Optimal individual health insurance strategy combined investment, consumption, income and public insurance

Dongchen Li, Linyi Qian, Danping Li, Chen Lv, Kun FanJournal of Industrial and Management Optimization 2025 · DOI

Introduction

Managing personal finances involves navigating a complex landscape of steady income, volatile investments, and unpredictable life events. Among these, medical expenses represent a significant "tail risk"—rare but potentially catastrophic costs that can derail long-term financial stability. While public health insurance provides a safety net in many regions, it often leaves individuals with substantial out-of-pocket expenses. This research addresses the challenge of optimizing a personal financial strategy that integrates investment, consumption, and private health insurance to supplement public coverage.

The Problem: Mitigating Medical "Shocks"

Traditional financial models often treat investment and consumption in isolation, overlooking the profound impact of health-related financial shocks. This paper fills that gap by proposing a comprehensive wealth management framework for individuals with a steady salary and initial assets. The core question is how to optimally allocate resources between risky stock markets (which may experience sudden price jumps), daily consumption, and private insurance deductibles to maximize long-term utility while hedging against medical emergencies.

Methodology: A Stochastic Control Approach

The authors utilize a stochastic optimal control framework to model an individual's wealth dynamics. The model incorporates four primary components:

  1. Investment Portfolio: A mix of risk-free bonds and risky stocks, where stock prices are modeled with "jumps" to reflect sudden market crashes or surges.
  2. Income Stream: A salary modeled as Geometric Brownian Motion, reflecting continuous but uncertain growth.
  3. Medical Expenses: Represented as a compound Poisson process, capturing both the frequency of illness and the varying severity of costs.
  4. Hybrid Insurance: A system where public insurance covers a fixed ratio ($m$) of costs, and the individual chooses a private insurance deductible ($N$) to cover the remainder.

To determine the optimal strategy, the researchers solve the Hamilton-Jacobi-Bellman (HJB) equation using an exponential utility function. This mathematical approach yields closed-form analytical solutions for the optimal deductible, investment amount, and consumption rate.

Key Insights and Results

The study reveals several critical findings for personal financial planning:

The Decoupling Principle

A significant discovery is the independence of insurance and investment decisions. The optimal insurance deductible is found to be independent of stock market performance, and conversely, the optimal investment strategy is unaffected by specific insurance parameters. This suggests that individuals can optimize their health coverage based solely on health risks and risk tolerance, without needing to adjust for daily portfolio fluctuations.

Tail Risk and Stock Jumps

The model emphasizes that private insurance is most effective when targeting "tail risks." By selecting an optimal deductible, policyholders cap their maximum potential loss. Furthermore, the inclusion of "jumps" in stock prices significantly alters investment behavior; the presence of non-continuous price changes reduces the recommended allocation to risky assets compared to models that assume continuous price movements.

Dynamic Strategy

The optimal strategy is not static. The research shows that the optimal deductible ($N^*$) typically decreases as an individual approaches the end of their planning horizon. This implies that as people age, they should generally opt for more comprehensive insurance coverage (lower deductibles) to protect their accumulated wealth.

Limitations and Future Directions

While the model provides a robust roadmap, it relies on certain simplifications. The assumption of a constant public reimbursement rate and the use of exponential utility (Constant Absolute Risk Aversion) are areas for refinement. Future research could explore more complex public insurance tiers, different utility models like Power Utility (CRRA), and the integration of other insurance types, such as life or long-term care insurance, into a unified lifecycle optimization framework.

Conclusion

By integrating health insurance into a broader financial optimization model, this research provides a mathematical foundation for balancing immediate consumption with long-term security. The explicit formulas derived offer a practical guide for individuals to navigate the trade-offs between market risk and health-related financial vulnerability.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, we investigate the optimal investment, consumption, and insurance problem for the policyholder who participates in a type of practical hybrid insurance to mitigate the tail risks of disease expenditures, complementing public health insurance. The policyholder invests with jumps, and the consumption process is also incorporated into the personal health insurance model, which is supported by a salary income and initial assets. By employing a stochastic optimal control framework, we explicitly derive both the optimal strategy and its corresponding value function. Moreover, a verification theorem is established, and the characteristics of the optimal strategy are analyzed. Lastly, a numerical example is provided to demonstrate how the model parameters affect both the optimal strategy and the value function.
BibTeX
@article{li2025optimal,
  author = {Dongchen Li and Linyi Qian and Danping Li and Chen Lv and Kun Fan},
  title = {{Optimal individual health insurance strategy combined investment, consumption, income and public insurance}},
  journal = {Journal of Industrial and Management Optimization},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3934/jimo.2025108},
}
Figure