Optimal Learning via Moderate Deviations Theory

Arnab Ganguly, Tobias SutterarXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

Introduction

In many scientific and engineering domains—ranging from finance and systems biology to reinforcement learning—the core task is to estimate a cost function $J(\theta)$ from noisy, finite data. A critical component of this estimation is the construction of confidence intervals (CIs) that provide rigorous guarantees on the accuracy of the estimate. This paper introduces a novel framework for constructing "statistically optimal" CIs by leveraging Moderate Deviations Theory (MDT). By bridging the gap between standard asymptotic methods and rare-event theory, the authors develop CIs that are exponentially accurate, consistent, and significantly tighter than traditional approaches.

The Limitations of CLT and LDP

Traditionally, researchers rely on the Central Limit Theorem (CLT) to build confidence intervals. While CLT-based intervals are effective for "small" deviations near the mean, they often falter when high confidence is required. In regimes where the probability of error must decay exponentially, CLT-based heuristics can become overly conservative (too wide) or fail to provide the necessary rigorous guarantees.

Conversely, Large Deviation Principles (LDP) are designed to handle rare events and provide exponential error decay. However, LDP-based intervals often suffer from a lack of consistency—they may not "shrink" to the true value as the sample size increases, making them less useful for high-precision estimation.

The authors identify Moderate Deviations as the "sweet spot" between these two regimes. MDT describes the scaling behavior between the CLT and LDP, allowing for the construction of intervals that are both exponentially accurate and consistent.

A Systematic Construction via MDP

The proposed methodology uses the Moderate Deviation Principle (MDP) to define the uncertainty set in a Distributionally Robust Optimization (DRO) framework. Instead of choosing an arbitrary distance metric (like Wasserstein or KL-divergence), the authors demonstrate that the data-generating process's own MDP rate function, $I^M$, naturally induces the optimal uncertainty set.

Optimality Criteria

The paper defines five rigorous criteria for an "ideal" confidence interval:

  1. Exponential Accuracy: The probability of the true value falling outside the interval decays exponentially with the sample size.
  2. Minimality: The interval is as small as possible for a given error rate.
  3. Consistency: The interval width converges to zero as the sample size $T \to \infty$.
  4. Low Mischaracterization Probability: Minimizing the chance of incorrectly identifying the true parameter.
  5. Eventual UMA Property: The interval eventually becomes the Uniformly Most Accurate (UMA) interval.

Computational Tractability

A significant contribution of this work is proving that these optimal CIs are computationally tractable. Even in non-parametric settings where the parameter space is infinite-dimensional, the resulting optimization problems can often be reformulated as finite-dimensional convex programs using duality theory. For i.i.d. data, the optimal "distance" for the uncertainty set simplifies to a scaled $\chi^2$-divergence, leading to highly efficient implementations.

Empirical Performance

The theoretical advantages of the MDP-based approach are validated through simulations of stochastic processes, such as the Ornstein-Uhlenbeck (OU) process.

Comparison of CLT-based and Optimal (MDP-based) confidence intervals.

As shown in the figure above, the optimal confidence intervals (blue) are significantly narrower than the standard CLT-based intervals (red) across various sample sizes $T$. Subplot (c) explicitly highlights the reduction in interval length, demonstrating that the MDP approach provides a much tighter bound while maintaining the same required error rate. This tightness is crucial for applications where over-conservatism can lead to inefficient decision-making.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This paper provides a robust theoretical foundation for optimal learning using Moderate Deviations Theory. By satisfying key statistical optimality criteria and maintaining computational tractability, the proposed framework offers a superior alternative to traditional CLT and LDP methods.

Future work aims to extend this framework from learning function values to optimal decision-making. Applying these "optimal" CIs to fields like offline reinforcement learning could significantly improve the balance between exploration and exploitation, providing safety guarantees without the burden of excessive conservatism.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper proposes a statistically optimal approach for learning a function value using a confidence interval in a wide range of models, including general non-parametric estimation of an expected loss described as a stochastic programming problem or various SDE models. More precisely, we develop a systematic construction of highly accurate confidence intervals by using a moderate deviation principle-based approach. It is shown that the proposed confidence intervals are statistically optimal in the sense that they satisfy criteria regarding exponential accuracy, minimality, consistency, mischaracterization probability, and eventual uniformly most accurate (UMA) property. The confidence intervals suggested by this approach are expressed as solutions to robust optimization problems, where the uncertainty is expressed via the underlying moderate deviation rate function induced by the data-generating process. We demonstrate that for many models these optimization problems admit tractable reformulations as finite convex programs even when they are infinite-dimensional.
BibTeX
@misc{ganguly2023optimal,
  author = {Arnab Ganguly and Tobias Sutter},
  title = {{Optimal Learning via Moderate Deviations Theory}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2305.14496},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14496},
}
Figure