TL;DR
This paper proposes a novel optimal dispatching model for multiple pumped hydro storage (PHS) stations to provide flexibility to the power grid, specifically addressing the challenges posed by the increasing integration of renewable energy sources. By accurately modeling PHS operational characteristics and quantifying flexibility demand and supply, the approach aims to achieve a better balance between grid needs and PHS capabilities, leading to improved grid stability and potentially lower operational costs.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The increasing penetration of renewable energy sources (RES) like wind and solar power introduces significant uncertainty and volatility into power systems. This variability creates a need for greater "flexibility" – the ability of the power system to rapidly adjust to changes in supply and demand. Traditional power system dispatching methods, often based on fixed time periods and power outputs, struggle to adequately address this growing flexibility demand. Pumped hydro storage (PHS) is a promising resource for providing this flexibility due to its fast response and large storage capacity. However, existing PHS dispatching models often lack detail in capturing operational constraints, fail to consider the coordinated operation of multiple PHS stations across different regions, and don't explicitly optimize for flexibility balance. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a comprehensive model for optimal flexibility dispatching of multi-PHS stations that accounts for RES uncertainty and regional allocation constraints.
Methods
The paper introduces a multi-stage approach to optimize PHS flexibility dispatching:
- Credible Predictable Power (CPP) Calculation: To handle RES uncertainty, the authors first calculate the Credible Predictable Power (CPP) of renewable energy. This represents the minimum output level of RES that can be reliably expected with a certain probability (power supply guarantee rate). This is a more robust approach than simply using predicted values, as it accounts for potential underperformance.
- Flexibility Demand Definition and Calculation: The paper defines power system flexibility as the ability to cope with power changes and maintain stability. Flexibility demand is then quantified as the rate of change in the net load (load minus RES generation) over time. This allows for the calculation of both upward and downward flexibility demands at different time scales.
- Refined PHS Operation Model: A detailed operational model for PHS stations is developed, going beyond basic constraints. It incorporates factors like:
- Power generation and pumping constraints.
- Simultaneity of working conditions (generation/pumping cannot occur simultaneously).
- Condition conversion reservation time constraints (transition periods between modes).
- Preventing sudden operating condition changes.
- Specified time shutdown constraints.
- Maximum number of starts/stops per day.
- Minimum running time constraints for generation and pumping.
- Reservoir capacity constraints (upstream and downstream).
- Dynamic balance between reservoir levels.
- Water-electricity conversion coefficients.
- Flexibility Supply Model for Multi-PHS Stations: The model considers the regional allocation of flexibility supply from multiple PHS stations. It quantifies the flexibility supply of each PHS station to different regions based on allocation ratios and the station's operational state (generation or pumping).
- Optimal Flexibility Dispatching Model: The core of the paper is an optimization model that aims to minimize the difference between the total flexibility supply from PHS stations and the flexibility demand in each region. This objective function ensures that the PHS stations optimally match the grid's flexibility needs, considering regional constraints and preventing oversupply.
Datasets
The study uses a simulated regional power grid in East China for its analysis. This system includes:
- 4 regions.
- 10 PHS stations with a total of 48 PHS units and an installed capacity of 13,700 MW.
- Total installed capacity of wind power: 29,553.9 MW.
- Total installed capacity of photovoltaic: 34,922.5 MW.
- Peak daily load of the system: 344,522 MW.
The paper does not introduce new benchmark datasets but uses simulated data representative of a real-world power system.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Flexibility is Key: The paper strongly emphasizes that as RES penetration grows, flexibility becomes a critical operational requirement for power systems, not just an optional feature.
- PHS as a Flexibility Provider: PHS stations are highlighted as a crucial resource for meeting this growing flexibility demand, offering advantages over traditional thermal power units in terms of response speed and operational flexibility.
- Detailed PHS Modeling Matters: The "refined operation model" is a significant contribution. Capturing detailed constraints like transition times, minimum run times, and reservoir dynamics is essential for realistic and effective PHS dispatching for flexibility.
- Regional Allocation is Crucial: For multi-PHS systems serving multiple regions, the allocation of flexibility supply is not trivial and needs to be explicitly modeled to ensure regional demands are met efficiently.
- Balancing Supply and Demand: The core optimization objective of minimizing the difference between flexibility supply and demand is critical. Oversupply can be as problematic as undersupply, leading to inefficiencies and potentially increased costs.
Key Results
The paper demonstrates the effectiveness of its proposed optimal flexibility dispatching model through a case study on a simulated East China power grid.
- Improved Flexibility Matching: The simulation results show that the proposed model can achieve a good match between flexibility supply and demand across different regions. Figure 4b and Figure 5 illustrate how the PHS flexibility supply (represented by histograms) generally covers the flexibility demand (represented by curves).
- Reduced Reliance on Thermal Power: Case studies comparing different dispatching scenarios (thermal power only, manual PHS dispatch, and optimal PHS dispatch) show a significant reduction in the need for thermal power flexibility supply when the proposed optimal PHS dispatching model is used.
- Economic Benefits: Table 3 indicates substantial cost savings. The cost of flexibility supply in Case 3 (optimal PHS dispatch) is significantly lower (2.5680 × 10⁷ CNY) compared to Case 1 (thermal power only, 6.4033 × 10⁸ CNY) and Case 2 (manual PHS dispatch, 9.4668 × 10⁷ CNY). This highlights the economic advantage of optimizing PHS flexibility.
- Adherence to Constraints: The dispatching results generally adhere to the operational constraints of PHS stations, including power limits, start/stop limits, and reservoir capacities.
Limitations and Future Work
- Flexibility Oversupply Constraint Violation: The authors acknowledge that in some periods, the flexibility oversupply constraint was violated in the simulation results. This is attributed to the solver's automatic relaxation of strict constraints to find a feasible solution, especially when convergence accuracy is set high. While the degree of violation was deemed acceptable, it suggests potential for further refinement in constraint handling.
- Simplified Cost Model: The economic evaluation uses a simplified cost model for flexibility supply. Future work could incorporate more complex cost structures, including start-up/shut-down costs, ramp rates, and market prices.
- Uncertainty Modeling: While CPP addresses RES uncertainty, future work could explore more sophisticated methods for modeling other uncertainties, such as load forecasting errors or equipment failures.
- Dynamic Allocation Ratios: The current model uses fixed allocation ratios for PHS stations to regions. Investigating dynamic or optimized allocation ratios could further improve dispatch efficiency.
- Integration with Other Flexible Resources: The study focuses on PHS. Future research could explore the coordinated dispatch of PHS with other flexible resources like battery energy storage systems (BESS) or demand response.
Summary updated