Optimal Decisions in Green, Low-Carbon Supply Chain Considering the Competition and Cooperation Relationships between Different Types of Manufacturers

Xiaoqing Zhang, Wantong Chen, Min Wang, Dalin ZhangInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates optimal strategies for green, low-carbon supply chains involving manufacturers, remanufacturers, and retailers. By modeling competition and cooperation under various decision-making frameworks, it reveals that increased remanufacturing cost savings boost recycling and overall profits, while manufacturer-retailer cooperation yields the highest greenness and recycling efforts.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing global concern over environmental pollution and resource depletion has driven a shift towards green supply chain management. While existing research has explored selling and collection channel strategies in green supply chains, there's a notable gap in understanding the interplay of competition and cooperation among different types of manufacturers (specifically, green manufacturers and green remanufacturers) within a green, low-carbon context. This paper aims to fill this gap by analyzing optimal decision-making for a supply chain comprising a green manufacturer, a green remanufacturer, and a retailer, considering various cooperative and competitive scenarios.

Methods

The study employs game theory and backward induction to model and solve the decision-making problems within four distinct supply chain structures:

  • Centralized Decision-Making Model (Model C): All members form an alliance, making joint decisions on recycling effort, greenness levels, and prices.
  • Decentralized Decision-Making Model (Model D): A Stackelberg game where the manufacturer and remanufacturer are leaders, and the retailer is a follower. Decisions are made sequentially.
  • Manufacturer-Remanufacturer Cooperative Model (Model M-M): The manufacturer and remanufacturer form an alliance, with the retailer acting independently.
  • Manufacturer-Retailer Cooperative Model (Model R-M-M): The manufacturer and retailer form an alliance, and the remanufacturer also cooperates with the retailer.

The core of the methodology involves setting up profit maximization functions for each entity or alliance and deriving equilibrium solutions for recycling effort, product greenness, and retail prices under these different models.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study uses a theoretical model with defined parameters rather than empirical datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Remanufacturing Savings Drive Green Efforts: Increased cost savings from remanufacturing (δ) not only incentivize more recycling effort and production of remanufactured goods but also positively impact the total supply chain profit. This highlights the economic viability of circular economy principles.
  • Cooperation is Key for Greenness: The highest levels of recycling effort and product greenness (for both new and remanufactured products) are achieved when there's a cooperative relationship between the manufacturer and the retailer (Model R-M-M). This suggests that aligning incentives between these key players is crucial for maximizing environmental benefits.
  • Centralization Maximizes Profit: The centralized decision-making model (Model C) yields the highest total supply chain profit, underscoring the efficiency gains from unified strategic planning. Conversely, the manufacturer-remanufacturer cooperative model (Model M-M) results in the lowest total profit, possibly due to less integrated decision-making.
  • Recycling Costs and Green Input Costs Have Negative Impacts: Higher recycling costs (θ) and green input costs (λ) generally lead to reduced recycling effort, lower greenness levels for remanufactured products, and decreased overall supply chain profits. This emphasizes the importance of managing these costs for sustainable operations.
  • Trade-offs Exist: While remanufacturing cost savings benefit remanufactured products, they can sometimes lead to a decrease in the greenness of new products, suggesting a potential trade-off that needs careful management.

Key Results

The paper derives equilibrium solutions for recycling effort ($e^*$), greenness levels ($g_n^*$, $g_r^*$), and retail prices ($p_n^*$, $p_r^*$) under the four models. Key findings from the analysis include:

  • Impact of Remanufacturing Cost Savings (δ): Generally, an increase in δ leads to higher recycling effort and remanufactured product greenness, and higher total profits. However, it can decrease the greenness of new products in some models.
  • Impact of Recycling Cost Coefficient (θ): An increase in θ leads to decreased recycling effort and remanufactured product greenness, and lower total profits. It can, however, increase the greenness of new products in some scenarios.
  • Impact of Green Input Cost Coefficient (λ): Numerical analysis shows that increasing λ leads to decreased optimal recovery effort levels and greenness levels across all models. This is attributed to decision-makers reducing recycling efforts to manage higher green input costs.
  • Model Comparison: Model C (centralized) consistently shows the highest total profit. Model R-M-M (manufacturer-retailer cooperation) demonstrates the highest greenness and recycling effort levels.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their study focuses on a specific supply chain structure (one manufacturer, one remanufacturer, one retailer) and a particular set of decision-making models. Future research directions suggested include:

  • Retailer as Stackelberg Leader: Investigating scenarios where the retailer takes the leadership role in the supply chain.
  • Integrated Manufacturer-Remanufacturer: Considering a situation where a single entity acts as both the manufacturer of new products and the recycler/remanufacturer of old ones, creating a more complex cooperative and competitive dynamic.
  • Exploring Other Cooperation Structures: Analyzing different alliance formations and their impact on optimal decisions.
  • Incorporating Additional Factors: Future work could also explore the impact of other factors like consumer preferences for recycled content, government regulations beyond carbon emissions, and supply chain disruptions.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this study, we built a green, low-carbon supply chain including one green manufacturer, one green remanufacturer and one retailer in which the manufacturer produces new, green, low-carbon products and the remanufacturer recycles and remanufactures the green, low-carbon products. We assumed the manufacturer to be the Stackelberg leader and the remanufacturer and the retailer to be Stackelberg followers. The game model was solved using backward induction. We discuss the optimal operation strategies for green, low-carbon supply-chain members in a centralized decision-making model, decentralized decision-making model, manufacturer-remanufacturer cooperative decision-making model and manufacturer-retailer cooperative decision-making model. Furthermore, we discuss the impacts of the unit cost savings for remanufacturing, the recovery cost coefficient and the green improvement cost coefficient on the green supply-chain members' optimal decision and profits. The results show that increased unit cost savings from remanufacturing can increase the total profit of the supply chain and promote the recycling and remanufacturing of waste products. Moreover, the total profit of the green, low-carbon supply chain is the highest in the centralized decision-making model and lowest in the manufacturer cooperative decision-making model. When there is a cooperation relationship between the manufacturer and the retailer, the optimal recycling effort level and the optimal greenness level for the new product and the remanufactured product are the highest.
BibTeX
@article{zhang2022optimal,
  author = {Xiaoqing Zhang and Wantong Chen and Min Wang and Dalin Zhang},
  title = {{Optimal Decisions in Green, Low-Carbon Supply Chain Considering the Competition and Cooperation Relationships between Different Types of Manufacturers}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph192215111},
}
Figure