Optimal Linear Transceiver Designs for Cognitive Two-Way Relay Networks

Yuan Liu (刘元), Rui Wang, Meixia Tao, Yuan LiuIEEE TSP 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of optimizing wireless communication in cognitive radio networks where two primary users (PUs) communicate via a secondary user (SU) acting as a relay. The authors propose a framework to maximize the SU's data rate while ensuring the PUs meet their communication requirements, considering three practical relay strategies: Amplify-and-Forward (AF), Decode-and-Forward XOR (DF-XOR), and Decode-and-Forward Superposition Coding (DF-SUP).

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In today's increasingly crowded wireless spectrum, efficient utilization of licensed frequencies is crucial. Cognitive radio (CR) offers a solution by allowing unlicensed secondary users (SUs) to access spectrum without disrupting primary users (PUs). This paper focuses on a specific scenario: a cognitive two-way relay network where two PUs need to exchange information, and a multi-antenna SU acts as a relay. The SU not only facilitates the PU-to-PU communication but also transmits its own messages simultaneously. The core challenge lies in designing optimal transmission strategies for the SU, specifically how to allocate power for relaying PU signals versus transmitting its own, which relay strategy to employ, and how to jointly design the precoders for both primary and secondary transmissions. This is a complex optimization problem due to the interplay between PU rate requirements, SU rate maximization, and power constraints.

Methods

The paper proposes a transmission framework that aims to maximize the SU's achievable rate while satisfying the rate requirements of the two PUs. To achieve this, they consider three practical two-way relay strategies:

  • Amplify-and-Forward (AF): The SU amplifies the received signals from the PUs and retransmits them.
  • Decode-and-Forward XOR (DF-XOR): The SU decodes the PU signals, combines them using XOR, and then retransmits the combined signal.
  • Decode-and-Forward Superposition Coding (DF-SUP): The SU decodes the PU signals, superimposes them with its own message, and then retransmits.

For each strategy, the authors formulate optimization problems to find the optimal power splitting and precoding designs. Recognizing that these problems are generally non-convex, they employ mathematical transformations and optimization tools like Semidefinite Programming (SDP) and Second-Order Cone Programming (SOCP) to find optimal solutions. In certain scenarios, closed-form solutions are also derived.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The evaluation relies on simulations with generated channel models.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Trade-off between PU and SU performance: The core of the problem is balancing the SU's desire to maximize its own data rate with the necessity of meeting the PUs' minimum rate requirements.
  • Relay strategy matters: The choice of relay strategy (AF, DF-XOR, DF-SUP) significantly impacts performance, especially under symmetric versus asymmetric PU rate requirements.
  • DF-XOR excels in symmetric scenarios: When PUs have similar rate needs, DF-XOR is preferred because it allows the SU to regenerate primary signals, avoiding noise accumulation and enabling more efficient power use for its own transmission.
  • DF-SUP shines in asymmetric scenarios: When PUs have different rate demands, DF-SUP offers more flexibility in allocating power to individual PU messages, leading to better overall SU performance.
  • Optimal SU placement is key: Simulations suggest that placing the SU relay in the middle of the two PUs generally yields the best performance.
  • MIMO antennas offer significant gains: Increasing the number of antennas at the SU relay improves performance for all strategies, reducing the gap between them and quickly achieving near-zero outage probabilities.

Key Results

  • Symmetric PU rates: The DF-XOR strategy, with optimal precoding, requires the least power for relaying, allowing the SU to transmit more of its own data.
  • Asymmetric PU rates: The DF-SUP strategy, with optimal precoding, performs best, achieving higher SU rates and lower outage probabilities for the PUs.
  • Performance comparison: Simulation results demonstrate clear performance differences between the strategies under various conditions (symmetric/asymmetric PU rates, varying SU power, relay placement, and antenna count). For instance, DF-XOR is shown to be superior in symmetric cases, while DF-SUP dominates in asymmetric ones.
  • Closed-form solutions: Optimal closed-form solutions were derived for specific cases, simplifying implementation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Channel State Information (CSI): The paper assumes that the secondary node C has access to network channel state information, including feedback from the PUs. While it notes that this is a common assumption and can be achieved in practical systems (e.g., with cooperative PUs and time-division duplex), acquiring and processing this CSI can be a practical challenge.
  • Practical Implementation of DF-XOR: While DF-XOR is considered practical, the paper acknowledges that capacity-achieving two-way relay strategies often involve complex techniques like random binning and jointly typical set decoding, which are difficult to implement in practice. The DF-XOR strategy is presented as a more feasible alternative.
  • Interference Cancellation: The paper analyzes scenarios with and without interference cancellation at the secondary receiver D. The performance gains from successful interference cancellation are highlighted.
  • Future Work: The paper implicitly suggests further exploration into more advanced relay strategies, potentially capacity-achieving ones, and investigating the impact of imperfect CSI or more complex network topologies. The optimization of power allocation and precoding for these scenarios remains an active area.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{2013optimal,
  author = {Yuan Liu (刘元) and Rui Wang and Meixia Tao and Yuan Liu},
  title = {{Optimal Linear Transceiver Designs for Cognitive Two-Way Relay Networks}},
  journal = {IEEE TSP},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1109/tsp.2012.2226452},
}
Figure