Optimal Allocation Model for Water Resources Coupled with Ecological Value Factors—A Case Study of Dalian, China

Jie Zhang, Chong Meng, Shugang Hu, Wei LiWater 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces an innovative Inexact Two-Stage Stochastic Programming (ITSP) model to optimize water resource allocation in Dalian, China. By integrating ecological value factors into traditional allocation models, it aims to achieve a more sustainable balance between socio-economic development and environmental health, especially crucial in water-scarce regions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Water scarcity is a growing global challenge, exacerbated by increasing demand from industrial, municipal, and agricultural sectors, alongside the critical need to preserve ecological systems. Traditional water resource allocation models often prioritize economic benefits, neglecting the intrinsic and instrumental value of water ecosystems. This oversight can lead to suboptimal decisions that harm environmental health and, in the long run, undermine sustainable development. The study specifically addresses this gap by developing a model that explicitly incorporates ecological value factors into the optimization process, aiming for a holistic approach to water management in a water-stressed urban environment like Dalian.

Methods

The core of this research is the development and application of an Inexact Two-Stage Stochastic Programming (ITSP) model. This approach is designed to handle uncertainties inherent in water resource management, such as variable water availability and environmental carrying capacities, which are represented by different flow scenarios (low, medium, high) with associated probabilities.

The ITSP model combines:

  • Interval-Parameter Programming (IPP): This allows for the representation of uncertain parameters (like water availability or demand) as intervals rather than precise values, reflecting real-world variability.
  • Two-Stage Stochastic Programming (TSP): This framework allows for decisions to be made in two stages. An initial decision is made under uncertainty, and a second decision is made after the uncertain outcomes (scenarios) are revealed, aiming to minimize penalties for any infeasibilities.

A key novelty of this work is the coupling of ecological value factors into the ITSP framework. These factors include the value of water purification, hydrological regulation, water conservation, and research/cultural value of wetlands and rivers. The model formulates objective functions that consider both water utilization benefits (economic) and ecological benefits, alongside costs associated with water shortage penalties and wastewater treatment. The model is solved by transforming it into two deterministic sub-models (upper and lower bound objectives) using an interactive algorithm.

Datasets

The study utilizes data specific to Dalian, China, for its case study. This includes:

  • Regional water resource consumption data from the past 10 years.
  • Developmental planning data for the region.
  • Data on wetland and river areas.
  • Information on pollutant emissions (COD, NH3-N, Tp) from industrial, municipal, and agricultural sectors.
  • Water environmental functions and water resource utilization data.

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, the study leverages existing regional data to parameterize and validate its model.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Ecological Value is a Critical Driver: The study strongly emphasizes that ecological value factors are not merely secondary considerations but are significant drivers in determining optimal water resource allocation. Ignoring them leads to suboptimal outcomes.
  • Synergy Between Economy and Ecology: The ITSP model successfully demonstrates how to achieve coordinated development by balancing socio-economic benefits with ecological benefits, fostering a synergistic relationship rather than a trade-off.
  • Uncertainty Management is Key: The use of ITSP effectively addresses the inherent uncertainties in water availability and demand, providing a more robust and realistic allocation plan compared to deterministic models.
  • Dalian's Water Stress: The case study highlights Dalian's significant water scarcity and the complex interplay of demands from various sectors, underscoring the need for sophisticated management strategies.
  • Pollutant Reduction Potential: The optimal allocation scheme not only manages water quantity but also shows a potential for reducing pollutant emissions, contributing to improved water quality.

Key Results

  • The ITSP model successfully determined optimal water resource allocation schemes for Dalian across different planning periods and scenarios, considering both economic and ecological factors.
  • Results indicated that water resource carrying capacity, ecological value factors, and water environmental capacity are the primary determinants of optimal allocation.
  • The study found that the optimal allocation strategy leads to a coordinated development of socio-economic goals and environmental quality improvement.
  • Analysis of pollutant emissions showed a downward trend over time under the proposed allocation scheme, with some exceptions in specific areas for certain pollutants (e.g., Tp in some municipal sectors), suggesting areas for targeted intervention.
  • The ecological regulation service value for Dalian's water ecosystem showed an increasing trend, from approximately 980,900 × 10⁴ CNY in period 1 to 999,700 × 10⁴ CNY in period 3, indicating improved ecosystem health and value.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Decision-Making Risks: While the ITSP model provides optimal schedules and adjustments for different scenarios, it does not explicitly measure decision-making risks.
  • Climate Change Impact: The model does not fully assess the impact of climate change on water resource availability.
  • Water Source Diversity: The current model does not extensively evaluate the influence of different water sources on the allocation.

Future work could focus on incorporating these aspects, such as developing models that explicitly account for climate change projections and a more detailed analysis of various water source types. Further refinement of the model to better quantify decision-making risks would also be beneficial.

Summary updated

Abstract

The surface water ecosystem has important ecological value and plays an important supporting and guarantee role in the sustainable development of human society. In this study, an inexact two-stage stochastic programming (ITSP) model was developed for supporting water resource allocation for the four main water sectors (industry, municipal, agriculture, and ecological environment). Several scenarios corresponding to different flow patterns, which reflect different probabilities of water resource availability and environmental carrying capacity, were examined. On the basis of traditional water resource allocation, this model adds consideration of ecological value factors, which is conducive to the synergistic efficiency of socio-economic and ecological water consumption. Results revealed that the water resource carrying capacity, ecological value factors, and water environmental capacity are the main factors affecting the optimal allocation of water resources. Furthermore, the optimal allocation scheme for water resources coupled with ecological value factors were determined to realize the coordinated development of social economic benefits and ecological benefits. The current study findings are of great significance for establishing a rational water resource management system for water resource exploitation and utilization. This model can be used to guide various departments in Dalian to formulate an optimal water resources allocation scheme by considering ecological value factors, and provide a basis for realizing the coordinated development of Dalian’s socio-economic development goals, water resource utilization, and environmental quality improvement.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2022optimal,
  author = {Jie Zhang and Chong Meng and Shugang Hu and Wei Li},
  title = {{Optimal Allocation Model for Water Resources Coupled with Ecological Value Factors—A Case Study of Dalian, China}},
  booktitle = {Water},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/w14020266},
}
Figure