Optimal operative choice for displaced midshaft clavicle fractures in adolescents: a comparative study of intramedullary flexible nails and plating

Jin Li, Saroj Rai, Renhao Ze, Xin Tang, Ruikang Liu, Hong PanResearch 2020 · DOI

This study, conducted by researchers at Wuhan Union Hospital, compares two surgical approaches for treating displaced midshaft clavicle fractures in adolescents: traditional metal plating versus Elastic Stable Intramedullary Nailing (ESIN). While both methods result in excellent functional recovery, ESIN emerges as the superior choice for most teens due to shorter operative times, smaller scars, and significantly easier hardware removal.

TL;DR

For adolescents with displaced collarbone fractures, "internal" flexible nailing (ESIN) offers the same functional recovery as traditional plates and screws but with half the surgery time and far better cosmetic results. However, the study suggests this minimally invasive approach may be less suitable for children weighing over 50 kg.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Clavicle (collarbone) fractures are incredibly common in the pediatric population. While most heal well with a simple sling, "displaced midshaft" fractures—where the bone ends are completely separated—often require surgery to ensure proper alignment and faster return to activity.

In adults, the "gold standard" is open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF) using a metal plate and screws. However, adolescents are a unique demographic; they heal faster than adults but are more active than younger children. The surgical community has been divided: should we use the invasive but sturdy plate, or the minimally invasive ESIN, where a flexible titanium nail is threaded through the hollow center of the bone? This paper seeks to provide a head-to-head comparison to determine the optimal operative choice.

Methods

The researchers conducted a retrospective comparative study of 73 patients (aged 10–14) treated between 2014 and 2018.

  • The ESIN Group (n=45): Received a flexible nail inserted through a small 1.5–3 cm incision.
  • The Plate Group (n=28): Received a standard 6-to-8-hole plate via a larger 4–7 cm incision.

The team tracked surgical metrics (time, blood loss, incision length), clinical outcomes (using the American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons or ASES score), and patient satisfaction regarding aesthetics (scarring). Crucially, they also tracked the metrics for the removal of the hardware, which is standard practice in pediatric orthopedics.

Datasets

The study utilized a clinical dataset from the Wuhan Union Hospital database. It included preoperative radiographic parameters, intraoperative data, and postoperative follow-up data (minimum 24 months). No external or public benchmarks were used, as this is a clinical outcome study.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Functional Equivalence: Perhaps the most important finding is that at the end of the recovery period, there was no statistically significant difference in shoulder function (ASES scores of ~95 for both). Both methods are "safe and effective."
  • The Cosmetic Priority: Adolescents are often highly sensitive to scarring. The "scar concern" rate was 50% in the plate group compared to just 4.4% in the ESIN group.
  • Surgical Efficiency: ESIN was nearly twice as fast to perform (~31 mins vs ~60 mins) and resulted in significantly less blood loss and shorter hospital stays.
  • The "Second Surgery" Advantage: Because implants are typically removed in children, the ease of removal matters. ESIN removal was significantly faster (10 mins vs 35 mins) and less traumatic than removing a plate and multiple screws.

Key Results

  • Incision Length: ESIN required an average incision of 2.4 cm, while plating required 4.8 cm.
  • Blood Loss: Estimated blood loss was 10.4 ml for ESIN vs. 31.1 ml for plating.
  • Hospital Stay: ESIN patients went home sooner (4.0 days vs. 6.0 days).
  • Complications: No cases of "non-union" (failure to heal) occurred in either group. However, two patients in the plate group suffered a "refracture" after the plate was removed, a risk often associated with the stress-shielding effects of rigid plates.
  • Implant Prominence: ESIN had a higher rate of "implant prominence" (44.4% vs 32.1%), where the end of the nail can be felt under the skin, but this did not translate to lower patient satisfaction.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors highlight a few critical caveats:

  • The Weight Limit: The study excluded "overweight" patients (defined here as >50 kg). The authors explicitly warn that ESIN might not provide enough mechanical stability for heavier teenagers, where plating might still be necessary.
  • Study Design: As a retrospective study with a relatively small sample size (73 patients), there is a risk of selection bias.
  • Follow-up: While 24 months is sufficient for healing, the study did not follow patients until full skeletal maturity to check for long-term bone growth discrepancies.

Future research should focus on a randomized controlled trial that specifically tests the "weight threshold" to see exactly when the flexible nail becomes too risky compared to a rigid plate.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Background: Traditionally, operative treatment for displaced midshaft clavicle fractures in adolescents has been achieved by a plate and screws. However, a minimally invasive trend in most of the surgeries has led the pediatric orthopedic surgeons to use elastic stable intramedullary nail (ESIN) for displaced midshaft clavicle fractures. This study aims to compare the clinical outcomes of adolescent patients who were surgically treated with the (ESIN) and plate for displaced midshaft clavicle fractures. Methods: A total of 73 patients, aged between 10 years and 14 years, with displaced midshaft clavicle fractures were treated surgically from January 2014 to January 2018. Patients were categorized into two groups, ESIN (n = 45; male 27, female 18) and plate (n = 28; male17, female 11) according to surgical technique. The preoperative data, including baseline information of the patients, radiographic parameters, and types of surgical procedure, were collected from the hospital database. The postoperative data, including clinical outcome and complications, were collected during the follow-up visit. Clinical outcome was evaluated using the American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons (ASES). Results: The average age of the patients in the ESIN group was 12.2±1.5 years, and that in the Plate group was 12.2±1.4 years. There was a significantly less operative time, reduced estimated blood loss (EBL), shortened hospital stay and smaller incision for ESIN group as compared to the Plate group (P<0.01). The rate of scar concern was much higher in plate (14/28, 50%) than ESIN (2/45, 4.4%) , (P <0.01). There was no statistically significant difference in shoulder function between the ESIN group (94.5±2.8) and the Plate group (95.1±2.7), P = 0.36. In all the cases, implant removal was performed between 4 and 12 months postoperatively, and the ESIN group had significantly less operative time, EBL and shortened hospital stay as compared to the plate for implant removal (P<0.01). Conclusion: Both the ESIN and Plate are safe and effective treatment methods for displaced midshaft clavicle fractures in adolescents. The ESIN is superior to plate in terms of shorter operative time, less intraoperative radiation exposure, shorter hospital stay, less scar concern and easier implant removals. However, ESIN for heavier kids remain cautious.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2020optimal,
  author = {Jin Li and Saroj Rai and Renhao Ze and Xin Tang and Ruikang Liu and Hong Pan},
  title = {{Optimal operative choice for displaced midshaft clavicle fractures in adolescents: a comparative study of intramedullary flexible nails and plating}},
  booktitle = {Research},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-21710/v1},
}
Figure