TL;DR
This paper presents a novel optimal path planning method for airborne wind energy systems (AWES) that incorporates a flexible tether model. By using a quasi-static flexible tether model and a homotopy-based optimization approach, the authors demonstrate that considering tether flexibility significantly impacts harvested power and tether force dynamics, even though the optimal flight trajectories appear similar to those generated with a rigid tether.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Airborne Wind Energy Systems (AWES) offer a promising avenue for generating electricity from more consistent and faster winds at higher altitudes by using aircraft and tethers instead of traditional turbine towers. A key challenge in AWES operation is establishing optimal flight paths that maximize power generation while ensuring the aircraft's safety. Existing research often simplifies the tether as a rigid rod, which can lead to inaccuracies, especially during retraction and transition phases where tether sag is significant. This paper addresses the need for a more accurate AWES model that includes a flexible tether, and develops an efficient optimization framework to find optimal flight paths for such systems.
Methods
The authors propose an optimal control problem (OCP) formulation for generating periodic, maximum power flight trajectories. They employ a semi-explicit index-1 differential-algebraic equation (DAE) form for the system dynamics, which allows for the inclusion of complementary constraints at the initial point. A key methodological contribution is the use of a quasi-static flexible tether model. This model approximates the tether using discrete lumped masses connected by massless elastic segments, balancing physical accuracy with computational efficiency. To tackle the complexity of the OCP, a homotopy-based approach is utilized. This involves solving a sequence of progressively more challenging optimization problems, starting with simplified models and gradually introducing the full system complexity, including fictitious forces and then the actual aerodynamic forces. This approach enhances solver reliability and robustness. For comparison, a simplified rigid tether model is also developed by neglecting drag and gravitational forces on the tether.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Flexible Tether Matters: Even though optimal flight paths for rigid and flexible tethers look similar, the flexible tether model reveals significant differences in harvested power and tether force direction, particularly during the retraction phase.
- Underestimation by Rigid Models: Rigid tether models can overestimate harvested power by up to 33% in pumping cycles due to their inability to capture tether sag.
- Computational Efficiency: The quasi-static flexible tether model, combined with a homotopy-based optimization, provides a computationally feasible approach to optimize AWES trajectories with a flexible tether.
- DAE Formulation Advantage: Using a semi-explicit index-1 DAE formulation allows for easier incorporation of initial conditions and constraints, which is crucial for enhancing trajectory characteristics.
- Homotopy for Robustness: The homotopy approach effectively manages the complexity of the optimal control problem, leading to more reliable convergence and robust solutions.
Key Results
The study generated optimal circular and lemniscate trajectories for a megawatt-scale AWES. Simulations showed that:
- Optimal trajectories for rigid and flexible tethers are visually similar, but differences emerge in control inputs and harvested power.
- The flexible tether model leads to a more accurate estimation of harvested power, with rigid models underestimating the impact of tether sag.
- Tether sag significantly affects the direction of the tether force on the aircraft during the retraction phase.
- The computation time for finding optimal trajectories with a flexible tether is higher than with a rigid tether, but remains manageable with the chosen quasi-static model and ten tether segments. Lemniscate trajectories require more computational effort than circular ones.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge that the quasi-static flexible tether model does not capture dynamic effects, which could be important in certain scenarios. Future work could involve exploring more dynamic tether models while maintaining computational tractability. The paper also suggests that the optimization framework could be extended to include take-off and landing maneuvers, as well as other operational constraints. Further investigation into the impact of different wind profiles and AWES configurations on the optimal trajectories and performance is also a promising direction.
Summary updated