Optimal Penetration Guidance Law for High-Speed Vehicles against an Interceptor with Modified Proportional Navigation Guidance

Lei Feng, Lu Wang, Fenglin Wang, Fan Zhang, Qiangui SunSymmetry 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenging problem of a high-speed vehicle evading an advanced interceptor by developing an optimal penetration guidance law. Using Hamilton's principle and a detailed 3D model, they derive analytical solutions for the vehicle's maneuvers, aiming to maximize miss distance while considering realistic flight constraints.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing sophistication of near-space weaponry has led to a critical need for high-speed vehicles to evade advanced interceptors. Traditional guidance laws often struggle against modern threats. This paper focuses on a specific, challenging scenario: a high-speed vehicle attempting to penetrate an interceptor employing a modified proportional navigation (PN) guidance law. This modified PN is more complex than standard PN, making evasion significantly harder. The authors aim to develop an optimal strategy for the high-speed vehicle that maximizes its chances of survival by achieving a substantial miss distance, even under tight flight constraints.

Methods

The core of this research lies in applying Hamilton's principle to derive an optimal control strategy. This principle, rooted in minimizing "action," is used to find the trajectory that optimizes a defined performance index. The authors construct a three-dimensional mathematical model of the attack-defense scenario, incorporating:

  • Modified Proportional Navigation Guidance: This is a key differentiator, as it's a more advanced interceptor behavior than typically modeled.
  • Control Constraints: Limits on the vehicle's maneuverability (e.g., maximum overload).
  • Pitch Angle Velocity Constraints: Restrictions on how quickly the vehicle can change its pitch.
  • Dynamic Delay: Accounting for system response times.
  • 180-degree Bank-to-Turn (BTT) Control: A specific maneuver capability of the high-speed vehicle.

By formulating this complex system, they derive analytical solutions for the optimal speed roll angle and overload of the high-speed vehicle. This analytical approach is a significant contribution, offering direct insights into optimal maneuvers rather than relying solely on numerical optimization.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The evaluation relies on simulations using parameters defined in Table 1.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Modified PN is a Game Changer: The inclusion of a modified PN guidance law for the interceptor significantly increases the complexity of the evasion problem, requiring more sophisticated strategies from the high-speed vehicle.
  • Analytical Solutions are Powerful: Deriving analytical solutions for optimal maneuvers (speed roll angle and overload) provides a direct understanding of the evasion strategy, which is more insightful than purely numerical results.
  • Overload Switching is Key: The paper highlights that the number of overload switches for optimal penetration is directly related to the interceptor's guidance coefficient (N-1). This suggests a predictable pattern in how the vehicle should maneuver.
  • Speed Roll Angle Velocity Matters: There's an optimal range for the high-speed vehicle's maximum speed roll angle velocity (around 60-90 deg/s) that leads to better penetration. Too slow, and it might not evade; too fast, and control might become unstable or less effective.

Key Results

  • The proposed optimal penetration guidance law can achieve a miss distance of over 5 meters when the overload capacity ratio is 0.33.
  • The overload switching times for optimal penetration are found to be N-1, where N is the modified proportional guidance coefficient of the interceptor.
  • A speed roll angle velocity range of [60, 90] degrees per second for the high-speed vehicle yields good penetration effects.
  • Simulation results (Figures 2-5) demonstrate the flight paths and maneuver profiles of both the high-speed vehicle and the interceptor under the proposed guidance law.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simplified Interceptor Model: While the interceptor uses modified PN, the paper assumes a first-order autopilot model for both vehicles. More complex interceptor dynamics could be explored.
  • Target Assumptions: The target is assumed to be moving in a horizontal plane. Future work could consider more general target maneuvers.
  • Monte Carlo Simulation Range: While 5000 runs were performed, exploring a wider range of initial conditions and parameters in Monte Carlo simulations could further validate the robustness of the strategy.
  • Real-World Implementation: The paper focuses on theoretical derivation and simulation. Future work could involve experimental validation or implementation on actual flight hardware.
  • Further Optimization: Exploring other performance indices or incorporating additional constraints (e.g., fuel consumption, thermal limits) could lead to even more refined strategies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Aiming at the penetration problem of high-speed vehicles against a modified proportional guidance interceptor, a three-dimensional mathematical model of attack–defense confrontation between the high-speed vehicle and the interceptor is established in this paper. The modified proportional navigation guidance law of the interceptor is included in the model, and control constraints, pitch angle velocity constraints, and dynamic delay are introduced. Then, the performance index of the optimal penetration of high-speed vehicles is established. Under the condition of considering the 180-degree BTT control, the analytical solutions of the optimal speed roll angle and the optimal overload of high-speed vehicles are obtained according to symmetric Hamilton principle. The simulation results show that the overload switching times of high-speed vehicles to achieve optimal penetration are N − 1, where N is the modified proportional guidance coefficient of the interceptor. When the maximum speed roll angle velocity is [60, 90] degrees per second, the penetration effect of high-speed vehicles is good. Finally, the optimal penetration guidance law proposed in this paper can achieve a miss distance of more than 5 m when the overload capacity ratio is 0.33.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{feng2023optimal,
  author = {Lei Feng and Lu Wang and Fenglin Wang and Fan Zhang and Qiangui Sun},
  title = {{Optimal Penetration Guidance Law for High-Speed Vehicles against an Interceptor with Modified Proportional Navigation Guidance}},
  booktitle = {Symmetry},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/sym15071337},
}
Figure