoming essential. However, a major bottleneck exists: revenue sharing.
In many current models, it is unclear how to fairly distribute profits among the different components of a hybrid plant. Because wind and solar are intermittent, they often fail to meet their traded power delivery targets, leading to heavy "deviation penalties." While energy storage can fix these deviations, it incurs high operational costs. If the revenue-sharing method doesn't accurately reflect the "value of flexibility" provided by the storage unit, operators have little incentive to invest in or use storage effectively. The authors aim to create a mathematical framework that quantifies these contributions and allocates profits equitably.
Methods
The researchers developed a multi-layered approach to optimize both the operation and the accounting of the hybrid plant:
- Uncertainty Modeling: They used Latin Hypercube Sampling (LHS) and the Kantorovich probability distance method to generate and reduce scenarios for volatile day-ahead spot market prices.
- Coordinated Scheduling: A two-stage scheduling strategy (day-ahead and intra-day) was designed to maximize revenue across two markets: the green power market (long-term contracts) and the spot market (real-time trading).
- Contribution Index System: This is the core innovation. The authors developed five indices to quantify the ESS's contribution:
- Cost Index: Operational costs.
- Generation Index: Equivalent power generation.
- Marginal Revenue Index: Contribution to the total revenue.
- Deviation Index: How much it reduces green power trading penalties.
- Accuracy Index: Improvement in tracking the planned output.
- MCRS Revenue Sharing: They applied the Minimum Cost-Remaining Savings (MCRS) method from cooperative game theory, modified by their contribution indices, to ensure that the "gains from cooperation" are distributed based on actual value provided rather than just raw energy output.
Datasets
The model was validated using a case study of a hybrid plant in a western province of China:
- Plant Specs: 30 MW wind farm, 30 MW photovoltaic (PV) station, and a 20 MWh/10 MW energy storage system.
- Market Data: Historical day-ahead electricity market clearing prices and typical wind/solar output profiles.
- Parameters: Green power price set at 506.6 ¥/MWh with an environmental premium of 91.3 ¥/MWh.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Negative Correlation Strategy: The model intelligently "decomposes" green power delivery. It schedules more green power delivery during off-peak price periods (when spot market revenue is low) and saves the renewable capacity for the spot market during peak price periods to maximize total profit.
- The "Penalty-Saver" Value: A major "aha" moment in the paper is that the ESS’s value isn't just in "buying low and selling high" (arbitrage). Its primary value in this context is acting as a buffer to avoid expensive deviation penalties in the green power market.
- Fairness Drives Cooperation: Traditional "allocation by output" significantly undervalues storage. By switching to a contribution-based MCRS model, the storage component becomes a profit center rather than a cost burden, making the entire hybrid project more bankable.
Key Results
The study compared their proposed model (Scheme 1) against a hybrid plant without energy storage (Scheme 2):
- Profit Increase: The net profit of the hybrid plant increased by 12.33%.
- Penalty Reduction: Deviation penalties in the green power market were reduced by a staggering amount—from 15,262 ¥ down to just 669 ¥.
- ESS Revenue Boost: After applying the modified revenue-sharing model, the energy storage system's share of proceeds increased by 28.19% compared to a standard MCRS method.
- Market Efficiency: The completion rate of green power transactions improved by 5.93%, indicating more reliable delivery to the grid.
Limitations and Future Work
While the model is robust, the authors note a few areas for further exploration:
- Market Complexity: The study focuses on a specific set of market rules in China. Future work could adapt the model for different international market structures (e.g., PJM or European markets).
- Battery Degradation: While operational costs are included, more granular modeling of long-term battery health and replacement cycles could refine the "Cost Index."
- Multi-Agent Games: The current model assumes a cooperative alliance. Future research could explore non-cooperative game theory scenarios where different entities own the wind, solar, and storage assets.
Summary updated