Optimal Contextual Pricing and Extensions

Allen Liu, Renato Paes Leme, Jon SchneiderSODA 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces novel algorithms for contextual pricing and search problems, achieving near-optimal regret bounds by employing a new geometric technique based on the Steiner polynomial. The work extends to more general learning settings with binary feedback and noisy observations, offering significant improvements over prior methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the problem of contextual pricing and search, where a seller (or learner) repeatedly faces items described by feature vectors and must decide on a price (or guess). The seller only observes whether a purchase occurs, and the goal is to maximize revenue (or minimize regret) by learning the buyer's hidden valuation. The core challenge lies in efficiently learning this valuation from limited, binary feedback, especially when the valuation is a linear function of the features. Existing algorithms struggled to achieve optimal regret, particularly in the pricing scenario. The paper also generalizes this to broader online learning problems with binary feedback and explores the impact of noisy feedback.

Methods

The paper's key innovation is the use of a Steiner polynomial as a potential function. This geometric object, related to intrinsic volumes, allows the authors to bound the volume of sets of consistent hypotheses.

  • Multiscale Steiner Potential: The core technique involves maintaining a set of "approximately valid" hypotheses and using the Steiner polynomial to track how this set shrinks. By evaluating the Steiner polynomial at different scales (controlled by the "width" of the hypothesis set), the algorithm can make progress by effectively reducing the volume of the consistent set. This is applied to both symmetric loss (where the guess is compared to the true value) and pricing loss (where revenue is considered).
  • Adaptive Scaling and Randomized Cuts: For more general settings and to achieve constant regret in T, the authors introduce adaptive scaling, which adjusts the granularity of the analysis based on the current situation. They also use randomized guesses to ensure progress with high probability.
  • Generalization to Hypothesis Classes: The framework is extended to arbitrary hypothesis classes by using the covering dimension as a measure of complexity. The Steiner potential idea is generalized to an "e-net" of the hypothesis class.
  • Noisy Feedback: For noisy feedback, the approach shifts to maintaining weights over hypotheses and using a Bayesian inference-inspired update rule. This is combined with multi-scale discretization for the contextual search problem.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The problem is framed in a theoretical, adversarial setting.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Steiner Polynomial as a Potential Function: The paper demonstrates a powerful new way to use geometric concepts (Steiner polynomial, intrinsic volumes) to analyze and design algorithms for online learning problems with binary feedback. This provides a more elegant and efficient approach than previous methods.
  • Bridging Theory and Practice: The algorithms achieve near-optimal regret bounds, matching theoretical lower bounds up to logarithmic factors, which is a significant theoretical achievement.
  • Generalizability: The techniques are shown to be applicable beyond linear models to more general hypothesis classes, with regret bounds depending on the covering dimension.
  • Impact of Noise: The paper highlights how noisy feedback fundamentally changes the learning approach, requiring probabilistic methods and careful weight updates, but still allows for efficient learning.

Key Results

  • Contextual Pricing: An algorithm with $O(d \log \log T + d \log d)$ regret is presented, matching the known lower bound up to a $\log d$ factor.
  • Symmetric Contextual Search: An algorithm with $O(d \log d)$ regret is achieved, also near-optimal.
  • General Hypothesis Classes: An algorithm with $O(d^2)$ regret is provided, where $d$ is the covering dimension of the hypothesis class. This improves previous bounds for sparse linear contextual search.
  • Noisy Feedback: An $O(d \log T)$ regret algorithm is given for general hypothesis classes, and a $O(\text{poly}(d))$ regret algorithm (independent of $T$) is developed for noisy linear contextual search.
  • Impossibility Result: For the pricing loss, it's shown that polynomial regret in covering dimension is impossible, highlighting a fundamental difference in learnability compared to symmetric loss.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Efficiency: While the algorithms are theoretically efficient, the paper notes that implementing the general $O(\text{poly}(d))$ algorithm for noisy contextual search might require efficient sampling from complex distributions, which is an open question.
  • Pricing Loss Impossibility: The impossibility result for pricing loss suggests that achieving strong regret bounds for this specific loss function might require different theoretical tools or might be inherently harder than for symmetric loss.
  • Tree Dimension vs. Covering Dimension: The paper explores the relationship between tree dimension and covering dimension, suggesting further research into their connections and applications.
  • Full Feedback Analysis: The paper introduces "tree dimension" for full feedback settings and shows its connection to optimal regret, posing an interesting direction for future work.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2021optimal,
  author = {Allen Liu and Renato Paes Leme and Jon Schneider},
  title = {{Optimal Contextual Pricing and Extensions}},
  booktitle = {SODA},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1137/1.9781611976465.66},
}
Figure