Optimal Energy Configuration of Integrated Energy Community Considering Carbon Emission

Jiangping Liu, Jianghong Nie, Xue Cui, Peng Liu, Pingzheng Tong, Xue LiuSustainability 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes a novel optimization model for integrated energy communities (IECs) that balances economic costs with carbon emissions. By employing an ε-constraint method and linearization techniques, the model determines the optimal configuration of energy equipment, including Solid Oxide Fuel Cells (SOFCs) and energy storage systems, to minimize both operational expenses and environmental impact. The findings highlight the trade-offs between cost and emissions and demonstrate the benefits of shared energy storage systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing demand for energy, coupled with the urgent need for carbon emission reduction, has led to a growing interest in integrated energy communities (IECs). These systems aim to efficiently manage multiple energy forms (electricity, gas, cold, and heat) and leverage renewable energy sources. However, optimizing the configuration of such complex systems presents a significant challenge. Traditional approaches often focus solely on economic objectives, neglecting crucial environmental considerations like carbon emissions. Furthermore, the non-linear nature of many energy generation and conversion components makes direct optimization difficult. This paper addresses the need for a comprehensive optimization framework that simultaneously considers economic viability and environmental sustainability in IEC planning, specifically incorporating SOFCs as a key component due to their efficiency and lower emissions compared to traditional systems.

Methods

The authors developed a bi-objective optimization model for IECs, aiming to minimize both total annual operating costs and total annual carbon emissions. To handle this multi-objective problem, they employed the ε-constraint method. This technique transforms the problem into a single-objective optimization by setting the carbon emission target as a constraint (represented by ε) and optimizing for the lowest operating cost.

To overcome the non-linearities inherent in the energy system components and constraints, the model was linearized. For terms involving the product of a variable and a binary (0/1) variable, the Big-M method was used. For bilinear terms (products of two continuous variables), the McCormick relaxation method was applied. This linearization process converts the mixed-integer nonlinear programming (MINLP) problem into a mixed-integer linear programming (MILP) problem, which can then be solved using standard commercial solvers like CPLEX or GUROBI.

Datasets

The paper utilizes simulated data for typical daily energy generation coefficients of clean energy sources (photovoltaic and wind) and typical daily load demands (electricity, heat, and cooling) for three buildings. It also uses typical daily electricity purchase and on-grid prices, as well as the price of natural gas. Specific economic, technological, and environmental parameters for various energy equipment are provided in Appendix A, Table A1. No real-world historical data was explicitly mentioned as being used for training or validation, but the parameters are derived from project data and general engineering knowledge.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The ε-constraint method effectively balances cost and emissions: By adjusting the ε value (maximum allowable carbon emissions), decision-makers can navigate the trade-off between minimizing operating costs and reducing carbon footprints. Lowering ε leads to higher costs but greater environmental benefits.
  • Shared energy storage is a game-changer: The study strongly suggests that sharing power and heat storage systems across the community significantly reduces the required capacity and overall costs compared to individual building configurations. This is attributed to improved utilization rates and economies of scale.
  • SOFCs offer a viable low-carbon alternative: The inclusion of SOFCs, with their high efficiency and lower emissions, is shown to be a key strategy for reducing the reliance on natural gas and improving the environmental performance of IECs.
  • Heat storage is cost-effective but has limitations: While heat storage systems are generally cheaper than power storage systems, relying heavily on them might not be optimal for carbon emission reduction, suggesting a need for careful balancing with clean energy sources.
  • Configuration shifts towards clean energy with stricter emission targets: As emission constraints become tighter (lower ε), the energy configuration shifts away from natural gas (SOFCs) towards renewable sources like wind and solar, alongside increased power storage.

Key Results

  • The model successfully optimizes the energy configuration of an IEC, demonstrating the trade-offs between economic and environmental objectives.
  • In Scenario 1 (shared power and heat storage), minimizing total operating cost resulted in an annual cost of CNY 6.913 million, 2708 tons of carbon emissions, and an initial investment of CNY 101.21 million.
  • Minimizing carbon emissions in Scenario 1 yielded 1162 tons of carbon emissions, a higher annual operating cost of CNY 8.1564 million, and an initial investment of CNY 108 million.
  • The study showed that as ε decreases (stricter emission limits), the annual operating costs increase, but carbon emissions decrease significantly. For example, a decrease in ε from 2708 to 1162 tons led to a 15.1% increase in operating costs.
  • Shared energy storage systems (Scenario 1) demonstrated the lowest overall operating costs and initial investment compared to scenarios with individual storage systems.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simplified carbon emission consideration: The paper states that carbon emissions from the operation and maintenance of energy equipment are not considered, focusing only on grid electricity purchase and natural gas consumption. Future work could incorporate these additional emission sources.
  • Assumption of storage system capacity: The study assumes that the capacity-to-power ratio of energy storage batteries and heat storage systems is small enough to fully charge or discharge within two continuous scheduling intervals. This simplification might not hold true for all real-world scenarios.
  • Potential over-reliance on thermal systems: The paper notes that an integrated energy community might rely more on natural gas and thermal energy systems, potentially reducing the use of clean energy, which could be a disadvantage for carbon emission reduction.
  • Future work suggestions: The authors suggest that future research should focus on balancing economic costs with environmental benefits by comprehensively considering the optimal configuration of power and heat storage systems. They also imply the need for further investigation into the trade-offs associated with different energy allocation strategies.

Summary updated

Abstract

An integrated energy community with a distributed utilization of renewable energy and complementary electricity–gas–cold–heat integrated energy will play an important role in energy conservation and emission reduction. In addition, compared with traditional thermoelectric power equipment, solid oxide fuel cells have many advantages, such as a high energy utilization rate, good waste heat quality, and low carbon emissions. Therefore, the SOFC-based multi-energy and energy storage sharing operation model of an integrated energy community with an electricity–gas–cooling–heat integrated energy system is constructed, and a bi-objective optimal configuration model considering the carbon emission index is established. Considering the economic objective of the smallest annual total operating cost as the most important objective in optimizing the planning model, the ε-constraint method is used to transform the environmental objective function with the smallest annual total carbon emission into a constraint condition under the decision making of an economic single objective function, and then the planning model is linearized and solved by using the Big-M method and the McCormick relaxation method. By calculating and analyzing the energy allocation results in five scenarios, the effectiveness and rationality of the model built in this article are verified. At the same time, the calculation example analysis results show that as the ε value decreases, the energy configuration of the integrated energy community will shift from natural gas to clean energy. From this perspective, the energy equipment configuration and operating costs will increase. However, the heat storage system and power storage system sharing can effectively reduce the energy allocation capacity and costs.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2024optimal,
  author = {Jiangping Liu and Jianghong Nie and Xue Cui and Peng Liu and Pingzheng Tong and Xue Liu},
  title = {{Optimal Energy Configuration of Integrated Energy Community Considering Carbon Emission}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/su16020728},
}
Figure