Optimal Design of Passive Control of Space Tethered-Net Capture System

Qingquan Chen, Genghui Li, Qingbin Zhang, Qiangang Tang, Guobin ZhangIEEE Access 2019 · DOI

Abstract

Active Debris Removal (ADR) is becoming a critical necessity as low Earth orbit (LEO) becomes increasingly congested. Among various ADR technologies, space tethered-nets are highly regarded for being lightweight, compact, and fault-tolerant. However, these systems suffer from a significant mechanical drawback: the "rebound" effect, where the net rapidly re-contracts after reaching its maximum deployment area, severely narrowing the capture window. This paper proposes a novel, passive control mechanism using Energy Dissipation Bands (EDBs) to absorb excess kinetic energy and stabilize the net's expansion. By employing a surrogate-assisted optimization algorithm, the study demonstrates a three-fold increase in the net's effective working distance and a substantial reduction in internal mechanical stress.

Introduction

As the density of orbital debris grows, the risk of the Kessler Syndrome—a chain reaction of collisions—threatens the long-term viability of space operations. Tethered-net systems are a frontrunner for capturing non-cooperative targets like defunct satellites. These systems typically involve a tug-satellite that launches a net toward a target to secure it for de-orbiting or transfer to a graveyard orbit.

Conceptual overview of a space tethered-net system capturing orbital debris and transferring it to a graveyard orbit.

Despite their advantages, the deployment physics of these nets are complex. When pilot masses pull the net open, the elastic energy stored in the mesh causes a violent rebound once the maximum area is reached. This contraction happens so quickly that the "effective working distance"— the span during which the net remains at least 60% open—is often too short for reliable capture. While active control systems (like thrusters) have been proposed to solve this, they add significant weight and complexity. This research focuses on a simpler, passive alternative.

Passive Control via Energy Dissipation Bands (EDBs)

The researchers introduced Energy Dissipation Bands (EDBs) as a mechanical solution to the rebound problem. These bands are installed along the outer contour lines of the net and function as one-way mechanical dampers.

The EDB Mechanism

An EDB consists of a folded high-strength band held together by sequential stitching. As the net expands, the tension pulls the band straight, forcing the stitches to stretch and break one by one. This process converts the kinetic energy of the deployment into work required to rupture the stitches, effectively damping the system without the need for electronics or fuel.

Internal configuration of the deployment cabin, highlighting the placement of the Energy Dissipation Bands (EDBs) and pilot masses.

Methods and Optimization

To evaluate the system, the authors developed a multibody dynamic model treating the net as a network of "semi-spring dampers." These components only exert force when under tension, mimicking the behavior of flexible tethers. The model was validated using physical tensile tests on a motion table to ensure the simulated EDB behavior matched reality.

Optimization Strategy

The primary challenge lay in determining the optimal stiffness of the EDBs. A band that is too stiff prevents the net from opening fully, while one that is too loose fails to stop the rebound. Because each physics simulation takes approximately five minutes and the design space is non-differentiable, the authors used a Radial Basis Function assisted optimization method with Batch infill Sampling (RBFBS). This machine learning-based approach creates a computationally efficient surrogate model of the simulation, allowing the team to find the optimal parameters with far fewer expensive function evaluations.

Key Results

The application of optimized EDBs yielded dramatic improvements in the performance of the capture system:

  • Extended Capture Window: The effective working distance increased by 3.27 times compared to an uncontrolled net. The optimized net maintained its shape for approximately 120 meters of travel.
  • Stress Mitigation: The peak internal force within the net dropped from 565.9 N to 443.2 N, a 21.7% reduction. This smoothing of the deployment forces reduces the risk of material failure and allows for the use of lighter tether materials.
  • Design Efficiency: The RBFBS algorithm proved highly effective at navigating the complex trade-offs between maximum expansion area and deployment stability.

Conclusion and Future Work

This study demonstrates that passive mechanical components can solve complex orbital mechanics challenges more efficiently than active control systems. While the EDBs slightly reduce the absolute maximum area the net can reach, the trade-off is a vastly more stable and reliable capture tool.

Future research will explore expanding the use of EDBs to internal knots within the net and optimizing the initial folding patterns within the launcher to further refine the deployment geometry. These advancements bring the goal of a reliable, low-cost orbital debris cleanup system closer to reality.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{chen2019optimal,
  author = {Qingquan Chen and Genghui Li and Qingbin Zhang and Qiangang Tang and Guobin Zhang},
  title = {{Optimal Design of Passive Control of Space Tethered-Net Capture System}},
  journal = {IEEE Access},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1109/access.2019.2939518},
}
Figure